Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

An Ellipsis Approach to Contrastive Left-Dislocation

Bibliographic Data

ID4829467
AuthorsDana Ott (0000-0002-9573-2348, Humboldt University of Berlin, Department of German Studies and Linguistics, Unter den Linden 6, 10099 Berlin, Germany, corresponding author), Dennis Ott
Year2014
Volume45
Issue2
Pages269-303
Publication date2014-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueLinguistic Inquiry (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0024-3892 • E-ISSN: 1530-9150
PublisherThe MIT Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1162/ling_a_00155
OpenAlexW2140852736
LanguageEN
Citations received48
References cited66

This article proposes a novel analysis of contrastive left-dislocation (CLD), according to which the left-dislocated XP is a remnant of clausal ellipsis. This analysis makes sense of the otherwise paradoxical fact that the dislocated XP shows connectivity into the clause it precedes, while other properties betray its clause-external status. The paradox is resolved by analyzing CLD as a juxtaposition of two parallel clauses, the first of which is reduced by deletion at PF. Akin to recent treatments of sluicing, fragment answers, split questions, and other phenomena, the analysis reduces CLD to an interplay of Ā-movement and ellipsis, thereby removing constructional residue from the theory of Universal Grammar

Contrastive analysis · Dislocation · Ellipsis (linguistics) · Grammar · Linguistics · Physics · Computer Science · Language, Discourse, Communication Strategies · Mathematics · Natural Language Processing Techniques · Philosophy · Syntax, Semantics, Linguistic Variation

  • What is Germanic and what is not about Old French V2

    Espen Klævik-Pettersen•Linguistic Variation•2019

  • Non‐sentential vs. Ellipsis Approaches

    Open Access•Ljiljana Progovac•Language and Linguistics Compass•2013

  • Thinking in the right direction

    Open Access•Dana Ott, Dennis Ott et al.•Linguistics in the Netherlands•2012

  • Left Dislocation

    Open Access•Artemis Alexiadou•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2017

  • The Oxford Handbook of Information Structure

    Caroline Fery, Shinichiro Ishihara•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2016

  • The Oxford Handbook of Ellipsis

    Jeroen Van Craenenbroeck, Tanja Temmerman•Oxford Handbook of Ellipsis•2018

  • Verum Focus

    Horst Lohnstein•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2015

  • Information Structure in Slavic

    Katja Jasinskaja•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2014

  • Information Structure and Discourse Particles

    Patrick Georg Grosz•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2015

  • Ellipsis in Spanish

    Open Access•Andrés Fábregas•Borealis – An International…•2023

  • Intervention effects in Catalan agrammatism

    Open Access•Io Salmons, Anna Gavarró•Glossa a journal of general…•2022

  • A note on negation, focus, and bias in Greek polar questions

    Open Access•Evripidis Tsiakmakis•Glossa a journal of general…•2025

  • Intervention effects in clefts

    Open Access•Giuseppe Samo, Paola Merlo•Glossa a journal of general…•2021

  • A biclausal account of Clitic Left-Dislocations with epithets in Rioplatense Spanish

    Open Access•Bruno Estigarribia•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • Experimental evidence suggests that null complement anaphora in Russian is not reducible to clausal ellipsis

    Open Access•Mikhail Knyazev•Folia Linguistica•2026

  • Topicalization, Dislocation and Clitic Resumption

    Open Access•Silvio Cruschina•Studia Linguistica•2022

  • The Syntax of Two Types of Gapping in Spanish

    Open Access•Wonsuk Jung•Studia Linguistica•2023

  • On the Syntax of Vp Dislocation in Mandarin

    Open Access•Wei-Cherng Sam Jheng•Studia Linguistica•2023

  • Korean Specificational Pseudoclefts as Caseless Focus Nominal Extraction

    Open Access•Dongwoo Park•Studia Linguistica•2021

  • How large is the left periphery of Present-Day German? A unifying approach to multiply-filled-prefield configurations

    Open Access•Nicholas Catasso•Open Linguistics•2021

  • La sintaxis del discurso y las relaciones de dependencia entre oraciones

    Open Access•Teresa María Rodríguez Ramalle•Círculo de lingüística aplicada a…•2025

  • Parallel copying in dislocation copying

    Open Access•Jackie Yan‐ki Lai, Jackie Yan-Ki Lai•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2019

