Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Making Development Agents

Participation as Boundary Object in International Development

Bibliographic Data

ID20302004
AuthorsM Green (0000-0002-9800-2738, Institute for Social Anthropology, corresponding author)
Year2010
Volume46
Issue7
Pages1240-1263
Publication date2010-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueThe Journal of Development Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-0388 • E-ISSN: 1743-9140
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/00220388.2010.487099
OpenAlexW2077043025
LanguageEN
Citations received41
References cited64

Despite high transaction and financial costs participatory approaches to development are now standardised across a range of organisations internationally. Participatory planning in various forms is widely used in donor funded local government projects worldwide. This article critically explores the reasons for the continued popularity of participatory approaches. Using examples of cognate participatory processes in Tanzania I show how the outputs of participatory approaches do not justify their continued popularity for development stakeholders. Analytical frameworks from science studies on the social process of collaboration provide insights into the persistence of participatory forms. Participation operates as a boundary object enabling diverse stakeholders to temporarily align themselves around a common project for the purpose of development implementation. © 2010 Taylor & Francis

Boundary object · Business · Citizen journalism · Participatory development · Political science · Popularity · Process (computing) · Process management · Public relations · Social science · Sociology · Transaction cost · Community Development and Social Impact · Computer Science · Finance · Foucault, Power, and Ethics · International Development and Aid · Public Administration

  • Opening up creative resources

    Open Access•Marielle Schuurman, Barbara Groot et al.•Educational Action Research•2025

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Hannah Brown, Ruth J Prince•African Studies Review•2015

  • The Politics of Poverty

    Open Access•F Becker•Politics of Poverty•2019

  • Thinking Like a Climate

    Open Access•Hannah Knox•Thinking Like a Climate•2020

  • Boundary Objects

    Open Access•Barbara Groot, Tineke Abma•International Journal of…•2021

  • Lessons in a bottle

    Open Access•Daniel Abrahams•Journal of International…•2022

  • Visualizing Energy Participation

    Open Access•Jorge Morales-Guerrero, Darshan M A Karwat•Energy Research & Social Science•2020

  • Boundary Objects and Global Consensus

    Noella J Gray, Rebecca L Gruby et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2014

  • After the MDGs

    M Green•Globalizations•2015

  • Co-designing non-hierarchical community arts research

    Open Access•Peter Gilchrist, Paul Gilchrist et al.•Qualitative Research Journal•2015

  • Identifying the Evaluative Impulse in Local Culture

    Open Access•Peter Easton, Peter B Easton•American Journal of Evaluation•2012

  • Three Challenges for Communication and Global Social Change

    Open Access•Silvio Waisbord•Communication Theory•2015

  • Development and Participation

    Open Access•Juan Telleria•European Journal of Development…•2020

  • The significance of student voice

    Hanna Posti-Ahokas, Elina Lehtomäki•Gender and Education•2014

  • Towards a critical geography of resettlement

    Open Access•Sarah Rogers, Brooke Wilmsen•Progress in Human Geography•2019

  • Mosaic glimpses

    Open Access•Jean-Philippe Venot, C B Jensen et al.•World Development•2022

  • Gender and participation in community based adaptation

    Open Access•Hannah Patnaik•World Development•2021

  • Organizational Communications in Developing Ethnic Tourism

    Ying Hu, Phyllis B Ngai et al.•Tourism Culture & Communication•2021

  • The Government of Chronic Poverty

    Samuel Hickey, Sam Hickey•The Journal of Development Studies•2010

  • Social Enterprise, Capabilities and Development Paradigms

    Margherita Scarlato•The Journal of Development Studies•2013

  • State Engagement with Farmer-led Irrigation Development

    Open Access•Chris De Bont, Gert Jan Veldwisch•The Journal of Development Studies•2020

  • After the consent

    Open Access•Kei Otsuki, Dakcha Achá et al.•Geoforum•2016

  • We have big ideas, but only small words’

    Open Access•Shona Loong•Geoforum•2023

  • "Caminante no hay [un solo] camino, se hace camino al andar"

    Open Access•Arely A Paredes Chi, María Teresa Castillo Burguete•Revista Colombiana de Sociología•2018

  • Reflexivity in Participatory Development

    Kei Otsuki•Human Organization•2012

  • Finding “What Works”

    Open Access•Dörte Bemme•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2019

  • Evaluating the impacts of boundary-spanning activities at the interface of environmental science and policy

    Open Access•Stephen Posner, Stephen M Posner et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2019

  • The travel of global ideas of waste management. The case of Managua and its informal settlements

    María José Zapata Campos, Patrik Zapata•Habitat International•2014

  • The obscured racialisation of humanitarian design

    Open Access•Mahmoud Keshavarz•Third World Quarterly•2025

  • Using Geodesign as a boundary management process for planning nature-based solutions in river landscapes

    Open Access•Sarah Gottwald, Jana Brenner et al.•AMBIO•2021

  • Demonstrating development

    Open Access•Hannah Brown, M Green•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2017

  • Continuity or Disruption? Rethinking Engagement in Multi-Stakeholder Forums Through the Lens of Boundary Objects

    Fernando Galeana•The Journal of Development Studies•2025

  • Technically speaking

    Open Access•Vyoma Dhar Sharma•Economy and Society•2024

  • Saving, Spending, and Future-Making

    Open Access•M Green, Uma Kothari et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2012

  • Negotiating interdependence and anxiety in community economies

    Open Access•Gradon Diprose•Environment and Planning A…•2016

  • Community policing and the politics of local development in Tanzania

    Open Access•Charlotte Cro, Charlotte Cross•The Journal of Modern African…•2014

  • Anticipatory development

    Open Access•M Green•Critique of Anthropology•2012

  • Urban mosquitoes, situational publics, and the pursuit of interspecies separation in Dar es Salaam

    Open Access•Ann H Kelly, Javier Lezaun•American Ethnologist•2014

  • Too Much Democracy in All the Wrong Places

    C M Kelty•Current Anthropology•2017

  • Obscuring and Revealing

    Open Access•F Becker•African Studies Review•2015

  • At the Service of Community Development

    Open Access•Hannah Brown, M Green•African Studies Review•2015

  • Purity and Danger

    Mary Douglas•Purity and Danger•2003

  • Rural Development

    Robert Chambers, Robert G Chambers•Rural Development•2014

  • No Condition Is Permanent

    Sara S Berry, Sara Berry•No Condition Is Permanent•1993

  • Understanding Agency in Collective Action

    Frances Cleaver•Journal of Human Development•2007

  • Participation and accountability in development management

    E A Brett•The Journal of Development Studies•2003

  • The Depoliticisation of Development and the Democratisation of Politics in Tanzania

    Siri Lange•The Journal of Development Studies•2008

  • Sorting Things Out

    G C Bowker, Susan Leigh Star•Sorting Things Out•1999

  • Powers of Freedom

    Open Access•Nikolas Rose, Nikolas S Rose•Powers of Freedom•1999

  • A different kind of political realist

    Open Access•N Marres•Area•2007

  • Participatory Rural Appraisal as Qualitative Research

    J R Campbell•Human Organization•2001

  • Historical perspectives on participation in development

    A Cornwall•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2006

  • A critical appraisal of participatory methods in development research

    J R Campbell, John Campbell•International Journal of Social…•2002

  • The Personal is Political

    Caitlin Cahill•Gender Place & Culture•2007

  • Development critiques in the 1990s

    Open Access•Gillian Hart•Progress in Human Geography•2001

  • Institutional Ecology, `Translations' and Boundary Objects

    Open Access•Susan Leigh Star, James Griesemer et al.•Social Studies of Science•1989

  • Scientific Work and Uncertainty

    Open Access•Susan Leigh Star•Social Studies of Science•1985

  • Teach a Man to Fish”

    Open Access•Ann Swidler, Susan Watkins et al.•World Development•2009

  • From correlates and characteristics to causes

    Open Access•M Green, David Hulme•World Development•2005

  • Tanzania

    Open Access•Arrigo Pallotti•Review of African Political Economy•2008

  • Introduction

    Open Access•A Cornwall•IDS Bulletin•2004

  • Introduction

    Open Access•A Cornwall, Elizabeth Harrison et al.•IDS Bulletin•2004

  • Participatory development and empowerment

    Giles Mohan, Kristian Stokke•Third World Quarterly•2000

  • Scholarly Dialogues and Participatory Action Research

    Open Access•Jean M Bartunekl•Human Relations•1993

  • From margins to center? The development and purpose of participatory research

    Open Access•Budd L Hall•The American Sociologist•1992

  • Globalisation in practice

    Open Access•John Law, A Mol•Geoforum•2006

  • Reflections on participatory research

    Open Access•Rachel Pain, Paul Francis et al.•Area•2003

  • Purity and Danger

    Douglas M Staff, Mary Douglas et al.•Purity and Danger•2013

  • After Method

    John Law•After Method•2004

  • Community Participation the Tanzanian Way

    Rebecca Marsland•Oxford Development Studies•2006

  • The Politics of the Governed

    P Chatterjee

  • Seeing the State

    Open Access•Stuart Corbridge, Glyn Williams et al.•Seeing the State•2005

  • The devil's in the theory

    Open Access•Ilan Kapoor•Third World Quarterly•2002

  • Rethinking 'Citizenship' in the Postcolony

    Steven Robin, Steven Robins et al.•Third World Quarterly•2008

  • Evaluating participatory development

    Glyn Williams•Third World Quarterly•2004

  • The origins and practice of participatory rural appraisal

    Open Access•Robert Chambers•World Development•1994

  • From the global to the local? Governance and development at the local level

    Open Access•Gail Harrison, Graham Harrison•The Journal of Modern African…•2008

  • Authority, Gender and Knowledge

    Open Access•David Mosse•Development and Change•1994

  • Framing participation

    Daniel Craig, David Craig et al.•Development in Practice•1997

  • Participation

    Pablo Alejandro Leal•Development in Practice•2007

  • What is participatory research

    Open Access•A Cornwall, Rachel Jewkes•Social Science & Medicine•1995

  • We Must Run While Others Walk

    Open Access•Michael Jennings•The Journal of Modern African…•2003

  • Choosing' Participatory Research

    Open Access•Fran Klodawsky•Environment and Planning A…•2007

  • Relocating Participation within a Radical Politics of Development

    Open Access•Samuel Hickey, Sam Hickey et al.•Development and Change•2005

  • Community, Citizenship, and the third Way

    Open Access•Nikolas Rose•American Behavioral Scientist•2000

  • Epistemic Cultures

    Karin Knorr Cetina, K Knorr-Cetina•Epistemic Cultures•1999

  • Local Participation in National Politics

    Open Access•Peter Rigby•Africa•1977

  • Doing development and writing culture

    Open Access•M Green•Anthropological Theory•2009

  • Participatory Research and the Philosophy of Social Science

    Open Access•Mary Van Der Riet•Qualitative Inquiry•2008

  • Globalizing Development in Tanzania

    Open Access•M Green•Critique of Anthropology•2003

  • Participatory Development and the Appropriation of Agency in Southern Tanzania

    Open Access•M Green•Critique of Anthropology•2000

  • Retheorizing Empowerment-through-Participation as a Performance in Space

    Mike Kesby•Signs: Journal of Women in…•2005

  • Practices of assemblage and community forest management

    Tania Murray Li•Economy and Society•2007

  • Local community on trial

    Ash Amin•Economy and Society•2005

  • On mediators

    Thomas Osborne•Economy and Society•2004

  • High on Modernity? Explaining the Failings of Tanzanian Villagisation1

    Leander Schneider•African Studies•2007

  • Inventing Social Categories Through Place

    Open Access•Stacy Leigh Pigg•Comparative Studies in Society…•1992

  • The Bureaucracy and the Bourgeoisie

    Open Access•Joel Samoff•Comparative Studies in Society…•1979

Unique citing works41
Citations per year2,56
Citation span2010 - 2025 (16)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 39
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae