Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Vision, Media, Noise and the Percolation of Time

Symmetrical Approaches to the Mediation of the Material World

Bibliographic Data

ID2390882
AuthorsChristopher Witmore (John Brown University, corresponding author), Christopher L Witmore (Brown University)
Year2006
Volume11
Issue3
Pages267-292
Publication date2006-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Material Culture (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1359-1835 • E-ISSN: 1460-3586
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1359183506068806
OpenAlexW2007686891
LanguageEN
Citations received71
References cited46

Why in the articulation of archaeological knowledge have wider sensory properties of the material world been over looked? This article considers this question in relation to sound. It argues that the neglect of sound is partly the product of human transactions with instruments and media in practice. Moreover, the denial of sound as a relevant category of archaeological inquiry arises out of modernist notions of space-time that reside at the heart of the discipline. So while the visual is linked with spatial properties that are resistant to change, the aural is connected with the temporal and is considered momentary and fleeting in nature. Still, it is argued that sound as a quality of things is fundamental to human sensation - to being. In building upon a non-modernist notion of time where entities and events quite distant in a linear temporality are proximate through their simultaneous entanglement and percolation I suggest we might learn what we can understand from tuning into the acoustic properties of the material past. But rather than reproduce an unnecessary dualism between seeing and hearing, this endeavor will require us to relearn how to see and hear at the same time through other, complimentary modes of articulation and engagement

Aesthetics · Art · Articulation (sociology · Cognitive psychology · Cognitive science · Denial · Dualism · Epistemology · Politics · Relation (database · Sociology · Temporality · Archaeology and Rock Art Studies · Computer Science · Diverse Musicological Studies · History · Philosophy · Psychology · Visual Culture and Art Theory

  • Symmetrical Archaeology

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore•Encyclopedia of Global Archaeology•2020

  • Some Stimulating Solutions

    Andrew Cochrane•Material agency•2008

  • Symmetrical Archaeology

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore•Encyclopedia Of Global Archaeology•2019

  • Archaeological Material Manifestations

    Open Access•T D Dillehay•Teleoscopic Polity•2014

  • Podcast – kuunteleminen tekstinjälkeisessä ajassa

    Open Access•Tarja Rautiainen-Keskustalo•Lähikuva – audiovisuaalisen…•2024

  • Droping the Trowel

    Open Access•José Antonio Mármol Martínez•AP: Online Journal in Public…•2017

  • Assemblages, relationality and recursivity. Comments on ‘Archaeology and contemporaneity’ by Gavin Lucas

    Open Access•Andrew Meirion Jones•Archaeological Dialogues•2015

  • Reflections on Reflections

    William J Parry•Obsidian Reflections•2014

  • We Have Never Been Latourian

    Tim Flohr Sørensen•Norwegian Archaeological Review•2013

  • Obsidian Obsessed? Examining Patterns of Chipped-Stone Procurement at Late Postclassic Tututepec, Oaxaca

    Marc N Levine•Obsidian Reflections•2014

  • The Symbolism of Obsidian in Postclassic Central Mexico

    Alejandro Pastrana, Ivonne Athie•Obsidian Reflections•2014

  • Obsidian Symbolism in a Temple Offering from La Laguna, Tlaxcala

    D M Carballo•Obsidian Reflections•2014

  • Obsidian and Household Ritual at Xochitecatl-Cacaxtla

    Mari Carmen Serra Puche, Jesus Carlos Lazcano Arce et al.•Obsidian Reflections•2014

  • The Signs of Mission

    Open Access•Zoë Crossland•Materializing Colonial Encounters•2015

  • The Importance of British Material Culture to Historical Archaeologies of the Nineteenth Century

    Alasdair Brooks•Importance of British Material…•2016

  • Everyday Reorientation

    Open Access•Panos Kratimenos•Open Archaeology•2026

  • Les acteurs-réseaux en archéologie

    Open Access•Astrid Van Oyen•Les Nouvelles de l archéologie•2014

  • When was the ‘smart border’? Towards an agenda for historicising the technopolitics of migration and border control

    Open Access•Michelle Pfeifer, Philipp Seuferling•Cultural Studies•2026

  • Digital Media, Participatory Culture, and Difficult Heritage

    C Morgan, Pierre Marc Pallascio•Journal of African Diaspora…•2015

  • Tradition in Transition

    Open Access•Loes Opgenhaffen•Open Archaeology•2021

  • Visualizing Archaeologists

    Open Access•Loes Opgenhaffen•Open Archaeology•2021

  • Anthropocene in the Solar System

    Alice Gorman•Journal of Contemporary Archaeology•2014

  • Tactics against Antiquity

    Marinos Koutsomichalis•Journal of Contemporary Archaeology•2022

  • Industrial Sonifact and the Soundscape of the Anthropocene

    Jeffrey Benjamin•Journal of Contemporary Archaeology•2014

  • The “wild” continent

    Andrés Zarankin, Matthew A Salerno•Journal of Contemporary Archaeology•2014

  • Dark artifacts

    M Hudson•Journal of Contemporary Archaeology•2014

  • Archaeology, the Anthropocene, and the Hypanthropocene

    Christopher Witmore•Journal of Contemporary Archaeology•2014

  • Empathy for the ‘Other’

    T Matila, Paul R Mullins et al.•Journal of War and Culture Studies•2021

  • Thinking Through Living

    Open Access•Michelle Charest•Archaeologies•2009

  • Materialities of Nostalgia at the Old Homestead

    Open Access•Christina J Hodges•Archaeologies•2009

  • Prolegomena to Open Pasts

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore•Archaeologies•2009

  • Attending to Place and Time

    Open Access•Michael Given•European Journal of Archaeology•2020

  • Teoría e Interpretación en la Arqueología de la Muerte

    Open Access•Javier Rodríguez-Corral, Eduardo Ferrer Albelda•SPAL Revista de Prehistoria y…•2018

  • Etnoarqueología, arqueología etnográfica y cultura material

    Open Access•Alfredo González Ruibal•Complutum•1970

  • Moving Subjects, Situated Memory

    Open Access•Kathryn Franklin•International Journal of…•2020

  • Virtual Representation

    Open Access•Kevin Garstki•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2016

  • Archaeology and the Time of Modernity

    Alfredo González Ruibal•Historical Archaeology•2016

  • Reclaiming their stories’

    Open Access•Liz Cameron•Australian Archaeology•2024

  • Human geography and archaeology

    Open Access•Lisa J Hill•Progress in Human Geography•2014

  • Reclaiming Archaeology

    Alfredo González Ruibal, Alfredo González-Ruibal•Reclaiming archaeology•2013

  • Seven Interventions with the Flatlands

    Open Access•K Ryzewski•Archaeologies•2009

  • Sacred Imagery and Ritual Landscape

    Richard D Kortum•Time and Mind•2014

  • Things Are Us! A Commentary on Human/Things Relations under the Banner of a ‘Social’ Archaeology

    Timothy Webmoor, Christopher Witmore et al.•Norwegian Archaeological Review•2008

  • Sense of Place, Heterotopia, and Community

    Francesca Ciancimino Howell•Folklore•2013

  • Archaeology 2.0? Review of Archaeology 2.0

    Open Access•Michael Shanks, Christopher Witmore et al.•Internet Archaeology•2012

  • Timber Monuments, Landscape Andthe Environment in the Nith Valley, Dumfries and Galloway

    Open Access•Kirsty Millican•Oxford Journal of Archaeology•2012

  • Avian aurality in Anglo-Saxon England

    Open Access•Kristopher Poole, Eric Lacey•World Archaeology•2014

  • Vagueness and Archaeological Interpretation

    Marko Marila•Norwegian Archaeological Review•2017

  • Archaeological (Digital) Maps as Performances

    Piraye Hacıgüzeller•Norwegian Archaeological Review•2017

  • Finding symmetry? Archaeology, Objects, and Posthumanism

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore•Cambridge Archaeological Journal•2021

  • A new model for memory work

    Christina J Hodges•International Journal of Heritage…•2011

  • Archaeology, process and time

    Open Access•Oliver J T Harris•World Archaeology•2021

  • Space, Sound, and Light

    Anthony Mcmahon, Augusta Mcmahon•American Journal of Archaeology•2013

  • Time and community

    Open Access•M Bastian•Time & Society•2014

  • De chaque côté de la surface

    Open Access•Johnny Samuele Baldi•Temporalités•2012

  • Symmetrical archaeology

    Christopher Witmore, Christopher L Witmore•World Archaeology•2007

  • Exorcising the 'plague of fantasies

    R Harrison•World Archaeology•2010

  • Whistles in the wind

    Dianne Scullin, Blair Boyd et al.•World Archaeology•2014

  • Ethnoarchaeology or simply archaeology

    Alfredo González Ruibal, Alfredo González-Ruibal•World Archaeology•2016

  • In defence of representation

    Robert W Preucel•World Archaeology•2020

  • Hadrian's Wall

    Open Access•Claire Nesbitt, Divya P Tolia-Kelly et al.•Journal of Social Archaeology•2009

  • A tiny home of one's own

    Open Access•Jan Smitheram, Akari Nakai Kidd•Journal of Material Culture•2024

  • A stone that feels right in the hand

    Open Access•John Harries•Journal of Material Culture•2017

  • Folding, stitching, turning

    Open Access•Titika Malkogeorgou•Journal of Material Culture•2011

  • Archaeologies of the Contemporary World

    R Harrison, Esther Breithoff•Annual Review of Anthropology•2017

  • Soundscapes

    David W Samuels, Louise Meintjes et al.•Annual Review of Anthropology•2010

  • When Smoking Pipes Grow Fins

    Craig N Cipolla•Current Anthropology•2023

  • Worlds Otherwise

    Benjamin Alberti, Severin Fowle et al.•Current Anthropology•2011

  • Clockpunk Anthropology and the Ruins of Modernity

    Shannon Lee Dawdy, Shannon Dawdy•Current Anthropology•2010

  • Archaeology and contemporaneity

    Open Access•Gavin Lucas•Archaeological Dialogues•2015

  • Archaeologies 'now'. Creative interventions in the present for the future

    Open Access•R Harrison•Archaeological Dialogues•2011

  • The Auditory Culture Reader

    Michael Bull, Les Back•Auditory Culture Reader•2020

  • The Language of the Forest

    Alfred Gell•The anthropology of landscape•1995

  • Symmetrical Archaeology

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore•Encyclopedia Of Global Archaeology•2019

  • Scenes from a Troubled Engagement

    Bjørnar Olsen•Handbook of Material Culture•2006

  • Critique of Pure Reason

    Open Access•Immanuel Kant, Paul Guyer et al.•Critique of Pure Reason•1998

  • Suspensions of Perception

    Jonathan Crary•Suspensions of Perception•1999

  • How We Became Posthuman

    N Katherine Hayles•How We Became Posthuman•1999

  • Discourse Networks, 1800/1900

    Friedrich Kittler•Discourse Networks, 1800/1900•1990

  • Archaeology and Modernity

    Julian Thomas•Archaeology And Modernity•2004

  • Discipline and Punish

    Michel Foucault, Simon Prebble•Surveiller et punir•2019

  • The Materiality of Stone

    Christopher Tilley, Wayne Bennett et al.•Materiality of Stone•2020

  • Critical Approaches to Fieldwork

    Gavin Lucas•Critical Approaches to Fieldwork•2001

  • How We Became Posthuman

    Jeremy Tambling, N Katherine Hayles•The Modern Language Review•2001

  • Conversations on Science, Culture, and Time

    Open Access•Michel Serres, Roxanne Lapidus•Conversations on Science,…•1995

  • The Order of Things

    Michel Foucault•The Order of Things•2018

  • On multiple fields. Between the material world and media

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore, Christopher L Witmore•Archaeological Dialogues•2004

  • Four Archaeological Engagements With Place Mediating Bodily Experience Through Peripatetic Video

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore, Christopher L Witmore•Visual Anthropology Review•2004

  • La dimension sonore des grottes ornées

    Iégor Reznikoff, Michel Dauvois•Bulletin de la Société…•1988

  • Pandora's Hope

    Monica J Casper, Bruno Latour•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2000

  • On the Rationalization of Sight

    F H C Marriott, William M Ivins•Leonardo•1977

  • The Cultural Life of Images

    George Nash•European Journal of Archaeology•1998

  • Poetry, language, thought

    Martin Heidegger•Being and time•2001

  • Material culture after text

    Bjørnar Olsen•Norwegian Archaeological Review•2003

  • The Perception of the Environment

    T Ingold•Perception of the Environment•2021

  • Pragmatogonies

    Open Access•Bruno Latour•American Behavioral Scientist•1994

  • Foundations for an anthropology of the senses

    Open Access•Constance Classen•International Social Science…•1997

  • The temporality of the landscape

    T Ingold•World Archaeology•1993

  • Seeing is deceiving

    Sven Ouzman•World Archaeology•2001

  • Flesh and Metal

    N Katherine Hayles•Configurations•2002

  • Architecture and sound

    Open Access•Aaron Watson, David Keating•Antiquity•1999

  • Archaeological Draughtsmanship

    Open Access•Stuart Piggott•Antiquity•1965

  • The archaeomusicology of Scandinavia

    Cajsa S Lund, Cajsa Lund•World Archaeology•1981

  • The Perception of the Environment

    T Ingold•The Perception of the Environment•2002

  • A phenomenology of landscape

    Open Access•John C Barrett, Ilhong Ko•Journal of Social Archaeology•2009

  • Mediational techniques and conceptual frameworks in archaeology

    Open Access•Timothy Webmoor•Journal of Social Archaeology•2005

  • Three Rooms

    Open Access•Michael Shanks•Journal of Social Archaeology•2004

  • Seeing Things

    Open Access•Richard Bradley•Journal of Social Archaeology•2003

  • Embodying a Site

    Open Access•Alessandra Lopez Y Royo•Journal of Material Culture•2005

  • The past of the present. Archaeological memory and time

    Open Access•Laurent Olivier•Archaeological Dialogues•2004

Unique citing works71
Citations per year1,27
Citation span1970 - 2026 (57)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 71
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae