Smith or Malthus? A Sea-Change in the Concept of a Population

This two-part article offers a critical appreciation of Malthus's political economy of population to mark the bi-centenary of hisPrinciples of Political Economy(1820). His general economic theory emerged after the first four editions of his famous Essay, in three steps: (1) a rapidly produced series of essays on tariffs, rents, and capital mal-distribution (1814-1815); (2) consequent revision of the economic basis of the Essay (1817); and (3) formal statement in the Principles. His main economic writings thus belong to a later, more mature period of his work, and their evolution is of particular interest for demography on three counts. One is that his rethinking was stimulated directly by the need to rectify serious deficiencies he had come to recognize in the Essay. Second, this makes his later thought of more direct interest to today's study of population and development. Third, all three steps began in, and were sustained by, dialogue with Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations. The dialogue led to further thinking beyond the Essay, with major innovative developments. Comparison to the Smithian baseline shows (1) that the familiar stereotype of Malthus as prophet of population-laden disaster is seriously incomplete; and (2) capital distribution replaces population distribution as a mechanism of growth, inducing a radical change in the concept of population

Capital (architecture · Capital accumulation · Distribution (mathematics · Economic rent · Economics · Economy · Market economy · Neoclassical economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Population · Population growth · Positive economics · Sociology · Demography · Economic Theory and Policy · Historical Economic and Social Studies · History · Law · Political Economy and Marxism

• Perceptions of the Future and Pregnancy Avoidance in the U.S

  Open Access•K B Guzzo, A A Belykh et al.•Population Research and Policy…•2025

  Añadir item

• Poverty, Progress, and Population

  E A Wrigley•Poverty, Progress, and Population•2004

  Añadir item

• Fertility, Class and Gender in Britain, 1860–1940

  Open Access•Simon Szreter•Fertility, Class and Gender in…•1996

  Añadir item

• Capital in the Twenty-First Century

  Thomas Piketty•Capital in the Twenty-First Century•2014

  Añadir item

• Malthus's Total Population Theory

  Open Access•Joseph J Spengler•The Canadian Journal of Economics…•1945

  Añadir item

• The Works and Correspondence of David Ricardo

  Open Access•Eraldo Fossati•Metroeconomica•1952

  Añadir item

• Theories of Value and Distribution since Adam Smith

  Open Access•Maurice Dobb, Maurice Herbert Dobb•Theories of Value and Distribution…•1973

  Añadir item

• Malthus as an Economist

  Robbins Robbins•The Economic Journal•1967

  Añadir item

• Bringing Income Distribution in From the Cold

  Open Access•A B Atkinson•The Economic Journal•1997

  Añadir item

• A History of the Theories of Production and Distribution in English Political Economy, from 1776 to 1848

  William Cunningham, Edwin Cannan•The Economic Journal•1893

  Añadir item

• Aristotle and Open Population Thinking

  Open Access•Philip Kreager•Population and Development Review•2008

  Añadir item

• Adam Smith, the Division of Labor, and the Renewal of Population Heterogeneity

  Open Access•Philip Kreager•Population and Development Review•2017

  Añadir item

• Corn and Crisis

  Open Access•E A Wrigley•Population and Development Review•1999

  Añadir item

• Economic Sentiments

  Jeffrey T Young•History of Political Economy•2003

  Añadir item

• Reappraisal of "Malthus the Economist," 1933-97

  A M C Waterman•History of Political Economy•1998

  Añadir item

• Population theory-A long view

  Philip Kreager•Population Studies•2015

  Añadir item

• Population Malthus. His Life and Times

  Eric Rolls, Eric Roll et al.•Population Studies•1980

  Añadir item

• Demand Theories of the Fertility Transition

  John G F Cleland, John Cleland et al.•Population Studies•1987

  Añadir item

• Fertility and Family Planning

  E Grebenik, J Behrman et al.•Population Studies•1970

  Añadir item

• The Works of Thomas Robert Malthus

  William Petersen, E A Wrigley et al.•Population and Development Review•1987

  Añadir item

• Ricardo on Population

  David Ricardo•Population and Development Review•1988

  Añadir item

• An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations

  Adam Smith, Edwin Cannan et al.•An inquiry into the nature and…•1977

  Añadir item