Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Understanding 'anticipatory governance

Bibliographic Data

ID5776521
AuthorsDavid H Guston (Arizona State University, corresponding author)
Year2013
Volume44
Issue2
Pages218-242
Publication date2013-11-15
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSocial Studies of Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0306-3127 • E-ISSN: 1460-3659
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0306312713508669
PMID24941612
OpenAlexW2128217744
LanguageEN
Citations received287
References cited69

Anticipatory governance is 'a broad-based capacity extended through society that can act on a variety of inputs to manage emerging knowledge-based technologies while such management is still possible'. It motivates activities designed to build capacities in foresight, engagement, and integration - as well as through their production ensemble. These capacities encourage and support the reflection of scientists, engineers, policy makers, and other publics on their roles in new technologies. This article reviews the early history of the National Nanotechnology Initiative in the United States, and it further explicates anticipatory governance through exploring the genealogy of the term and addressing a set of critiques found in the literature. These critiques involve skepticism of three proximities of anticipatory governance: to its object, nanotechnology, which is a relatively indistinct one; to the public, which remains almost utterly naïve toward nanotechnology; and to technoscience itself, which allegedly renders anticipatory governance complicit in its hubris. The article concludes that the changing venues and the amplification within them of the still, small voices of folks previously excluded from offering constructive visions of futures afforded by anticipatory governance may not be complete solutions to our woes in governing technology, but they certainly can contribute to bending the long arc of technoscience more toward humane ends

Deliberation · Futures studies · Skepticism · Technoscience · Vision · Innovation, Sustainability, Human-Machine Systems · Nanotechnology research and applications · Neuroethics, Human Enhancement, Biomedical Innovations

  • Smart Governance and the Direction of Innovation

    Open Access•Elias G Carayannis, Nikos-Rigert Zota•Technology in Society•2026

  • Affordance Entrenchment Analysis

    Open Access•Ryan Wittingslow•Technology in Society•2026

  • The Practices of Making Innovation Public

    Open Access•Sujatha Raman•Engaging Science Technology and…•2015

  • Governance logics and foresight functions

    Open Access•Natalia Veselitskaya, Dina Malekova•European Journal of Futures…•2026

  • U.S. wildfire governance as social-ecological problem

    Open Access•Toddi A Steelman, Toddi Steelman•Conservation Ecology•2016

  • Supporting stakeholders to anticipate and respond to risks in a Mekong River water-energy-food nexus

    Open Access•Louise Gallagher, B Kopainsky et al.•Conservation Ecology•2020

  • Implications of Panarchy for ecosystem service research

    Open Access•Klara J Winkler, Karina Benessaiah et al.•Conservation Ecology•2022

  • Beyond the Binaries

    Open Access•Johanna Ahola-Launonen•Minerva•2026

  • Converging Technologies

    Open Access•James Michael MacFarlane•Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • Nanotechnology

    Open Access•Barbara Herr Harthorn•Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • The tentative governance of emerging science and technology—A conceptual introduction

    Open Access•Stefan Kuhlmann, Peter Stegmaier et al.•Research Policy•2019

  • Governing for Transformative Change across the Biodiversity–Climate–Society Nexus

    Open Access•Unai Pascual, Pamela Mcelwee et al.•BioScience•2022

  • Exploring the normative turn in regional innovation policy

    Open Access•Elvira Uyarra, Bruno Ribeiro et al.•European Planning Studies•2019

  • Governance frictions at work? Explaining socio-technical transformation in waste-to-energy

    Open Access•Danieli Braun Vargas, Stefania Sardo et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2026

  • A participative method to build bridges between sustainability science and anticipatory governance at Urdaibai Biosphere Reserve (Basque Country)

    Open Access•Manu Monge-Ganuzas, Igor Ahedo Gurrutxaga et al.•Oñati Socio-legal Series•2023

  • La anticipación en la búsqueda de una innovación responsable

    Open Access•Sergio Urueña•Recerca•2022

  • Accelerazione e governance della tecnoscienza

    Open Access•Silvia Caianiello•SocietàMutamentoPolitica•2023

  • The neurotechnology patent landscape in a time of neuroethics

    Open Access•Ari Rotenberg, Stacey Anderson-Redick et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Exploring public perspectives on synthetic biology and its integration with sex/gender characteristics

    Open Access•Heajin Kim, Chaewon Lee et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Guardians of science or stewards of society? The role of grant peer reviewer identity in governing socially responsible innovation

    Open Access•Y Wu, Yanyi Wu et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2026

  • Undergraduate Disabled Students as Knowledge Producers Including Researchers

    Open Access•Aspen Lillywhite, G Wolbring•Education Sciences•2022

  • Opening or foreclosing futures? A longitudinal analysis of European bioeconomy foresight (SCAR, 2007–2020)

    Open Access•Julien Vastenaekels•European Journal of Futures…•2026

  • Knowledge governance for the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Serge Clément•Global Policy•2022

  • Why EdTech is always right

    Kevin Witzenberger, Kalervo N Gulson•Learning Media and Technology•2021

  • Anticipatory Governance in Biobanking

    Open Access•Dagmar Vorlíček, Dagmar Rychnovská•Science and Engineering Ethics•2021

  • What generative Artificial Intelligence priorities and challenges do senior Australian educational policy makers identify (and why)

    Open Access•Matt Bower, M Henderson et al.•The Australian Educational…•2025

  • Foresighting future oceans

    Open Access•Rachel Kelly, Paul Foley et al.•Marine Policy•2022

  • Anticipatory gaps challenge the public governance of heritable human genome editing

    Open Access•Jon Rueda Etxeberria, Seppe Segers et al.•Journal of Medical Ethics•2025

  • Synthetic biology and governance research in China

    Open Access•Li Tang, Jennifer Kuzma et al.•Scientometrics•2023

  • Citizen visions of drone uses and impacts in 2057

    Open Access•Marianne Harbo Frederiksen, Patricia Wolf et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2024

  • Blockchain for industrial transformations

    Open Access•Alexandre Pólvora, Susana Nascimento et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2020

  • Anticipatory governance and moral imagination

    Open Access•P Lehoux, Fiona A Miller et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2020

  • Technology readiness levels for policy making

    Open Access•Diana Hicks, Navya Gupta et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2026

  • On different lanes

    Open Access•Veronika Stein, Tim Fraske et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2026

  • A comprehensive appraisal of responsible research and innovation

    Open Access•Martijn Wiarda, Geerten Van De Kaa et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2021

  • Anticipatory governance in government

    Open Access•Johanna Kallo, Jussi Välimaa•Higher Education•2025

  • From Governance to Green Behavior

    Open Access•Quoc Dung Ngo, Tuan Vinh Tran et al.•Environment and Behavior•2025

  • Wicked Crises and the (In)capacity to Act

    Open Access•R E Meyer•Administrative Science Quarterly•2025

  • Reassembling Energy Policy

    Open Access•Stefan C Aykut•Science & Technology Studies•2019

  • Constructing the Meaning of Humanoid Sex Robots

    Open Access•Deborah G Johnson, Mario Verdicchio•International Journal of Social…•2020

  • From EU Robotics and AI Governance to HRI Research

    Open Access•Jesse de Pagter•International Journal of Social…•2024

  • From artificial to artefactual wisdom

    Open Access•Nicolas Merveille•AI & Society•2026

  • Building Anticipatory Capacity for Transformative Resilience

    Open Access•Francesco Cappellano, Cristian Matti et al.•Technology in Society•2026

  • The divide so wide

    Open Access•Jenenne P Nelson, David Tomblin et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2024

  • Imagined futures for livestock gene editing

    Open Access•Senna Middelveld, Phil Macnaghten et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2023

  • Social empathy in public deliberation

    Open Access•Lauren Lambert•Public Understanding of Science•2026

  • From bones to bytes

    Open Access•Máirtín Cunneen, Ruhi AnandFinn et al.•AI & Society•2026

  • Beyond accidents and misuse

    Open Access•Kyle A Kilian•AI & Society•2026

  • Knowledge and support for AI in the public sector

    Open Access•Sveinung Arnesen, Troy Saghaug Broderstad et al.•AI & Society•2025

  • What can science fiction tell us about the future of artificial intelligence policy

    Open Access•Andrew Dana Hudson, Ed Finn et al.•AI & Society•2023

  • Improving Soft Law Governance of the Internet of Things

    Open Access•Jordan M Buckwald, Gary E Marchant•IEEE Technology and Society…•2021

  • Intellectual Virtues and Scientific Endeavor

    Open Access•Oscar Eliezer Mendoza-De Los Santos•Bulletin of Science Technology &…•2023

  • The Decision Phases Framework for Public Engagement

    Open Access•S Kathleen Barnhill‐Dilling, Adam Kokotovich et al.•The Hastings Center Report•2021

  • Surveillance, Privacy and Security

    Open Access•Michaël Friedewald, J Peter Burgess et al.•Surveillance, Privacy and Security•2017

  • Botswana tuberculosis (TB) stakeholders broadly support scaling up next-generation whole genome sequencing

    Open Access•Stephen Molldrem, Sedilame Bagani et al.•PLOS Global Public Health•2023

  • Opportunities for and barriers to anticipatory governance of two lake social–ecological systems in Germany and Canada

    Open Access•Louis Tanguay, Laura M Herzog et al.•People and Nature•2023

  • Sustainable commercialization of new crops for the agricultural bioeconomy

    Open Access•Neil R Jordan, Kevin Dorn et al.•Elementa Science of the…•2016

  • Responsible innovation in biotechnology

    Open Access•Pat Roberts, Joseph R Herkert et al.•Elementa Science of the…•2020

  • The complexity of the gene and the precision of CRISPR

    Open Access•Esha Shah, David Ludwig et al.•Elementa Science of the…•2021

  • Building capacity to govern emerging climate intervention technologies

    Open Access•Zachary Dove, Sikina Jinnah et al.•Elementa Science of the…•2024

  • Citizen expectations of ‘academic entrepreneurship’ in health research

    Open Access•Fiona A Miller, Michael Painter‐Main et al.•Health Expectations•2015

  • Anticipatory governance of a maritime mission using a real-time mission-oriented transition assessment

    Open Access•Jurrit Bergsma, Martijn Wiarda et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2026

  • The role of adaptive governance in disaster risk reduction

    Nikita Agarwalla, Pradeep Kumar Parida•Climate and Development•2026

  • Consensus or Contestation

    Open Access•G Valkenburg•Science Technology and Society•2020

  • Administrative Friction

    Open Access•Renato Base•Administration & Society•2026

  • Reclaiming urban nature

    Open Access•F De Molli•Cities•2026

  • Configurational pathways to smart city AI adoption

    Open Access•Tan Yigitcanlar, Ke Liu et al.•Cities•2026

  • Ethical playgrounds

    Open Access•Wenzel Mehnert, Michael J Bernstein et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2026

  • Reforming Export Control Regimes

    Open Access•Stella Blumfelde•Global Policy•2026

  • Anticipatory governance of digital platforms

    Open Access•Lin Huang, Guihua Li•Telecommunications Policy•2026

  • Auditing the ‘Social’ of Quantum Technologies

    Open Access•G Wolbring•Societies•2022

  • Anticipatory governance of solar geoengineering

    Open Access•Aarti Gupta, Ina Möller et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2020

  • Imagining the public

    Open Access•Larry Au•BioSocieties•2022

  • Beyond checklists

    Open Access•Asle H Kiran, Nelly Oudshoorn et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2015

  • The objects of technology assessment. Hermeneutic extension of consequentialist reasoning

    Open Access•Armin Grunwald•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2019

  • From foresight to hindsight

    Open Access•James Wilsdon•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2014

  • Knowledge kills action – why principles should play a limited role in policy-making

    Open Access•J Britt Holbrook, Adam Briggle•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2014

  • Neuroethics and the NIH BRAIN Initiative

    Open Access•Khara M Ramos, Karen S Rommelfanger et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2017

  • Challenge-driven innovation and responsible innovation

    Open Access•Achim Rosemann, Susan Molyneux‐hodgson•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2023

  • Power to the Public

    Sara El-Sayed

  • Ethics in the Metaverse

    Open Access•Kalli Giannelos•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2026

  • Governing digital innovations for responsible outcomes – the case of digital healthcare and welfare services

    Open Access•Raj Kumar Thapa, Tatiana Iakovleva•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2025

  • Responsible innovation

    Open Access•David H Guston, Erik Fisher et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2014

  • Anticipation and its degrees of critical-reflective radicality

    Open Access•Sergio Urueña•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2024

  • Democratizing science, technology, and innovation — what do we mean

    Open Access•Philipp Neudert•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2026

  • Responsible innovation ecosystem governance

    Open Access•Mareike Smolka, Stefan Böschen•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2023

  • Value beyond scientific validity

    Open Access•M Wienroth•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2020

  • Process, outcomes, virtues

    Open Access•Sophie Pellé•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2016

  • Why do newly industrialized economies deter to adopt responsible research and innovation

    Open Access•Eunok Ko, Jungsub Yoon et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2020

  • The neurotechnology and society interface

    Open Access•Diana M Bowman, Hermann Garden et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2018

  • Traditional ecological knowledge in innovation governance

    Open Access•David Ludwig, Phil Macnaghten•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2019

  • Imagining socio-technical futures – challenges and opportunities for technology assessment

    Open Access•Ulrike Bechtold, Daniela Fuchs et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2017

  • Eclectic, random, intuitive? Technology assessment, RRI, and their use of history

    Open Access•Silke Zimmer-Merkle, Torsten Fleischer•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2017

  • On not forgetting futures

    Open Access•Cynthia Selin•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2014

  • A roadmap for gene drives

    Open Access•Jennifer Kuzma, Fred Gould et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2017

  • The hermeneutic side of responsible research and innovation

    Open Access•Armin Grunwald•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2014

  • A comparative, sociotechnical design perspective on Responsible Innovation

    Open Access•David J He, Dasom Lee et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2021

  • Mapping the integrative field

    Open Access•Erik Fisher, Michael O’rourke et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2015

  • Privacy designs, technological sovereignty and digital pandemic response-ability

    Open Access•Nel Van Dijk, Niels Van Dijk et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2026

  • Responsible innovation as empowering ways of knowing

    Open Access•G Valkenburg, Annapurna Mamidipudi et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2019

  • Societal Implications of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology

    Open Access•Mihail C Roco, William Sims Bainbridge•Societal Implications of…•2001

  • Science in Democracy

    Michael B Brown, Mark B Brown•Science in democracy•2009

  • Street-Level Bureaucracy

    Michael Lipsky•Michigan Law Review•1981

  • Reinventing Government

    David Osborne•Public Productivity & Management…•1993

  • Anticipatory Governance

    Ray Quay•Journal of the American Planning…•2010

  • The past and future of constructive technology assessment

    Open Access•Johan Schot, Arie Rip•Technological Forecasting and…•1997

  • Handbook of Science and Technology Studies

    Sheila Jasanoff, Gerald E Markle et al.•Handbook of Science and…•1995

  • Building the capacity for public engagement with science in the United States

    Open Access•David H Guston•Public Understanding of Science•2014

  • Public engagement coming of age

    Open Access•A Delgado, Kamilla Lein Kjølberg et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2011

  • Acting in an uncertain world

    Yannick Barthe, Michel Callon et al.•Choice Reviews Online•2010

  • Will small be beautiful? Making policies for our nanotech future

    W Patrick Mccray•History and Technology•2005

  • If and Then

    Open Access•Alfred Nordmann•NanoEthics•2007

  • The Sociology of the Future

    Open Access•Cynthia Selin•Sociology Compass•2008

  • Engaging the Public in Public Policy

    Larry Bell•Museums & Social Issues•2009

  • Too Little, Too Late? Research Policies on the Societal Implications of Nanotechnology in the United States

    Ira Bennett, Daniel Sarewitz•Science as Culture•2006

  • Compressed Foresight and Narrative Bias

    Robin Williams•Science as Culture•2006

  • Lost in Translation? The Need for ‘Upstream Engagement’ with Nanotechnology on Trial

    Pierre-Benoit Joly, Pierre‐benoit Joly et al.•Science as Culture•2008

  • Responsibility and nanotechnology

    Open Access•Elise Mccarthy, C M Kelty et al.•Social Studies of Science•2010

  • The Long History of Molecular Electronics

    Open Access•Hyungsub Choi, Cyrus C M Mody•Social Studies of Science•2009

  • Citizen engagement and urban change

    Open Access•Sarah R Davies, Cynthia Selin et al.•Cities•2012

  • Envisioning nanotechnology

    Open Access•Cynthia Selin, Rebecca Hudson•Technology in Society•2010

  • Real-time technology assessment

    Open Access•David H Guston, Daniel Sarewitz•Technology in Society•2002

  • Cultural Boundaries of Science

    Peter Whalley, Thomas F Gieryn•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2001

  • Directed Evolution

    Open Access•Eun-Sook Kim, Eun-Sung Kim•Minerva•2008

  • Science for the post-normal age

    Open Access•Silvio Funtowicz, Silvio O Funtowicz et al.•Futures•1993

  • The New Behemoth

    Open Access•Fuller, Steve Fuller•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2010

  • Unpackaging synthetic biology

    Open Access•Jennifer Kuzma, Todd Tanji•Regulation & Governance•2010

  • "The Science of "Muddling Through

    Charles E Lindblom•Public Administration Review•1959

  • Responsible research and innovation

    Roger Owens, R Owen et al.•Science and Public Policy•2012

  • Informing, involving or engaging? Science communication, in the ages of atom-, bio- and nanotechnology

    Open Access•Monika Kurath, Priska Gisler•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • Anticipation

    Open Access•Vincanne Adams, Michelle Murphy et al.•Subjectivity•2009

  • Dazzled by the Mirage of Influence

    Open Access•Brian Wynne•Science Technology & Human Values•2007

  • How Many Policy Rooms are There

    Open Access•Helga Nowotny•Science Technology & Human Values•2007

  • Crossing Boundaries Social Science in the Policy Room

    Open Access•Andrew Webster•Science Technology & Human Values•2007

  • The Handbook of Science and Technology Studies

    Open Access•Charles Camic•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2009

  • Designing Human Practices

    Paul Rabinow, Gaymon Bennett•Designing human practices•2012

Unique citing works287
Citations per year20,5
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 279
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae