Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Data Sharing Reveals Complexity in the Westward Spread of Domestic Animals across Neolithic Turkey

Bibliographic Data

ID23328480
AuthorsBenjamin S Arbuckle (0000-0002-5445-5516, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, corresponding author), Sarah Whitcher Kansa (0000-0001-7920-5321, Alexandria Archive Institute), Eric Kansa (0000-0001-5620-4764, Alexandria Archive Institute), D Orton (0000-0003-4069-8004, University College London), Canan Çakırlar (0000-0002-7994-0091, University of Groningen), Lionel Gourichon (0000-0002-5160-5902, Université Côte d'Azur), Levent Atici, Levent Atıcı (0000-0002-4929-173X, University of Nevada, Las Vegas), Alfred Galik (0000-0002-7070-1035, University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna), A Marciniak (0000-0001-6933-3290, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań), Jacqui Mulville (0000-0002-9392-3693, Cardiff University), Hijlke Buitenhuis (0009-0007-3350-2532, University of Groningen), Denise Carruthers (University of Liverpool), Bea De Cupere (0000-0001-7559-8965, Institute of Natural Sciences), Arzu DEMIRERGI (Stony Brook University), Sheelagh Frame, Daniel Helmer (Archéorient), Louise Martins (0000-0002-2083-813X, University College London), Louise Martin, Joris Peters (0000-0003-0894-2628, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München), Nadja Pöllath (0000-0001-8714-467X, Bavarian State Collection of Zoology), Kamilla Pawłowska (0000-0002-4103-4501, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań), N Russell (0000-0001-7623-1364, Cornell University), K C Twi (0000-0002-7609-853X, Stony Brook University), Katheryn Twiss, Doris Würtenberger
EditorsStephen Shennan
Year2014
Volume9
Issue6
Pagese99845
Publication date2014-06-13
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenuePLoS ONE (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1932-6203 • E-ISSN: 1932-6203
PublisherPublic Library of Science (PLoS) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1371/journal.pone.0099845
PMID24927173
PMCIDPMC4057358
OpenAlexW2074830918
LanguageEN
Citations received88
References cited50

This study presents the results of a major data integration project bringing together primary archaeozoological data for over 200,000 faunal specimens excavated from seventeen sites in Turkey spanning the Epipaleolithic through Chalcolithic periods, c. 18,000-4,000 cal BC, in order to document the initial westward spread of domestic livestock across Neolithic central and western Turkey. From these shared datasets we demonstrate that the westward expansion of Neolithic subsistence technologies combined multiple routes and pulses but did not involve a set 'package' comprising all four livestock species including sheep, goat, cattle and pig. Instead, Neolithic animal economies in the study regions are shown to be more diverse than deduced previously using quantitatively more limited datasets. Moreover, during the transition to agro-pastoral economies interactions between domestic stock and local wild fauna continued. Through publication of datasets with Open Context (opencontext.org), this project emphasizes the benefits of data sharing and web-based dissemination of large primary data sets for exploring major questions in archaeology (Alternative Language Abstract S1).

Biology · Evolutionary biology · Geography · Archaeology and ancient environmental studies · Forensic Anthropology and Bioarchaeology Studies · Paleopathology and ancient diseases

  • The origins of nomadic pastoralism in the eastern Jordanian steppe

    Holly Miller, Douglas Baird et al.•Levant•2018

  • Documenting heritage in the 21st century

    Open Access•Letty ten Harkel, Michael Fradley et al.•Levant•2021

  • Anthropological Data in the Digital Age

    Jerome W Crowder, Mike Fortun et al.•Anthropological Data in the…•2019

  • Early farmers in northwest Turkey

    Open Access•Chelsea Budd, Alfred Galik et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2020

  • The Use and Challenges of Spatial Data in Archaeology

    Open Access•Carla Klehm•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2023

  • What North American Archaeology Needs to Take Advantage of the Digital Data Revolution

    Open Access•G Ortman, Jeffrey H Altschul•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2023

  • Refining Archaeological Data Collection and Management

    Open Access•Michael Heilen, Shelby A Manney•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2023

  • Snapshots of Digital Scholarship in Zooarchaeology

    Open Access•Iain Mckechnie, Sarah Whitcher Kansa et al.•Ethnobiology Letters•2015

  • Diet uniformity at an early farming community in northwest Anatolia (Turkey)

    Open Access•Chelsea Budd, Necmi Karul et al.•Archaeological and Anthropological…•2018

  • Barcın Höyük, a seventh millennium settlement in the Eastern Marmara region of Turkey

    Open Access•F Gerritsen, Rana Özbal•Documenta Praehistorica•2019

  • Pigs and humans in Early Neolithic South-eastern Europe

    Open Access•Donna De Groene, Petar Zidarov et al.•Documenta Praehistorica•2018

  • Pigs and humans in Early Neolithic South-eastern Europe

    Open Access•Donna De Groene, Petar Zidarov et al.•Documenta Praehistorica•2019

  • Long and short revolutions towards the Neolithic in western Anatolia and Aegean

    Open Access•Barbara Horejs•Documenta Praehistorica•2019

  • Niche Construction and Theory of Agricultural Origins. Case studies in punctuated equilibrium

    Open Access•Bernhard Weninger, Bernhard Paul Weninger•Documenta Praehistorica•2017

  • Diversity and homogeneity among the early farming communities of Western Anatolia

    Open Access•Eylem Özdoğan•Documenta Praehistorica•2016

  • Modelling the initial expansion of the Neolithic out of Anatolia

    Open Access•Maxime Brami, Andrea Zanotti•Documenta Praehistorica•2015

  • Different manifestations of Neolithization in Northwest Anatolia

    Open Access•Hüreyla Balcı, Rana Özbal et al.•Documenta Praehistorica•2022

  • The beginning of herding and animal management

    Open Access•Caroline Middleton•Anatolian Studies•2018

  • Zooarchaeology in Practice

    Open Access•Christina M Giovas, Michelle J Lefebvre•Zooarchaeology in Practice•2018

  • Digital Archaeological Data

    Open Access•Francis P Mcmanamon, Fp Mcmanamon•Encyclopedia Of Global Archaeology•2018

  • Standardization, Storage, and Dissemination of Environmental Archaeological Data

    Open Access•Sarah Whitcher Kansa, Eric Kansa et al.•Encyclopedia of Global Archaeology•2020

  • Standardization, Storage, and Dissemination of Environmental Archaeological Data

    Open Access•Sarah Whitcher Kansa, Eric Kansa et al.•Encyclopedia Of Global Archaeology•2018

  • Digital Archaeological Data

    Open Access•Francis P Mcmanamon, Fp Mcmanamon•Encyclopedia of Global Archaeology•2020

  • Regional asynchronicity in dairy production and processing in early farming communities of the northern Mediterranean

    Open Access•Cynthianne Spiteri, Cynthianne Debono Spiteri et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2016

  • The Cultural Evolution of Neolithic Europe. Euroevol Dataset 2

    Open Access•Katie Manning•Journal of Open Archaeology Data•2016

  • Morphometric evolution of the domestic triad, in western Gallia Narbonensis (southern France, Languedoc), between the 2nd c.BC and the 4th c.AD

    Open Access•Marine Jeanjean, Cyprien Mureau et al.•Quaternary International•2023

  • New insights into livestock management and domestication at Tel Ro'im West, a multi-layer Neolithic site in the Upper Jordan Valley, Israel

    Open Access•Nuha Agha, Dani Nadel et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2019

  • A probabilistic model for distinguishing between sheep and goat postcranial remains

    Open Access•Jesse Wolfhagen, M Price•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2017

  • From prehistoric shores

    Open Access•Emma L Baysal, Sera Yelözer•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2023