  • Right dislocation and raising-to-object in Zulu

    Claire Halpert, Jochen Zeller•The Linguistic Review•2015

  • Hanging Topic Left Dislocations as extrasentential constituents

    Open Access•Julio Villa-García•The Linguistic Review•2023

  • VP-fronting

    Dana Ott, Dennis Ott•The Linguistic Review•2018

  • Voice and Ellipsis

    Jason Merchant•Linguistic Inquiry•2013

  • Syntactic Identity in Sluicing

    Sandra Chung•Linguistic Inquiry•2013

  • Fragment answers with infinitives in a Flemish dialect

    Open Access•Kathy Rys, Albert Oosterhof•Linguistics in the Netherlands•2016

  • Hanging Topic Left Dislocations in seemingly embedded contexts

    Open Access•Julio Villa-García•Journal of Linguistics•2025

  • Recomplementation as a paratactic phenomenon

    Open Access•Julio Villa-García, Dana Ott•Journal of Linguistics•2022

  • Case mismatching in Icelandic clausal ellipsis

    Open Access•J Wood, Matthew Barros et al.•Journal of Linguistics•2019

  • Icelandic Object Extraposition Is Still a Problem for the Movement Theory of Control

    J Wood•Linguistic Inquiry•2017

  • On “sluicing” with apparent massive pied-piping

    Open Access•Klaus Abels•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2019

  • Predicate fronting in Yiddish and conditions on multiple copy Spell-Out

    Open Access•Isaac L Bleaman•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2022

  • Prosody as syntactic evidence

    Open Access•Justin Royer•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2022

  • Right-dislocation as deletion

    Open Access•Dana Ott, Dennis Ott et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2016

  • Negation and the functional sequence

    Open Access•Karen De Clercq, Guido Vanden Wyngaerd•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2019

  • Microvariation in the Distribution of Resumptive Pronouns in the Left Dislocation Construction in Two Tyrolean Dialects of Northern Italy

    Open Access•Federica Cognola, Jan Casalicchio•Languages•2023

  • Evidential Adverbs and Polarity

    Open Access•Teresa María Rodríguez Ramalle•Languages•2023

  • Middle-Passive Constructions, Dative Possessors, and Word Order in Spanish

    Open Access•Imanol Suárez-Palma•Languages•2023

  • The Syntax-Pragmatics Interface in Heritage Languages

    Open Access•Jan Casalicchio, Manuela Caterina Moroni•Languages•2023

  • Connectivity in left-dislocation and the composition of the left periphery

    Dana Ott, Dennis Ott•Linguistic Variation•2015

  • Dislocations

    Open Access•Javier Fernández-Sánchez, Dana Ott•Language and Linguistics Compass•2020

  • On the Nonexistence of Asymmetric DOM in Spanish

    Andrés Saab, Pablo Zdrojewski•Linguistic Inquiry•2021

  • Contrasting Contrastive Left-Dislocation Explications

    Open Access•Marcel Den Dikken, Balázs Surányi•Linguistic Inquiry•2017

  • On the Parataxis of Arabic split questions

    Open Access•Ali Alzayid•Syntax•2024

  • Symmetric Merge and Local Instability

    Open Access•Dana Ott, Dennis Ott•Syntax•2015

  • Focus Licensing at the Left Periphery in Japanese Right Dislocation

    Open Access•Jun Abe•Syntax•2019

  • Knowledge of language

    Noam Chomsky•Knowledge of language•1986

  • Materials on Left Dislocation

    Elena Anagnostopoulou, Henk Van Riemsdijk et al.•Materials on left dislocation•1997

  • The Blackwell Companion to Syntax

    Open Access•Martin Everaert, Henk Van Riemsdijk•Blackwell Companion to Syntax•2006

  • The Polysynthesis Parameter

    Mark C Baker•The polysynthesis parameter•1996

  • Prolific Domains

    Kleanthes K Grohmann•Prolific domains•2003

  • Ellipsis

    Anne Lobeck, Anne C Lobeck•Ellipsis•1995

  • The Syntax of German

    Open Access•Hubert Haider•Syntax of German•2010

  • Core Syntax

    David Adger•Core syntax•2003

  • The Syntax of Silence

    Jason Merchant•The syntax of silence•2001

  • Fragments and ellipsis

    Open Access•Jason Merchant•Linguistics and Philosophy•2005

  • The Fine Structure of the Left Periphery

    Laura Rizzi, Luigi Rizzi•Elements of Grammar•1997

  • Semantic Interpretation In Generative Grammar

    Ray S Jackendoff•Semantic Interpretation In…•1974

  • The Syntax and Semantics of the Left Periphery

    Horst Lohnstein, Susanne Trissler•Syntax and Semantics of the Left…•2004

  • Incomplete Category Fronting

    Open Access•G Muller•Incomplete Category Fronting•1998

  • Left dislocation in Germanic

    Cedric Boeckx, Kleanthes K Grohmann•Focus on Germanic Typology•2014

  • The Syntax of Icelandic

    Open Access•Hoskuldur Thrainsson, Höskuldur Þráinsson•Syntax of Icelandic•2007

  • Grundriss der deutschen Grammatik

    Open Access•Peter Eisenberg, Rolf Thieroff•Grundriss Der Deutschen Grammatik•2013

  • Swiping in Germanic

    Jason Merchant•Studies in Comparative Germanic…•2002

  • Formen der "Herausstellung" im Deutschen

    Hans Altmann•Formen der Herausstellung Im…•1981

  • Syntactic Structures

    Noam Chomsky•Syntactic Structures•1957

  • Grundzüge einer deutschen Grammatik

    Gerhart Lindner•Grundlagen und Anwendung der…•1981

  • On Complementation in Icelandic

    Hoskuldur Thrainsson, Höskuldur Þráinsson•On Complementation in Icelandic•2014

  • Lectures on Government and Binding

    Noam Chomsky•Lectures on Government and Binding•1993

  • The Polysynthesis Parameter

    Jean-Pierre Koenig, Karin Michelson et al.•Language•1998

  • Syntactic identity and ellipsis

    Hidekazu Tanaka•The Linguistic Review•2011

  • Reverse sluicing in English and Greek

    Anastasia Giannakidou, Jason Merchant•The Linguistic Review•1998

  • The left and right periphery in Dutch

    Mark De Vries•The Linguistic Review•2009

  • Contrastive topics decomposed

    Open Access•Michael Wagner•Semantics and Pragmatics•2012

  • ‘Verb floating’ and VP-ellipsis

    Gary Thoms•Linguistic Variation Yearbook•2010

  • Thinking in the right direction

    Open Access•Dana Ott, Dennis Ott et al.•Linguistics in the Netherlands•2012

  • Left dislocation, topicalization, and interjections

    Open Access•Gerald R Greenberg•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1984

  • Ellipsis in split questions

    Open Access•Karlos Arregi•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2010

  • Empty categories, case, and configurationality

    Open Access•Eloise Jelinek•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1984

  • The syntax of Dutch embedded fragment answers

    Open Access•Tanja Temmerman•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2013

  • Right-dislocation as deletion

    Open Access•Dana Ott, Dennis Ott et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2016

  • The syntax of answers to polar questions in English and Swedish

    Open Access•Anders Holmberg•Lingua•2013

  • Pronominal doubling under predicate topicalization

    Open Access•Anikó Lipták, Luis Vicente et al.•Lingua•2009

  • Sluicing and logical form

    Open Access•Sandra Chung, William A Ladusaw et al.•Natural Language Semantics•1995

  • Connectivity in left-dislocation and the composition of the left periphery

    Dana Ott, Dennis Ott•Linguistic Variation•2015

  • Syntactic Identity in Sluicing

    Sandra Chung•Linguistic Inquiry•2013

  • Epithets as Antilogophoric Pronouns

    Stanley Dubinsky, Robert Hamilton•Linguistic Inquiry•1998

  • Rescue by PF Deletion, Traces as (Non)interveners, and the That-Trace Effect

    Zeljko Boskovic•Linguistic Inquiry•2011

  • Voice and Ellipsis

    Jason Merchant•Linguistic Inquiry•2013

  • Successive-Cyclic Movement and Island Repair

    Danny Fox, Howard Lasnik•Linguistic Inquiry•2003

  • The Italian Left Periphery

    Klaus Abels•Linguistic Inquiry•2012

  • Symmetric Merge and Local Instability

    Open Access•Dana Ott, Dennis Ott•Syntax•2015

  • A sentential subject asymmetry in English and its implications for complement selection

    Open Access•Peter Alrenga•Syntax•2005

  • The crosslinguistic syntax of sluicing

    Open Access•Jeroen Van Craenenbroeck, Anikó Lipták•Syntax•2006

  • Contrast and Island Sensitivity in Clausal Ellipsis

    Open Access•James E Griffiths, James Griffiths et al.•Syntax•2014

  • Invisible Last Resort

    Open Access•Jeroen Van Craenenbroeck•Lingua•2010

Unique citing works48
Citations per year3,43
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 45
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae