Intellectuals of the Left and the Atomic Dilemma in the Age of the US Atomic Monopoly, 1945–1949

Given its close association with the formation of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, it is tempting to assume that the response of Left intellectuals to the advent of atomic weapons was rooted in consistent opposition. This article demonstrates that the reality was much more complex. During the period of the US atomic monopoly (1945-1949) British Left intellectuals wrestled with the implications of this new destructive force and arrived at widely different understandings and prognoses. However, many shared a pessimism rooted in the belief that the atomic monopoly could not be maintained for long, that beyond this point the atomic future was unmanageable, and that it would result in future war and annihilation. Drawing on a range of British left-wing responses, and focusing in particular on those of Bertrand Russell and George Orwell, this article emphasizes the shifting nature and complexity of Left responses to the advent of the US atomic monopoly and analyses the circumstances in which these were arrived at. It shows that it is inaccurate to think in terms of a single or coherent left-wing position on atomic weapons at a time when many on the left believed further war to be inevitable and some believed that the only way to prevent it lay in launching a preventive atomic attack on the Soviet Union.

Atomic energy · Dilemma · Disarmament · Economics · Epistemology · Market economy · Monopoly · Nuclear weapon · Opposition (politics) · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Social science · Sociology · Law · Nuclear Issues and Defense · Philosophy · Twentieth Century Scientific Developments

• Atomic War or World Peace Order? Karl Jaspers, Denis de Rougemont, Bertrand Russell

  Open Access•Mats Andrén•Global Intellectual History•2020

  Añadir item

• Dissenting Scientists in Early Cold War Britain

  Alison Kraft•Journal of Cold War Studies•2018

  Añadir item

• Mass-Observers at the ‘atomic crossroads’

  Open Access•Simon J Moody•Contemporary British History•2024

  Añadir item

• Die soziale Funktion der Wissenschaft

  J D Bernal•Die soziale Funktion der…•1986

  Añadir item

• The Freedom of Necessity

  J D B Miller, J D Bernal•The Australian Quarterly•1950

  Añadir item

• The Making of the Atomic Bomb

  Zuoyue Wang, Rita Rhodes et al.•Technology and Culture•1989

  Añadir item