How Do They Compare

OBJECTIVES: The Consumer Assessment of Health Plans Survey (CAHPS) includes an adult version and also a child version for parents or caretakers to rate children's care in health plans. This study examined how adult and child assessments differed in ranking health plans and explored whether the differences justified the additional cost and respondent burden in administering both surveys. METHODS: Data were from 136 commercial health plans participating in the National CAHPS Benchmarking Database, with 80,539 adults and 40,003 children. We compared mean assessments for adults and children on four global ratings and five composites, and determined respondent characteristics predictive of these assessments using regression analysis. We calculated correlations of plan mean scores for adults and children and kappa statistics for agreement when health plans are ranked as above average, average, or below average performers based on adult and child scores. RESULTS: CAHPS scores for children were significantly (P <0.001) higher than those for adults, except for customer service (lower for children) and specialist ratings. Similar respondent characteristics predicted adult and child scores. Plan-level correlations between corresponding adult and child mean scores were moderate to high (r = 0.60-0.85), which translate into fair to moderate agreement (kappa = 0.27-0.61) in ranking health plans. CONCLUSIONS: Adult and child CAHPS provide similar scores and plan rankings on many aspects of care. Child reports include information that may be useful for consumer choice and to health plans for targeting quality improvement. Methods should be developed for assessing health care for children that minimize cost and respondent burden

Benchmarking · Family medicine · Health care · Health plan · Kappa · Patient satisfaction · Ranking (information retrieval) · Respondent · Health Systems, Economic Evaluations, Quality of Life · Healthcare Policy and Management · Marketing · Medicine · Nursing · Patient Satisfaction in Healthcare

• Differences in CAHPS Reports and Ratings of Health Care Provided to Adults and Children

  Alex Y Chen, Marc N Elliott et al.•Medical Care•2012

  Añadir item

• Parents’ Reports of Children's Medical Care Access

  Tyrone F Borders, Angelique Brannon-Goedeke et al.•Medical Care•2004

  Añadir item

• The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data

  J R Landis, Gary G Koch•Biometrics•1977

  Añadir item

• A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales

  Open Access•Jacob Cohen•Educational and Psychological…•1960

  Añadir item

• Sex differences in assessments of the quality of medicare managed care

  Open Access•Paul D Cleary, Alan M Zaslavsky et al.•Women s Health Issues•2000

  Añadir item

• Parent Satisfaction With Children??s Medical Care

  Catherine C Lewis, Catherine Lewis et al.•Medical Care•1986

  Añadir item

• Dimensions of Consumer-Assessed Quality of Medicare Managed-Care Health Plans

  Alan M Zaslavsky, Nancy Dean Beaulieu et al.•Medical Care•2000

  Añadir item

• Psychometric Properties of the CAHPSTM 1.0 Survey Measures

  Ron D Hays, James A Shaul et al.•Medical Care•1999

  Añadir item

• The Impact of Having Parents Report About Both Their Own and Their Children's Experiences With Health Insurance Plans

  James A Shaul, Floyd Jackson Fowler et al.•Medical Care•1999

  Añadir item

• The Use of Cognitive Testing to Develop and Evaluate CAHPSTM 1.0 Core Survey Items

  Lauren Harris-Kojetin, Lauren D Harris-Kojetin et al.•Medical Care•1999

  Añadir item