The Folk Ethics of Commodification

Commodification is the process of transforming goods or services traditionally transferred without charge into commercially exchangeable commodities. Critics argue that this transformation often entails the loss of inherent value, rendering the resulting transactions morally problematic. In contrast, proponents of commodification contend that if it is morally acceptable to give something away for free, it should likewise be permissible to transfer it in exchange for money. Despite the extensive academic debate surrounding the moral implications of commodification, there remains a significant lack of empirical research on how laypeople perceive and evaluate this phenomenon. Given that policies supporting or opposing commodification are frequently influenced by public attitudes, addressing this gap is of critical importance. To this end, we conducted four online experiments to systematically examine the folk ethics of commodification. Our findings indicate a pronounced anti-commodification attitude across a range of specific contexts, an attitude that remains robust to several variations. Anti-commodification attitudes in specific contexts, however, erode when people are first asked to reflect on the general legitimacy of commodification. In contrast, their approval of this general legitimacy is weakened when they are first asked to evaluate specific cases. These latter results should sensitize educators that a case-based approach to the moral limits of markets might induce different normative conclusions than a principled approach

Business · Business ethics · Commodification · Economics · Environmental ethics · Market economy · Political science · Positive economics · Quality of Life Research · Sociology · Ethics in Business and Education · Law · Philosophy

• TurkPrime.com

  Open Access•Leib Litman, Jonathan Robinson et al.•Behavior Research Methods•2017

  Añadir item

• The Fatal Conceit

  F A Hayek, W W Bartley et al.•Fatal Conceit•1988

  Añadir item

• A Theory of Justice

  Open Access•John Rawls•Theory of Justice•1999

  Añadir item

• Market-Inalienability

  Margaret Jane Radin•Harvard Law Review•1987

  Añadir item

• When Goliath sells to David

  Open Access•Johanna Jauernig, Matthias Uhl et al.•Public Choice•2025

  Añadir item

• The myth of the rational voter

  Bryan Caplan, Bryan Douglas Caplan•Myth of the Rational Voter•2007

  Añadir item

• Markets without Symbolic Limits

  Jason Brennan, Peter Jaworski et al.•Ethics•2015

  Añadir item