Saltar al contenido principal

ETHNOS_APP

Inicio • Búsqueda • Revistas • Lista 0

They Live in a State of Nomadism and Savagery

The Late Ottoman Empire and the Post-Colonial Debate

Datos Bibliográficos

ID2108224
AutoresSelim Deringil (Bogaziçi University, autor de correspondencia)
Año2003
Volumen45
Número02
Fecha de publicación2003-04-01
Peer ReviewedSí
Open AccessNo
TipoARTICLE
RevistaComparative Studies in Society and History (JOURNAL)
Identificadores de la revistaISSN: 0010-4175 • E-ISSN: 1475-2999
EditorialCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s001041750300015x
OpenAlexW2164122055
IdiomaEN
Citas recibidas104

The Ottoman Empire was the last great Muslim world empire to survive into the age of modernity. The Ottoman state, together with its contemporaries, Habsburg Austria and Romanov Russia, was engaged in a struggle for survival in a world where it no longer made the rules. As the nineteenth century approached its last quarter, these rules were increasingly determined by the successful and aggressive world powers, Britain, France, and after 1870, Germany. As external pressure on the ottoman Empire mounted from the second half of the century, the Ottoman center found itself obliged to squeeze manpower resources it had hitherto not tapped. Particularly nomadic populations, armed and already possessing the military skills required, now became a primary target for mobilization. This study is an attempt to come to grips with the “civilizing mission” mentality of the late Ottomans and their “project of modernity” as reflected in their provincial administration. It is the view of this writer that sometime in the nineteenth century the Ottoman elite adopted the mindset of their enemies, the arch-imperialists, and came to conceive of its periphery as a colonial setting.My definition of colonialism here closely follows the Leninist position as in “Imperialism the Highest Stage of Capitalism.” In my view, this is still one of the best and most succinct definitions of imperialism. After showing how the partition of the word accelerated in the 1880s, Lenin concludes, “It is beyond doubt therefore, that capitalism's transition to the stage of monopoly capitalism, to finance capital, isconnected with the intensification of the struggle for the partitioning of the world.” V. Lenin, Selected Works (Moscow: Progress Publishers 1977), 224

Ancient history · Archaeology · Colonialism · Economic history · Empire · Ottoman empire · Political science · Politics · State (computer science) · History · Law · Turkey's Politics and Society

  • Microstructural Evidence for Early Childhood Stress in a Community in Transition at Hisban, Jordan

    Open Access•Kristina Cockerille, Akacia Propst et al.•American Journal of Biological…•2026

  • A History of the Ottoman Empire

    Douglas A Howard•History of the Ottoman Empire•2017

  • Negotiating Empire in the Middle East

    Open Access•M Talha Çiçek•Negotiating Empire in the Middle…•2021

  • The Cambridge History of the Kurds

    Open Access•Hamit Bozarslan, Cengiz Gunes et al.•Cambridge History of the Kurds•2021

  • Parameters of a Postcolonial Sociology of the Ottoman Empire

    Open Access•Fatma Muge Gocek•Decentering Social Theory…•2013

  • The History of Kurdish and the Development of Literary Kurmanji

    Open Access•Ergin Öpengin•Cambridge History of the Kurds•2021

  • The Arabs of the Ottoman Empire, 1516–1918

    Open Access•Bruce Masters, Bruce Alan Masters•Arabs of the Ottoman Empire,…•2013

  • Armed Negotiations

    Elektra Kostopoulou•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2013

  • Ottoman Judicial Change in the Age of Modernity

    Open Access•Avi Rubin•History Compass•2008

  • Epistemologies of Domination

    Open Access•Alina Sajed•International Studies Review•2024

  • The Capitulations Syndrome

    Open Access•Nora Fisher‐onar•Global Studies Quarterly•2022

  • Beyond ‘Black Turks’ and ‘White Turks’ – The Turkish Elites’ Ongoing Mission to Civilize a Colourful Society

    Christoph Ramm•Asiatische Studien – Études…•2016

  • Libyan Provincialization and the Invention of Ottoman Africa

    Jonathan M Lohnes•Eurasian Studies•2024

  • Fashioning identity

    Open Access•Şakir Özüdoğru•dObra[s] – revista da Associação…•2025

  • La colonización de Kurdistán y las continuidades colonialistas en el conflicto turco-kurdo

    Open Access•Tutkal•Revista de Estudios Internacionales…•2025

  • The problem with hybridity

    Aram Ghoogasian•Middle Eastern Literatures•2022

  • An Orient of One’s Own

    Open Access•Jacob Olley•Royal Musical Association…•2023

  • Beyond Stereotypes of Bedouins as ‘Nomads’ and ‘Savages’

    Open Access•Ahmad Amara•Journal of Holy Land and…•2016

  • War, resistance, and memory in Libya’s oral history project

    Eileen Ryan•The Journal of North African…•2024

  • From the Birth of Universal Humanity to National Identity in Ottoman and Republican Thought

    Open Access•Bahtiyar Mermertaş•Sociology Lens•2025

  • A Mobile Boundary

    Open Access•Fredrick Walter Lorenz•Mashriq & Mahjar Journal of…•2025

  • Rewriting National Narratives through the Study of Past Migrations

    Juliette Tolay•Ethnopolitics•2017

  • Shedding an ethnic identity in diaspora

    Ipek Demir•Critical Discourse Studies•2017

  • Gendering Landscapes of War Through the Narratives of Soldiers’ Mothers

    Senem Kaptan•Journal of Middle East Women s…•2017

  • Lost and found, then lost again? The social history of workers and peasants in the modern Middle East

    Open Access•Kyle Anderson•History Compass•2016

  • Bringing the imperial back in

    Open Access•Thomas Kuehn•History Compass•2021

  • Over the Borderline? Rethinking Territoriality at the Margins of Empire and Nation in the Modern Middle East (Part I)

    Open Access•Matthew H Ellis•History Compass•2015

  • Turkey Discovers Sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Gokhan Bacik, Isa Afacan•Turkish Studies•2013

  • The marginalization of the Ottoman Empire's state formation legacy in the Middle East

    Open Access•Nilüfer Güneş•Turkish Studies•2025

  • Symbolic boundary work among Syrian refugees

    Open Access•Çetin Çelik•European Societies•2025

  • The Sinai Bedouins and the Ottoman army in World War I

    Open Access•Eyal Berelovich, Ruth Kark•Israel Affairs•2023

  • Six gallant steeds seated in a schoolhouse

    Open Access•Kobi Peled•Israel Affairs•2024

  • Me among the Turks?’

    Houssine Alloul•European Review of History Revue…•2020

  • Upgrade

    Adam Mestyan•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2017

  • Nationalism, Internationalism, and Cosmopolitanism

    Christine Philliou•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2016

  • Novel Anxieties

    Beyza Lorenz•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2020

  • On Ottoman, British, and Belgian Monarchs' Ownership of Private Property in the Late Nineteenth Century

    Naz Yücel•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2023

  • Isma‘ili-Ottoman Petitioners in the Second Constitutional Period

    Amaan Merali•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2025

  • Fantômes d’Empire

    Open Access•Aline Schlaepfer, Philippe Bourmaud et al.•Revue des mondes musulmans et de…•2020

  • Ghosts of Empire

    Open Access•Aline Schlaepfer, Philippe Bourmaud et al.•Revue des mondes musulmans et de…•2020

  • Assembling urban worlds

    Open Access•Mansour Nasasra, Bruce Stanley et al.•Urban History•2023

  • Rational choice theory and religion

    Jonathan Fox, Ahmet Erdi Öztürk•Religion State & Society•2024

  • The Transformation of the Ottoman State’s Relationship with the Nusayri/ʿAlawi Community in the Nineteenth Century

    Ali Çapar•Islam and Christian–Muslim…•2024

  • Algeria in declining ottoman hierarchy

    Ali Balci•Cambridge Review of International…•2020

  • Bedouin Poetry as an Art of Memory. The Dialogue Between the Present and the Past in the Political Poetry of the Negev Bedouin

    Open Access•Kobi Peled•Nomadic Peoples•2024

  • Civilizational Exceptions

    Open Access•Ahmad Amara•Law and History Review•2018

  • Hashimite depictions of Wahhabi Islam as a rhetorical front in the late Ottoman period

    Open Access•Sami Jiryis Sweis, Sami Sweis•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2024

  • Contracts of survival

    Open Access•Ekrema Shehab, Bilal Hamamra et al.•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2025

  • What Is Bahai Orientalism

    Open Access•Geoffrey Nash•Humanities•2020

  • Sociology’s Imperial Unconscious

    Open Access•Julian Go•Sociology and Empire•2013

  • Turkey and the Colonial/Modern International

    Open Access•Zeynep Gulsah Capan•Critical Readings of Turkey's…•2022

  • The Imperial Tribal School

    Open Access•Madison Leeson•Heritage and Legitimacy: Cultural…•2025

  • Japanese Colonial Structure in Korea in Comparative Perspective

    Open Access•Ou-Byung Chae•Sociology and Empire•2013

  • German Sociology and Empire

    Open Access•Andrew Zimmerman•Sociology and Empire•2013

  • Occupying Syria under the French Mandate

    Open Access•Daniel Neep•Occupying Syria under the French…•2012

  • Transhumants and Rural Change in Northern Greece Throughout the Nineteenth Century

    Open Access•Fatma Öncel•International Review of Social…•2020

  • A Tale of a “Gypsy” Couple

    Open Access•Egemen Yılgür•International Journal Middle East…•2025

  • On the Representation of ‘Others’ at Europe's Borders

    Ipek Demir, Welat Zeydanlıoğlu•Journal of Contemporary European…•2010

  • The Never Ending Dance

    Open Access•C Houston•The Australian Journal of…•2006

  • Anti-Westernism on the European Periphery

    Open Access•Samuel J Hirst•Slavic Review•2013

  • Iranian Studies in Turkey

    Open Access•Metin Yüksel•Iranian Studies•2014

  • Between Paternalism and Orientalism

    Open Access•Alisa Shablovskaia•Iranian Studies•2025

  • Winter-Quartering Tribes

    Open Access•Yener Koç•International Review of Social…•2023

  • Literature and the legacy of Empire

    Open Access•Johanna Chovanec•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2024

  • The Arab East and the Bedouin Component in Modern History

    Johann Büssow, Kurt Franz et al.•Journal of the Economic and…•2015

  • Beyond Rhetoric

    Mostafa Minawi•Journal of the Economic and…•2015

  • Bedouin Petitions from Late Ottoman Palestine

    Yuval Ben-Bassat, Yuval Ben‐bassat•Journal of the Economic and…•2015

  • Sheikh and Pasha

    Yoav Alon•Journal of the Economic and…•2016

  • Marginal Actors? The Role of Bedouin in the Ottoman Administration of Animals as Property in the District of Salt, 1870-1912

    Nora Elizabeth Barakat, Nora Barakat•Journal of the Economic and…•2015

  • Secularizing Anatolia Tick by Tick

    Open Access•Mehmet Bengü Uluengin•International Journal Middle East…•2010

  • Malhamé–malfamé”

    Open Access•Jens Hanssen•International Journal Middle East…•2011

  • Postcoloniality, the Ottoman Past, and the Middle East Present

    Open Access•Fatma Muge Gocek•International Journal Middle East…•2012

  • Efendilik

    Open Access•Onursal Erol•International Journal Middle East…•2023

  • Ottomans in the Caucasian Highlands

    Open Access•Tuna Başıbek•International Journal Middle East…•2024

  • The Ottoman Quagmire

    Open Access•Chris Gratien•International Journal Middle East…•2017

  • Locating the Wallachian Revolution of 1848

    Open Access•James O Morris•The Historical Journal•2020

  • Ottoman imperialism

    Yusuf Can İndibay•The Journal of North African…•2026

  • Ottoman travelers' perceptions of Africa in the Late Ottoman Empire (1860-1922)

    Open Access•Mustafa Serdar Palabıyık•New Perspectives on Turkey•2012

  • Postcoloniality Without Race? Racial Exceptionalism and Southeast European Cultural Studies

    Catherine Baker•Interventions•2018

  • The colour of Orientalism

    Amy Aisen Elouafi•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2010

  • Ethnicity as a category of imperial racialization

    Open Access•Bogdan Popa•Ethnicities•2021

  • Securing Turkey through western-oriented foreign policy

    Open Access•Pinar Bilgin, Pınar Bilgin•New Perspectives on Turkey•2009

  • Presenting the Desert to the Ottomans During WWI

    Open Access•Eyal Ginio•New Perspectives on Turkey•2005

  • Social Biography of a Late OttomanShari'aJudge

    Open Access•Iris Agmon•New Perspectives on Turkey•2004

  • Interrogating the tribal

    Open Access•Ahmad Mohammadpour, Kamal Soleimani•British Journal of Sociology•2019

  • The creation of Palestinian citizenship under an international mandate

    Lauren Banko•Citizenship Studies•2012

  • Extractive Colonialism and State Making in Early Modern Ottoman Kurdistan

    Nilay Özok-Gündoğan, Nilay Özok‐gündoğan•South Atlantic Quarterly•2024

  • Kurdish Vernacular Learning as Indigenous Knowledge

    M Leezenberg•South Atlantic Quarterly•2024

  • Humbling Turkishness

    Open Access•Ipek Demir•Journal of Historical Sociology•2014

  • On Public Intellectuals and Their Conceptual Frameworks

    Open Access•Maria Todorova•Slavic Review•2015

  • Backwardness and the Quest for Civilization

    Open Access•A Khalid•Slavic Review•2006

  • The Arab Mexicans before the Great War

    Open Access•Francisco Reyes•Nuevo mundo mundos nuevos•2024

  • An Honorable Break from Besa

    Open Access•Isa Blumi•European journal of Turkish studies•2014

  • Renewing an 'Armenian' neighbourhood

    Open Access•Alice Von Bieberstein•Anthropological Theory•2024

  • An anti-history of a non-people

    Open Access•Cheryl Houston•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2009

  • Compulsory guesthood, social cohesion, and the politics of hospitality in Turkey

    Open Access•Elif M Babül•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2024

  • The Racial Policies of De-development in the Middle East

    Ahmad Mohammadpour, Kamal Soleimani•Current Anthropology•2024

  • Elitist by Default? Interaction Dynamics and the Inclusiveness of Secularization in Turkish Literary Milieus

    Barış Büyükokutan•American Journal of Sociology•2018

  • Paths well travelled

    Ayşe Polat•History and Anthropology•2025

  • La catégorie ' études coloniales ' est-elle indispensable

    Open Access•Jean-Frédéric Schaub•Annales Histoire Sciences Sociales•2008

Obras citantes distintas104
Citas por año4,73
Intervalo de citas2004 - 2026 (23)
Velocidad de citacióncurrent
Altamente citadoSí
Tipos de citaNeutras: 103
Ethnos_APP • Proyecto Open Source • Licencia MIT • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacidad y Cookies • Documentación de la API: api.ethnos.app/docs • Código de la API: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Código del Frontend: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae