Cost comparison of a rapid results initiative against standard clinic-based model to scale-up voluntary medical male circumcision in Kenya

Voluntary male medical circumcision (VMMC) reduces HIV acquisition by up to 60%. Kenya has successfully scaled up VMMC to an estimated 91% of eligible men and boys in certain regions in combination due to VMMC and cultural circumcisions. VMMC as a program is implemented regionally in traditionally non-circumcising counties where the prevalence is still below 91%, ranging from 56.4% to 66.7%. Given that funding toward VMMC is expected to decline in the coming years, it is important to identify what models of service delivery are most appropriate and efficient to sustainably meet the VMMC needs of new cohorts’ eligible men. To this end, we compared the costs of facility-based VMMC and one within a rapid results initiative (RRI), a public health service scheduled during school holidays to perform many procedures over a short period. We employed activity-based micro-costing to estimate the costs, from the implementer perspective, of facility-based VMMC and RRI-based VMMC conducted between October 2017 and September 2018 at 41 sites in Kisumu County, Kenya supported by the Family AIDS care & Education Services (FACES). We conducted site visits and reviewed financial ledger and programmatic data to identify and quantify resources consumed and the number of VMMC procedures performed during routine care and RRIs. Ledger data were used to estimate fixed costs, recurring costs, and cost per circumcision (CPC) in United States dollar (USD). A sensitivity analysis was done to estimate CPC where we allocated 6 months of the ledger to facility-based and 6 months to RRI. Overall, FACES spent $3,092,891 toward VMMC services and performed 42,139 procedures during the funding year. This included $2,644,910 in stable programmatic costs, $139,786 procedure costs, and $308,195 for RRI-specific activities. Over the year, 49% (n = 20,625) of procedures were performed as part of routine care and 51% (n = 21,514) were performed during the RRIs. Procedures conducted during facility-based cost $99.35 per circumcision, those conducted during the RRIs cost $48.51 per circumcision, and according to our sensitivity analysis, CPC for facility-based ranges from $99.35 to $287.24 and for RRI costs ranged from $29.81 to $48.51. The cost of VMMC during the RRI was substantially lower than unit costs reported in previous costing studies. We conclude that circumcision campaigns, such as the RRI, offer an efficient and sustainable approach to VMMC

Geography · Terrorism, Counterterrorism, and Political Violence

• Male circumcision for HIV prevention in young men in Kisumu, Kenya

  Open Access•Robert C Bailey, Robin L Bailey et al.•The Lancet•2007

  Añadir item

• Randomized, Controlled Intervention Trial of Male Circumcision for Reduction of HIV Infection Risk

  Open Access•Bertran Auvert, Dirk Taljaard et al.•PLoS Medicine•2005

  Añadir item

• Religion politics and ethics

  SC Chima, Sylvester C Chima•Nigerian Journal of Clinical…•2015

  Añadir item

• Acceptability of Medical Male Circumcision and Improved Instrument Sanitation Among a Traditionally Circumcising Group in East Africa

  Open Access•Aaron J Siegler, Jessie Mbwambo et al.•AIDS and Behavior•2012

  Añadir item

• HIV prevention costs and their predictors

  Open Access•Omar Galárraga, Richard G Wamai et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2017

  Añadir item

• Causality between transnational terrorism and tourism

  Walter Enders, Tod Sandler et al.•Terrorism•1991

  Añadir item