Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Take a Stand Commentary

How Can Medical Anthropologists Contribute to Contemporary Conversations on “Illegal” Im/migration and Health

Bibliographic Data

ID7199453
AuthorsWillen (0000-0002-0827-0510, University of Connecticut), Sarah S Willen, Jessica Mulligan (0000-0001-8165-7722, Providence College), H Castaneda (0000-0001-5892-3279, University of South Florida)
Year2011
Volume25
Issue3
Pages331-356
Publication date2011-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueMedical Anthropology Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0745-5194 • E-ISSN: 1548-1387
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.1548-1387.2011.01164.x
PMID22007561
OpenAlexW2137944923
LanguageEN
Citations received29
References cited74

Of the estimated 214 million people who have migrated from poorer to richer countries in search of a better life, between 20 and 30 million have migrated on an unauthorized, or “illegal,” basis. All have health needs, or will in the future, yet most are denied health care available to citizens and authorized residents. To many, unauthorized im/migrants’ exclusion intuitively “makes sense.” As scholars of health, social justice, and human rights, we find this logic deeply flawed and are committed to advancing a constructive program of engaged critique. In this commentary, we call on medical anthropologists to claim an active role in reframing scholarly and public debate about this pressing global health issue. We outline four key theoretical issues and five action steps that will help us sharpen our research agenda and translate ourselves for colleagues in partner disciplines and for broader audiences engaged in policymaking, politics, public health, and clinical practice . [unauthorized im/migration, “illegality,” social determinants of health, “deservingness,” public anthropology

Criminology · Sociology · Global Security and Public Health · Health and Conflict Studies · Migration, Health and Trauma

  • The health of migrants passing through Serbia

    Open Access•Ela Meh•Glasnik Etnografskog instituta•2017

  • Societies’ hostility, anger and mistrust towards Migrants

    Open Access•Maria José da Silva Rebelo, Mercedes Fernández García et al.•Journal of Social Work•2021

  • Building a Life Despite It All

    Open Access•SaraJane Renfroe•Journal for Undergraduate…•2020

  • Mobility, Latino Migrants, and the Geography of Sex Work

    T Sangaramoorthy, Karen Kroeger•Human Organization•2013

  • Damned If You Drive, Damned If You Don’t

    Jennifer R Guzmán, Melanie A Medeiros•Human Organization•2020

  • Ultimate Introvert’ to the ‘Touchy-Chummy’

    Open Access•Timi Lynne Barone, Samantha K Ammon et al.•Teaching Anthropology•2021

  • Health at the Intersections of Precarious Documentation Status and Gender-Based Partner Violence

    Open Access•Nia Parson, Rebecca Escobar et al.•Violence Against Women•2014

  • Cessation Clauses, Uncertain Futures and Wellbeing among Rwandan Urban Refugees in Cameroon

    Open Access•Kelly A Yotebieng, Kelly Yotebieng et al.•Journal of Refugee Studies•2018

  • Back There We Had Nothing to Eat”

    Open Access•Megan A Carney•International Migration•2017

  • Challenges in access to health care among involuntary migrants in Germany. A case study of migrants' experiences in Oldenburg, Lower Saxony

    Open Access•Anas Ansar, Frida Johansson et al.•International Migration•2017

  • Generation, Displacement, and Deservedness among Karen Refugees in California

    Open Access•K E Yarris, Jillian C Stasiun et al.•International Migration•2014

  • Biopolitics of public health and immigration in times of crisis

    Open Access•Panagiota Kotsila, G Kallis•Geoforum•2019

  • The biopolitics of 'food insecurity

    Open Access•Megan A Carney, Megan Carney•Journal of Political Ecology•2014

  • Ethical and Epistemological Implications of Conducting Ethnographic Fieldwork as a Researcher-cum-Clinician in Brussels, Belgium

    Open Access•Dirk Lafaut, Lisa Dikomitis•Medical Anthropology•2024

  • Is coverage enough? Persistent health disparities in marginalised Latino border communities

    H Castaneda•New Community•2017

  • Who Will Pick Georgia's Vidalia Onions? A Text-Driven Content Analysis of Newspaper Coverage on Georgia's 2011 Immigration Law

    J S Luque, John Luque et al.•Human Organization•2013

  • Cholera control and anti-Haitian stigma in the Dominican Republic

    Hunter M Keys, Hunter Keys et al.•Anthropology and Medicine•2019

  • When deservingness policies converge

    Nolan Kline, Nolan S Kline•Anthropology and Medicine•2019

  • Neocolonialism and Health Care Access among Marshall Islanders in the United States

    Open Access•Michael Duke, Michael R Duke•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2017

  • Eating and Feeding at the Margins of the State

    Open Access•Megan A Carney•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2015

  • Buffering the Uneven Impact of the Affordable Care Act

    Open Access•C M Getrich, Jacqueline M García et al.•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2018

  • Risk entrepreneurship and the construction of healthcare deservingness for 'desirable', 'acceptable' and 'disposable' migrants in Malaysia

    Open Access•Meghann Ormond, Alice M Nah•New Community•2020

  • Navigating a fragmented health care landscape

    Open Access•C M Getrich, Kaelin Rapport et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2019

  • Health workers' perceptions of access to care for children and pregnant women with precarious immigration status

    Open Access•Karine Vanthuyne, Francesca Meloni et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2013

  • Migration, "illegality," and health

    Open Access•Willen, Sarah S Willen•Social Science & Medicine•2012

  • How is health-related "deservingness" reckoned? Perspectives from unauthorized im/migrants in Tel Aviv

    Open Access•Willen, Sarah S Willen•Social Science & Medicine•2012

  • The clinical gaze in the practice of migrant health

    Open Access•M Holme, Seth M Holme•Social Science & Medicine•2012

  • Undocumented immigrants and their use of medical services in Orange County, California

    Open Access•L R Chavez•Social Science & Medicine•2012

  • Intangible obstacles

    Open Access•Stéphanie Larchanché•Social Science & Medicine•2012

  • Efficient spatial separation of charge carriers over Sv-ZnIn2S4/NH2-MIL-88B(Fe) S-scheme heterojunctions for enhanced photocatalytic H2 evolution and antibiotics removal performance

    Open Access•Wei Li, Mary-Jo DelVecchio-Good et al.•Journal of Colloid and Interface…•2024

  • An Ethnographic Study of the Social Context of Migrant Health in the United States

    Open Access•M Holme, Seth M Holmes et al.•PLoS Medicine•2006

  • Legal Status And Health Insurance Among Immigrants

    Dana P Goldman, James P Smith et al.•Health Affairs•2005

  • Health Care Use Among Undocumented Latino Immigrants

    Marc L Berk, Claudia L Schur et al.•Health Affairs•2000

  • Closing the gap in a generation

    Open Access•Michael Marmot, Sharon Friel et al.•The Lancet•2008

  • Latino Immigrants

    Open Access•Jen Pylypa•Journal of Immigrant Health•2001

  • Managed Care or Managed Inequality? A Call for Critiques of Market‐Based Medicine

    Open Access•Barbara Rylko‐bauer, Paul Farmer•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2002

  • Illegal Immigrants, Health Care, and Social Responsibility

    James Dwyer•The Hastings Center Report•2004

  • Impossible Subjects

    Mae M Ngai•Choice Reviews Online•2004

  • Medical Humanitarianism and Physicians' Organized Efforts to Provide Aid to Unauthorized Migrants in Germany

    H Castaneda•Human Organization•2011

  • It Really Opened My Eyes

    Keiko Goto, Gretel Pelto et al.•Human Organization•2010

  • Counseling Contraception for Malian Migrants in Paris

    Carolyn Sargent•Human Organization•2005

  • Expert Witness

    Open Access•Asale Angel‐ajani•Anthropology & Humanism•2004

  • Healthcare Access and Barriers for Unauthorized Immigrants in El Paso County, Texas

    Josiah Mcc Heyman, Guillermina Gina Núñez et al.•Family & Community Health•2009

  • Immigrants Raising Citizens

    Başak Yavçan•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2011

  • A Review of Tenure and Promotion Guidelines in Higher Education

    Open Access•Linda A Bennett, Sunil K Khanna•American Anthropologist•2010

  • A Sea Change in Anthropology? Public Anthropology Reviews

    Open Access•Melissa Checker, David Vine et al.•American Anthropologist•2010

  • The New Poverty Studies

    Mark Robert Rank, Judith Goode et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2003

  • Restrictions on Undocumented Immigrants’ Access to Health Services

    Jeffrey T Kullgren•American Journal of Public Health•2003

  • The Price of Citizenship

    Joanne L Goodwin, Joanne Goodwin et al.•Journal of American History•2002

  • Oaxacans Like to Work Bent Over”

    Open Access•M Holme, Seth M Holmes•International Migration•2007

  • Health Care Access for Refugees and Immigrants with Precarious Status

    Open Access•C Rousseau, Sonia ter Kuile et al.•Canadian Journal of Public Health•2008

  • Finding a Moral Heart for U.S. Immigration Policy

    B Coutin, Susan C B Coutin et al.•Anthropological Quarterly•1999

  • Right and access to healthcare for undocumented children

    Open Access•Mónica Ruiz-Casares, C Rousseau et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2009

  • Botánicas in America’s Backyard

    A Viladrich•Human Organization•2006

  • Sidewalk Radio

    Open Access•Jim Igoe•American Anthropologist•2010

  • Challenging Hegemonies

    Jean J Schensul, Marlene J Berg et al.•Collaborative anthropologies•2008

  • "Toward a Critical Phenomenology of "Illegality

    Open Access•Willen, Sarah S Willen•International Migration•2007

  • Community-Based Research Partnerships

    Meredith Minkler•Journal of Urban Health•2005

  • Im/Migration and Health

    Open Access•H Castaneda•NAPA Bulletin•2010

  • Engaging With the Immigrant Human Rights Movement in a Besieged Border Region

    Open Access•Josiah Mcc Heyman, M C Morales et al.•NAPA Bulletin•2009

  • How is health-related "deservingness" reckoned? Perspectives from unauthorized im/migrants in Tel Aviv

    Open Access•Willen, Sarah S Willen•Social Science & Medicine•2012

  • Visualizing sexual assault

    Open Access•D White, Janice Du Mont•Social Science & Medicine•2009

  • The Muslim Body and the Politics of Immigration in France

    Open Access•Carolyn Sargent, Stéphanie Larchanché•Body & Society•2007

  • Migration, "illegality," and health

    Open Access•Willen, Sarah S Willen•Social Science & Medicine•2012

  • Our health and theirs

    Open Access•Natalie J Grove, Anthony B Zwi•Social Science & Medicine•2006

  • Illegality as risk factor

    Open Access•H Castaneda•Social Science & Medicine•2009

  • Vernacularization on the ground

    Open Access•P Levitt, Sally Engle Merry et al.•Global Networks•2009

  • Impossible Subjects

    Yen Le Espiritu, Mae M Ngai•Western Historical Quarterly•2005

  • Community Participatory Research in HIV/Aids Prevention

    Open Access•Jon Poehlman•Anthropology in Action•2008

  • Reproductive Strategies and Islamic Discourse

    Open Access•Carolyn F Sargent, Carolyn Sargent•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2006

  • Different Subjects

    Open Access•Horton, Sarah B Horton et al.•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2004

  • Migratory Journeys and Tuberculosis Risk

    Open Access•Ming-Jung Ho, Ming‐jung Ho•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2003

  • Where ethics and politics meet

    Open Access•M Ticktin•American Ethnologist•2006

  • Ethical Theory as Social Practice

    Open Access•Mark Goodale•American Anthropologist•2006

  • Another Politics of Life is Possible

    Open Access•D Fassin•Theory Culture & Society•2009

  • Migrant "Illegality" and Deportability in Everyday Life

    N De Genova, Nicholas P De Genova•Annual Review of Anthropology•2002

  • Immigrant Voices

    Open Access•Deborah Nelson•American Anthropologist•2010

  • Blogging Anthropology

    Open Access•David H Price•American Anthropologist•2010

  • Stigmatized Biologies

    Open Access•Horton, Sarah B Horton et al.•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2010

  • Health Is Hard Here" or "Health for All

    Open Access•Kathryn Goldade•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2009

  • La Tecnología y Las Monjitas

    Open Access•Jill Fleuriet, K Jill Fleuriet•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2009

  • What Can Critical Medical Anthropology Contribute to Global Health

    Open Access•J Pfeiffer, M Nichter•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2008

  • Paternity for Sale

    Open Access•H Castaneda•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2008

  • Making anthropology public

    Open Access•Nancy Scheper‐hughe, Nancy Scheper‐Hughes•Anthropology Today•2009

  • Collaborative Ethnography and Public Anthropology

    Luke Eric Lassiter•Current Anthropology•2005

  • Biocommunicability and the Biopolitics of Pandemic Threats

    Charles L Briggs, M Nichter•Medical Anthropology•2009

Unique citing works29
Citations per year2,07
Citation span2012 - 2024 (13)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 28
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae