A Comment on Curren's 'Potential Interpretations of 'Stone Gorget' Function

Curren (1977) presents an interesting and provocative hypothesis regarding the 'potential' function of 'stone gorgets.' Nevertheless, there are some serious problems with his thesis that require comment.Initially, there is a danger in the rather simplistic association drawn between form and function. To claim a functional similarity because there is a morphological similarity between stone gorgets and contemporary ceramic tools called 'ribs' is a risky procedure. One does not need to go very far to demonstrate analogous examples. For instance, if I were to show a surveyor a stone 'plummet,' I would most likely elicit the response, ' a surveyor's plummet in stone?' If I were to present an unsuspecting archaeologist with a surveyor's plummet, I might hear, 'plummets (net sinkers or bolas] in brass?' In contrast to the paper under disucssion, Ahler's (1971) important study is a sophisticated treatment of the problems involved in equating form with function

Cartography · Epistemology · Function (biology) · Geography · Similarity (geometry) · Surveyor · Archaeology and ancient environmental studies · Archaeology and Rock Art Studies · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · History · Image Processing and 3D Reconstruction · Mathematics · Philosophy

• The Reaction against Analogy

  Open Access•A Wylie•Advances in Archaeological Method…•1985

  Añadir item

• ‘Simple’ analogy and the role of relevance assumptions

  A Wylie•International Studies in the…•1988

  Añadir item

• Archaeological Cables and Tacking

  Open Access•A Wylie•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•1989

  Añadir item

• Ascribing Functions to Archaeological Objects

  Open Access•Merrilee H Salmon•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•1981

  Añadir item

• The archaeology of New York State

  William Augustus Ritchie•The archaeology of New York State•1994

  Añadir item

• A Study of the Glacial Kame Culture in Michigan, Ohio, and Indiana

  Wilbur M Cunningham•Study of the Glacial Kame Culture…•1948

  Añadir item

• Archeological Survey of Southwest Virginia

  Open Access•C G Holland•Smithsonian contributions to…•1970

  Añadir item

• Late Woodland Cultures of Southeastern Michigan

  James E Fitting•Late Woodland Cultures of…•1965

  Añadir item

• Potential Interpretations of 'Stone Gorget' Function

  Open Access•Cailup B Curren•American Antiquity•1977

  Añadir item

• Archaeology as Anthropology

  Open Access•Lewis R Binford•American Antiquity•1962

  Añadir item

• The Archaic Culture in the Middle South

  Open Access•Tom Lewis, T M N Lewis et al.•American Antiquity•1959

  Añadir item