  • Meta-analysis in zooarchaeology expands perspectives on Indigenous fisheries of the Northwest Coast of North America

    Open Access•Iain Mckechnie, M L Mo•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2016

  • The emergence and evolution of Neolithic cattle farming in southeastern Europe

    Open Access•Safoora Kamjan, Donna De Groene et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2021

  • Clay preparation and function of the first ceramics in north-west Anatolia

    Open Access•B de Groot, Laurens Thissen et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2017

  • Reuse Remix Recycle

    Open Access•Jeremy Huggett•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2018

  • Data Beyond the Archive in Digital Archaeology

    Open Access•Sarah Whitcher Kansa, Eric Kansa•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2018

  • Archaeological Analysis in the Information Age

    Open Access•Sarah Whitcher Kansa, Levent Atıcı et al.•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2019

  • Beyond the Archive

    Open Access•Ixchel M Faniel, A Austin et al.•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2018

  • Teaching Open Science

    Open Access•Katherine M Cook, Canan Çakırlar et al.•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2018

  • Data Integration in the Service of Synthetic Research

    Open Access•K W Kintigh, Katherine Spielmann et al.•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2017

  • Tdar

    Open Access•Fp Mcmanamon, K W Kintigh et al.•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2017

  • From Anatolia to Algarve

    Open Access•Ferran Borrell, Ignacio Clemente-Conte et al.•Open Archaeology•2022

  • On the Value of Informal Communication in Archaeological Data Work

    Open Access•Zachary Batist•Open Archaeology•2024

  • The Rise of Cattle Cultures in Bronze Age Anatolia

    Benjamin S Arbuckle•Journal of Eastern Mediterranean…•2014

  • Before the Neolithic in the Aegean

    Çiğdem Atakuman, Burçin Erdoğu et al.•The Journal of Island and Coastal…•2020

  • From the Aegean to the Adriatic

    E Pilaar Birch•The Journal of Island and Coastal…•2017

  • A Species Specific Investigation Into Sheep and Goat Husbandry During the Early European Neolithic

    Rosalind E Gillis, Jane S Gaastra et al.•Environmental Archaeology•2019

  • Open Context in a Changing Context

    Open Access•Eric Kansa, Sarah Whitcher Kansa•Internet Archaeology•2026

  • Computational Reproducibility in Archaeological Research

    Open Access•Ben Marwick•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2016

  • Estimating the Ontogenetic Age and Sex Composition of Faunal Assemblages with Bayesian Multilevel Mixture Models

    Open Access•Jesse Wolfhagen•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2023

  • Process and Dynamics of Mediterranean Neolithization (7000–5500 bc)

    Open Access•Thomas P Leppard•Journal of Archaeological Research•2021

  • Archaeological Approaches to Agricultural Economies

    Open Access•J M Marston•Journal of Archaeological Research•2021

  • Adaptation, identity, and innovation in Neolithic and Chalcolithic Western Anatolia (6800–3000 cal. BC)

    Open Access•Canan Çakırlar•Quaternary International•2015

  • Re-examining the use of the LSI technique in zooarchaeology

    Open Access•Jesse Wolfhagen•Journal of Archaeological Science•2020

  • The contributions of animal bones from archaeological sites

    Open Access•Teresa E Steele•Journal of Archaeological Science•2015

  • Documenting the initial appearance of domestic cattle in the Eastern Fertile Crescent (northern Iraq and western Iran)

    Open Access•Benjamin S Arbuckle, M Price et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2016

  • Taxonomic and phylogenetic signals in bovini cheek teeth

    Open Access•Thomas Cucchi, Barbara Stopp et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2019

  • Modelling caprine age-at-death profiles using the Gamma distribution

    Open Access•Adrian Timpson, Rosalind E Gillis et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2018

  • Zooarchaeology in the era of big data

    Open Access•Hannah Lau, Sarah Whitcher Kansa•Journal of Archaeological Science•2018

  • Investigation of dietary habits in the Neolithic Tepecik-Çiftlik population

    Open Access•K Özdemir, Benjamin Irvine et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2024

  • Fostering Collaborative Synthetic Research in Archaeology

    Open Access•Jeffrey H Altschul, K W Kintigh et al.•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2018

  • Is There an Anatolian Mesolithic? An Assessment of the New Evidence from Western Türkiye

    Çiler Çilingiroğlu•Journal of Eastern Mediterranean…•2025

  • The Aegean in the Early 7th Millennium BC

    Open Access•Barbara Horejs, Bogdana Milić et al.•Journal of World Prehistory•2015

  • Anthropological Archaeology in 2016

    Open Access•C T Halperin•American Anthropologist•2017

  • Eski̇şehi̇r Küllüoba’da İlk Tunç Çağ Iii’den Orta Tunç’a Geçi̇ş Evresi̇ne Ai̇t İki̇ Adak Çukuru

    Open Access•Can Yümni Gündem, Can GÜNDEM•Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi…•2021

  • The Galena Objects from Neolithic Ulucak

    Özlem Çevik, Murat Dirican et al.•ADALYA•2020

  • Hoofprints in the sand

    Open Access•Sierra Harding, Vermeersch et al.•Quaternary International•2023

  • Does the choice of a reference matter for log size index analysis? A case study from roman times in southern France

    Open Access•Allowen Evin, Marine Jeanjean et al.•Quaternary International•2023

  • Geoarchaeological research at Barcın Höyük

    Open Access•Mark R Groenhuijzen, Sjoerd Kluiving et al.•Quaternary International•2015

  • New Directions in South African Archaeozoology of the Last 2,000 Years

    Open Access•Annie R Antonites, Karin Scott et al.•African Archaeological Review•2016

  • Between Anatolia and the Aegean

    Çiler Çilingiroğlu, Małgorzata Kaczanowska et al.•Journal of Field Archaeology•2020

  • Between the Danube and the Deep Blue Sea

    Open Access•D Orton, Jane S Gaastra et al.•Open Quaternary•2016

  • Beginnings of the Neolithic in Southeast Europe

    Open Access•Raiko Krauß, Nedko Elenski et al.•Documenta Praehistorica•2014

  • The Digital Index of North American Archaeology

    Open Access•Eric Kansa, Eric C Kansa et al.•Antiquity•2018

  • Sheep in Early Neolithic settlements in South Iberia, insights from proteomics

    Open Access•Carmen Domínguez-Castillo, Esteban García-Viñas et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2026

  • Traction in Neolithic Çatalhöyük? Palaeopathological analysis of cattle and aurochs remains from the East and West Mounds

    Open Access•Safoora Kamjan, Pınar Erdil et al.•Journal of Anthropological…•2022

  • Domestic dogs and wild canids on the Northwest Coast of North America

    Open Access•Iain Mckechnie, M L Mo et al.•Journal of Anthropological…•2020

  • The Promise and Peril of Older Collections

    Open Access•E L Jones, Caroline Gabe•Open Quaternary•2015

  • Feeding Teotihuacan

    Open Access•N Sugiyama, A D Somerville•Archaeological and Anthropological…•2017

  • Time of change

    Open Access•Kamilla Pawłowska•Archaeological and Anthropological…•2020

  • Combined osteomorphological, isotopic, aDNA, and ZooMS analyses of sheep and goat remains from Neolithic Ulucak, Turkey

    Open Access•E Pilaar Birch, Suzanne E Pilaar Birch et al.•Archaeological and Anthropological…•2019

  • Contrasting pathways to domestication and agriculture around Southwest Asia

    Open Access•D Q Fuller, Leilani Lucas•Archaeological and Anthropological…•2025

  • A catch 22 of 3D data sustainability

    Open Access•Heather Richards-Rissetto, Jennifer Von Schwerin•Digital Applications in…•2017

  • Archaeozoological study of a unique Late Neolithic pit from Tepecik-Çiftlik, central Turkey

    Open Access•Can Yümni Gündem•Anthropozoologica•2019

  • Pigs in the Neolithic of the Eastern Fertile Crescent

    Open Access•Donna De Groene, Robin Bendrey et al.•International Journal of…•2021

  • Subsistence strategies in the Late Neolithic and Bronze Age in Nenjiang River Basin

    Open Access•Qiyao Liang, Quanjia Chen et al.•International Journal of…•2023

  • Flattening the Wild in the Ancient Near East

    Benjamin S Arbuckle, Christine Mikeska et al.•Near Eastern Archaeology•2022

  • Data Publishing and Archaeology's Information Ecosystem

    Sarah Whitcher Kansa, Eric Kansa•Near Eastern Archaeology•2014

  • Towards the End of the Çatalhöyük East Settlement

    Kamilla Pawłowska•Near Eastern Archaeology•2020

  • Una mirada cuantitativa sobre las primeras cuatro décadas de la zooarqueología de los Andes Centro-Sur

    Open Access•Carlos Raúl Belotti López De Medina•Revista del Museo de Antropología•2023

  • Initial diversity in sheep and goat management in Neolithic south-western Asia

    Benjamin S Arbuckle, Levent Atici et al.•Levant•2013

  • The Early Neolithic in Greece

    Open Access•Catherine Perlès, Gérard Monthel•Early Neolithic in Greece•2001

  • Pig Domestication and Human-Mediated Dispersal in Western Eurasia Revealed through Ancient DNA and Geometric Morphometrics

    Open Access•Claudio Ottoni, Linus Girdland Flink et al.•Molecular Biology and Evolution•2013

  • The origins of animal domestication and husbandry

    Open Access•Jean-Denis Vigne, Jean‐denis Vigne•Comptes Rendus Biologies•2011

  • The Initial Domestication of Goats ( Capra hircus ) in the Zagros Mountains 10,000 Years Ago

    Open Access•M A Zeder, Brian Hesse•Science•2000

  • First wave of cultivators spread to Cyprus at least 10,600 y ago

    Open Access•Jean-Denis Vigne, Jean‐denis Vigne et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2012

  • Climate Forcing Due to the 8200 Cal yr BP Event Observed at Early Neolithic Sites in the Eastern Mediterranean

    Open Access•Bernhard Weninger, Eva Alram-Stern et al.•Quaternary Research•2006

  • Ancient DNA, pig domestication, and the spread of the Neolithic into Europe

    Open Access•Greger Larson, U Albarella et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2007

  • Domestication and early agriculture in the Mediterranean Basin

    Open Access•M A Zeder•Proceedings of the National…•2008

  • Earliest date for milk use in the Near East and southeastern Europe linked to cattle herding

    Open Access•R P Evershed, Sebastian Payne et al.•Nature•2008

  • Grand challenges for archaeology

    Open Access•K W Kintigh, Jeffrey H Altschul et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2014

  • Pathways to Animal Domestication

    Open Access•M A Zeder•Biodiversity in Agriculture•2012

  • The Walking larder

    Juliet Clutton-Brock•The Walking larder•1989

  • The Aceramic Neoloithic Period in Western Turkey and in the Aegean

    Mehmet Özdoğan, Ivan Gatsov•Anatolica•1998

  • The Prehistory of Asia Minor

    Open Access•Bleda S Düring, Bleda S Dürıng•Prehistory of Asia Minor•2010

  • Animal Exploitation at Çayönü Tepesi̇, Southeastern Anatolia

    Hitomi Hongo, Richard H Meadows et al.•Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi…•2004

  • Early Neolithic settlement patterns and exchange networks in the Aegean

    Open Access•Agathe Reingruber•Documenta Praehistorica•2011

  • Towards configuring the neolithisation of Aegean Turkey

    Open Access•Çiler Çilingiroğlu, Canan Çakırlar•Documenta Praehistorica•2013

  • Distinguishing Wild Boar from Domestic Pigs in Prehistory

    Open Access•P A Rowley‐conwy, Peter Rowley-Conwy et al.•Journal of World Prehistory•2012

  • Open Archaeology

    Eric Kansa, Sarah Whitcher Kansa•Journal of Eastern Mediterranean…•2013

  • Species distribution modelling of ancient cattle from early Neolithic sites in SW Asia and Europe

    Open Access•James Conolly, Katie Manning et al.•The Holocene•2012

  • Ages of epiphyseal closure in feral and domestic goats and ages of dental eruption

    Open Access•Barbara Noddle•Journal of Archaeological Science•1974

  • The late adoption of cattle and pig husbandry in Neolithic Central Turkey

    Open Access•Benjamin S Arbuckle•Journal of Archaeological Science•2012

  • Meta-analysis of zooarchaeological data from SW Asia and SE Europe provides insight into the origins and spread of animal husbandry

    Open Access•James Conolly, Sue Colledge et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2010

  • Revisiting Neolithic Caprine Exploitation at Suberde, Turkey

    Benjamin S Arbuckle•Journal of Field Archaeology•2008

  • Aktivitäten und Subsistenz in den Siedlungen des Çukuriçi Höyük. Der Forschungsstand nach den Ausgrabungen 2006–2009

    Barbara Horejs, Alfred Galik et al.•Praehistorische Zeitschrift•2011

  • The origins of Europe's first farmers

    Maxime Brami, Volker Heyd•Praehistorische Zeitschrift•2011

  • The evolution of animal husbandry in Neolithic central-west Anatolia

    Open Access•Canan Çakırlar•Anatolian Studies•2012

  • Kill-off Patterns in Sheep and Goats

    Open Access•Sebastian Payne•Anatolian Studies•1973

  • A Regional Biological Approach to the Spread of Farming in Europe

    Ron Pinhasi, Mark Pluciennik•Current Anthropology•2004

  • Neolithic Dairy Technology at the European-Anatolian Frontier

    Open Access•Canan Çakırlar, Canan Çakirlar•Anthropozoologica•2012

  • Cattle Domestication at Çatalhöyük Revisited

    N Russell, Louise Martins et al.•Current Anthropology•2005

  • Dating the East Adriatic Neolithic

    Open Access•Stašo Forenbaher, Timothy Kaiser et al.•European Journal of Archaeology•2013

  • Climatic Change and the Advent of Domestication

    Simon Davis•Paléorient•1982

  • The early management of cattle (Bos taurus) in Neolithic central Anatolia

    Open Access•Benjamin S Arbuckle, C A Makarewicz•Antiquity•2009

  • Openness and archaeology's information ecosystem

    Eric Kansa•World Archaeology•2012

  • Large-scale cereal processing before domestication during the tenth millennium cal BC in northern Syria

    Open Access•George Willcox, Danielle Stordeur•Antiquity•2012

  • "The concept of "Neolithic package

    Open Access•Çiler Çilingiroğlu•Documenta Praehistorica•2005

  • Grand Challenges for Archaeology

    Open Access•K W Kintigh, Jeffrey H Altschul et al.•American Antiquity•2014

  • The Origins of Agriculture

    Kent V Flannery•Annual Review of Anthropology•1973

  • The Origins of Agriculture in the Near East

    M A Zeder•Current Anthropology•2011

  • The Early Process of Mammal Domestication in the Near East

    Jean-Denis Vigne, Jean‐denis Vigne et al.•Current Anthropology•2011

  • Archaeological Evidence on the Westward Expansion of Farming Communities from Eastern Anatolia to the Aegean and the Balkans

    Mehmet Özdoğan•Current Anthropology•2011

Unique citing works88
Citations per year7,33
Citation span2014 - 2026 (13)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 70
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae