A comparison of direct versus self-report measures for assessing physical activity in adults: A systematic review

Stéphanie A Prince; Kristi B Adamo; Meghan Hamel; Jill Hardt; Sarah Connor Gorber; Mark Tremblay

doi:10.1186/1479-5868-5-56

A comparison of direct versus self-report measures for assessing physical activity in adults

A systematic review

Dados Bibliográficos

ID	23322113
Autores	Stéphanie A Prince (0000-0001-6729-5649), Kristi B Adamo (0000-0001-7925-1889), Meghan Hamel, Jill Hardt, Sarah Connor Gorber (0000-0001-9240-7294), Mark Tremblay
Ano	2008
Volume	5
Fascículo	1
Páginas	56
Data de publicação	2008-01-01
Peer Reviewed	Sim
Open Access	Sim
Tipo	ARTICLE
Periódico	International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity (JOURNAL)
Identificadores do periódico	ISSN: 1479-5868 • E-ISSN: 1479-5868
Editora	Springer Science and Business Media LLC (PUBLISHER)
DOI	10.1186/1479-5868-5-56
PMID	18990237
PMCID	PMC2588639
Idioma	EN
Citações recebidas	316

Physical activity levels and associated factors among Rohingya older adults living in the refugee camp in Bangladesh
Open AccessSabuj Kanti Mistry, Afsana Anwar et al.PLOS Global Public Health2026
Predictors of long-term resistance exercise adherence
Open AccessFederica Conti, Thiago Marzagão et al.Frontiers in Sports and Active…2026
The forgotten guidelines
Open AccessTessa Strain, Claire Fitzsimons et al.BMC Public Health2016
Technically measured compositional physical work demands and prospective register-based sickness absence (Podesa)
Open AccessSofie Dencker-Larsen, Charlotte Lund Rasmussen et al.BMC Public Health2019
Pda
Open AccessJennifer M Duncan, E Amy Janke et al.BMC Public Health2011
Clustering of risk factors for non-communicable disease and healthcare expenditure in employees with private health insurance presenting for health risk appraisal
Open AccessTracy L Kolbe-Alexander, Tracy Kolbe‐Alexander et al.BMC Public Health2013
Measurement of physical activity in urban and rural South African adults
Open AccessAdewale L Oyeyemi, Sarah Mo et al.BMC Public Health2016
Association of dog ownership with accelerometer-measured physical activity and daily steps in 70-year-old individuals
Open AccessMarcel Ballin, Oskar Antonsson et al.BMC Public Health2021
The association between age and accelerometry-derived types of habitual daily activity
Open AccessKimberley S van Schooten, Jaap H Van Dieën et al.BMC Public Health2018
Validity of the Global Physical Activity Questionnaire (GPAQ) in assessing levels and change in moderate-vigorous physical activity and sedentary behaviour
Open AccessCharles Cleland, Claire L Cleland et al.BMC Public Health2014
Improving movement behavior in office workers
Open AccessLisa-Marie Larisch, Victoria Blom et al.BMC Public Health2024
Annual risk of long-term sickness absence due to musculoskeletal disorders across the lifespan and the role of physical activity and insomnia symptoms
Open AccessKaroline Moe, Eivind Schjelderup Skarpsno et al.BMC Public Health2025
Stepping volume and intensity patterns in a multi-ethnic urban Asian population
Open AccessJennifer Sumner, Léonie Uijtdewilligen et al.BMC Public Health2018
Do routinely measured risk factors for obesity explain the sex gap in its prevalence? Observations from Saudi Arabia
Open AccessFatima Garawi, George Ploubidis et al.BMC Public Health2015
A validation study of the Eurostat harmonised European time use study (Hetus) diary using wearable technology
Open AccessTeresa Harms, J Gershuny et al.BMC Public Health2019
Health behaviours associated with video gaming in adolescent men
Open AccessTuulia Puolitaival, Mirjam Sieppi et al.BMC Public Health2020
Association Between Change in Physical Activity During Pregnancy and Infant Birth Weight
Open AccessKennedy M Peter‐Marske, Kathryn R Hesketh et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2023
The Need to Objectively Measure Physical Activity During Pregnancy
Open AccessEva Guérin, Zachary M Ferraro et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2018
Increasing Trajectories of Multimorbidity Over Time
Open AccessMayilée Cañizares, Sheilah Hogg-Johnson et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2017
Cardiorespiratory Fitness and Muscular Strength Do Not Predict Social Cognitive Capacity in Older Age
Open AccessSarah A Grainger, Julie D Henry et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2023
Trajectories of device-assessed physical activity and sleep in ICU- and non-ICU-treated patients up to 2 years after hospitalization for Covid-19, and their association with health-related quality of life
Open AccessJulia C Berentschot, G W M Broeren et al.Quality of Life Research2025
A Test of How Australian Adults Allocate Time for Physical Activity
Amanda Rebar, Renée Johnston et al.Behavioral Medicine2017
Health Behaviors, Assessment of
Open AccessBritta Renner, Verena Klusmann et al.International Encyclopedia of the…2015
Health benefits of physical activity
Darren E R Warburton, Shannon S D BredinCurrent Opinion in Cardiology2017
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2014 Update
Alan S Go, Dariush Mozaffarian et al.Circulation2014
Changes in Physical Activity Patterns Due to the Covid-19 Pandemic
Open AccessKathrin Wunsch, Korbinian Kienberger et al.International Journal of…2022
Large-scale physical activity data reveal worldwide activity inequality
Open AccessTim Althoff, Rok Sosič et al.Nature2017
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2019 Update
Emelia J Benjamin, Paul Muntner et al.Circulation2019
Ambulatory Assessment
Timothy J Trull, Ulrich Ebner‐Priemer et al.Annual Review of Clinical…2013
Physical activity
Ryan E Rhodes, Ian Janssen et al.Psychology & Health2017
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2018 Update
Emelia J Benjamin, Salim S Virani et al.Circulation2018
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2016 Update
Dariush Mozaffarian, Emelia J Benjamin et al.Circulation2016
Dose-response associations between accelerometry measured physical activity and sedentary time and all cause mortality
Open AccessUlf Ekelund, Jakob Tarp et al.BMJ2019
A comparison of self-reported and device measured sedentary behaviour in adults
Open AccessStéphanie A Prince, Luca Cardilli et al.International Journal of…2020
Quantifying the Association Between Physical Activity and Cardiovascular Disease and Diabetes
Open AccessAhad Wahid, Nishma Manek et al.Journal of the American Heart…2016
Cardiorespiratory Fitness in Youth
Geetha Raghuveer, Jacob Hartz et al.Circulation2020
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2017 Update
Emelia J Benjamin, Michael J Blaha et al.Circulation2017
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2011 Update
Véronique L Roger, Alan S Go et al.Circulation2011
Predictors of Covid-19 voluntary compliance behaviors
Open AccessConnie J Clark, Andrés Dávila et al.Global Transitions2020
The contribution of health behaviors to socioeconomic inequalities in health
Open AccessĐorđe Petrović, Carlos De Mestral et al.Preventive Medicine2018
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2013 Update
Alan S Go, Dariush Mozaffarian et al.Circulation2013
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2015 Update
Dariush Mozaffarian, Emelia J Benjamin et al.Circulation2015
Comparison of Self-reported versus Accelerometer-Measured Physical Activity
Sindre M Dyrstad, Bjørge Herman Hansen et al.Medicine & Science in Sports &…2014
Physical Activity and Daily Stress Processes in Older Adulthood
Open AccessKate A Leger, Susan T Charles et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2022
Avoiding the Major Causes of Death
Open AccessMonica M Williams, Blakelee Kemp et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2018
Concordance of Physical Activity Trajectories Among Middle-Aged and Older Married Couples
Kin-Kit Li, Kin‐kit Li et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2013
Nonlinear Associations of Accelerometer-Based Sedentary Time With Cognitive Functions in the UK Biobank
Open AccessSilvio Maltagliati, Daniel H Aslan et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2025
Geriatric Syndromes and Functional Status in NSHAP
Megan Huisingh‐Scheetz, M Huisingh-Scheetz et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2014
Education and Cognition in Middle Age and Later Life
Open AccessYujun Liu, Margie E Lachman et al.The Journals of Gerontology…2019
Low Physical Activity and Cardiorespiratory Fitness in People With Schizophrenia
Open AccessThomas W Scheewe, Frederike Jörg et al.Frontiers in Psychiatry2019
Does Childcare Work Promote Cardiorespiratory Fitness and Health? A Cross-Sectional Study of Danish Childcare Workers Based on Accelerometry and Heart Rate Measurements
Open AccessKathrine Greby Schmidt, Rasmus Kildedal et al.International Journal of…2021
A Multilevel Analysis of Neighbourhood Built and Social Environments and Adult Self-Reported Physical Activity and Body Mass Index in Ottawa, Canada
Open AccessStéphanie A Prince, Elizabeth Kristjansson et al.International Journal of…2011
Behavioral health risk factor profiles in general hospital patients
Open AccessJennis Freyer‐Adam, Florian Noetzel et al.BMC Public Health2019
Associations between Lifestyle Changes and Adherence to Covid-19 Restrictions in Older Adults with Hypertension
Open AccessMarco D’Αddario, Roberta Adorni et al.International Journal of…2022
I Can Stand Learning
Open AccessKatharina Wick, Oliver Faude et al.International Journal of…2018
Perceived neighborhood built environment and physical activity in urban population in Chile
Open AccessRodrigo Fuentes Kloss, Jaime Cerda et al.BMC Public Health2025
Accelerometer-determined physical activity and self-reported health in a population of older adults (65–85 years)
Open AccessHilde Lohne‐Seiler, Hilde Lohne-Seiler et al.BMC Public Health2014
Association between total and leisure time physical activity and risk of myocardial infarction and stroke – a Swedish cohort study
Open AccessMadeleine Hummel, Essi Hantikainen et al.BMC Public Health2022
Associations of Objectively-Measured Sedentary Time and Patterns with Cognitive Function in Non-Demented Japanese Older Adults
Open AccessSanmei Chen, Tao Chen et al.International Journal of…2022
Education-related disparities in reported physical activity during leisure-time, active transportation, and work among US adults
Open AccessShaun Scholes, David BannBMC Public Health2018
The association between psychological distress and alcohol consumption and physical activity
Open AccessSilvia Eiken Alpers, Ståle Pallesen et al.Frontiers in Psychiatry2023
Domain-Specific Adult Sedentary Behaviour Questionnaire (ASBQ) and the GPAQ Single-Item Question
Open AccessAnne HY Chu, Sheryl Hui-Xian Ng et al.International Journal of…2018
Agreement between pedometer and accelerometer in measuring physical activity in overweight and obese pregnant women
Open AccessTarja I Kinnunen, Peter WG Tennant et al.BMC Public Health2011
Integrated motivational interviewing and cognitive behaviour therapy can increase physical activity and improve health of adult ambulatory care patients in a regional hospital
Open AccessStephen Barrett, Stephen Begg et al.BMC Public Health2018
Sense of Coherence Predicts Physical Activity Maintenance and Health-Related Quality of Life
Open AccessRoberta Adorni, Andrea Greco et al.International Journal of…2022
Concordance between Different Criteria for Self-Reported Physical Activity Levels and Risk Factors in People with High Blood Pressure in a Rural District in Bangladesh
Open AccessAmirul Islam, Jahar Bhowmik et al.International Journal of…2021
An inventory of national surveillance systems assessing physical activity, sedentary behaviour and sport participation of adults in the European Union
Open AccessMaroje Sorić, Kaja Meh et al.BMC Public Health2021
Collective Efficacy, Physical Activity, and Health Outcomes Among Mothers
Deirdre Dlugonski, Bhibha M Das et al.Family & Community Health2017
Joint Association between Sedentary Time and Moderate-to-Vigorous Physical Activity with Obesity Risk in Adults from Latin America
Open AccessEduardo Rossato De Victo, Mauro Fisberg et al.International Journal of…2023
Changing educational inequalities in sporting inactivity among adults in Germany
Open AccessJens Hoebel, Jonas D Finger et al.BMC Public Health2017
Time kinetics of physical activity, sitting, and quality of life measures within a regional workplace
Open AccessDaniel Lindsay, Daniel B Lindsay et al.BMC Public Health2016
Relationships between Physical Activity, Sedentary Behaviour and Cognitive Functions in Office Workers
Open AccessEmil Bojsen‐Møller, Carl-Johan Boraxbekk et al.International Journal of…2019
Short-term outcomes of physical activity counseling in in-patients with Major Depressive Disorder
Open AccessC Robyn, Robyn Cody et al.Frontiers in Psychiatry2023
Does Physically Demanding Work Hinder a Physically Active Lifestyle in Low Socioeconomic Workers? A Compositional Data Analysis Based on Accelerometer Data
Open AccessCharlotte Lund Rasmussen, Javier Palarea‐Albaladejo et al.International Journal of…2018
Generational differences in patterns of physical activities over time in the Canadian population
Open AccessMayilée Cañizares, E M BadleyBMC Public Health2018
Physical activity interventions for older adults – an overview of systematic reviews
Open AccessJo Canneaux, Richard A Sharpe et al.BMC Public Health2026
Physical Activity in Adults with Schizophrenia and Bipolar Disorder
Open AccessGarry A Tew, Laura Bailey et al.International Journal of…2023
Associations between 24 h Movement Behavior and Mental Health in Office Workers
Open AccessLisa-Marie Larisch, Lena Kallings et al.International Journal of…2020
Does Physical Activity Mediate the Associations Between Local-Area Descriptive Norms, Built Environment Walkability, and Glycosylated Hemoglobin
Open AccessSusan J Carroll, Theo Niyonsenga et al.International Journal of…2017
Physical activity, screen time and obesity status in a nationally representative sample of Maltese youth with international comparisons
Open AccessAndrew Decelis, Russell Jago et al.BMC Public Health2014
Association of Self-Reported and Device-Measured Sedentary Behaviour and Physical Activity with Health-Related Quality of Life among European Older Adults
Open AccessOriol Sansano-Nadal, Maria Giné‐Garriga et al.International Journal of…2021
Analysis of the Athletic Career and Retirement Depending on the Type of Sport
Open AccessCristina López De Subijana, Larissa Rafaela Galatti et al.International Journal of…2020
A Study of Physical Activity Determinants among High-Risk Hypertensive Filipino and Korean Americans
Open AccessAisha Bhimla, Crystal A Gadegbeku et al.International Journal of…2019
The association between physical activity, sleep, and quality of life in patients in bio-chemical remission from Cushing’s syndrome
Open AccessSusette A Moyers, Jitske TiemensmaQuality of Life Research2020
Differences in physical activity participation among young adults in Aotearoa New Zealand
Open AccessOliver W A Wilson, Melody Smith et al.BMC Public Health2023
Calibration of Self-Reported Time Spent Sitting, Standing and Walking among Office Workers
Open AccessDavid Hallman, Svend Erik Mathiassen et al.International Journal of…2019
Telephone-Based Coaching and Prompting for Physical Activity
Open AccessXenia Fischer, Jan-Niklas Kreppke et al.International Journal of…2019
The effects of clinical illness severity and physical activity on health-related quality of life in schizophrenia
Open AccessMei San Ang, Milawaty Nurjono et al.Quality of Life Research2019
Fit and Healthy Family Camp for Engaging Families in a Child Obesity Intervention
Sally P Weaver, Lance P Kelley et al.Family & Community Health2014
Feasibility Study Comparing Physical Activity Classifications from Accelerometers with Wearable Camera Data
Open AccessAlyse Davies, Margaret Allman‐Farinelli et al.International Journal of…2020
Meeting physical activity guidelines is associated with reduced risk for cardiovascular disease in black South African women; a 5.5-year follow-up study
Open AccessKasha Dickie, Lisa K Micklesfield et al.BMC Public Health2014
The associations between social support change and physical activity trajectory from late adolescence to young adulthood
Open AccessJuan Cao, Kun Wang et al.BMC Public Health2023
Associations of Objectively-Assessed Smartphone Use with Physical Activity, Sedentary Behavior, Mood, and Sleep Quality in Young Adults
Open AccessMoisés Grimaldi Puyana, José María Fernández Batanero et al.International Journal of…2020
Differing Contributions of Classical Risk Factors to Type 2 Diabetes in Multi-Ethnic Malaysian Populations
Open AccessNoraidatulakma Abdullah, Nor Azian Abdul Murad et al.International Journal of…2018
Older adults’ community participation, physical activity, and social interactions during and following Covid-19 restrictions in Australia
Open AccessClaire Gough, Chris Barr et al.BMC Public Health2023
Physical activity, body mass index and heart rate variability-based stress and recovery in 16 275 Finnish employees
Open AccessTiina Föhr, Julia Pietilä et al.BMC Public Health2016
Differential impacts of physical activity volume and intensity on blood lead levels in children and adolescents
Open AccessShengrong Ouyang, Yan Yin et al.BMC Public Health2025
Week Inspiratory Muscle Training Improves Respiratory Muscle Strength in Adult Patients with Stable Asthma
Open AccessYi Chung, Ting‐Yu Huang et al.International Journal of…2021
Childhood temperament predictors of adolescent physical activity
Open AccessJames A Janssen, Jacek Kolacz et al.BMC Public Health2017
Does participating in community gardens promote sustainable lifestyles in urban settings? Design and protocol of the JArDinS study
Open AccessMarion Tharrey, Marlène Pérignon et al.BMC Public Health2019

Obras citantes distintas	316
Citações por ano	19,75
Intervalo de citações	2010 - 2026 (17)
Velocidade de citação	current
Altamente citado	Sim
Tipos de citação	Neutras: 314