Michelle Searle
Biographic Data
| ID | 6508728 |
|---|---|
| NAME | Michelle Searle |
| GIVEN NAMES | Michelle |
| FAMILY NAME | Searle |
| SIGNATURE | SEARLE M |
| AFFILIATIONS | Queen's University |
| ORCID | 0000-0001-6504-5128 |
| VERIFIED | Yes |
| TOTAL WORKS | 22 |
| TOTAL CITATIONS | 13 |
| AUTHOR COUNT | 22 |
| EDITOR COUNT | 0 |
| FIRST PUBLICATION YEAR | 2009 |
| LATEST PUBLICATION YEAR | 2024 |
| H-INDEX | 2 |
Evaluation Capacity Building
There is a growing need for evaluation capacity building (ECB) in community organizations; however, learning opportunities for both organizations and post-secondary students are limited, particularly opportunities to apply evaluation concepts in practice. This practice note describes four initiatives and highlights the ways in which experiential learning can be leveraged through community-university collaborations to provide responsive, hands-on …
Strengthening Evaluation Capacity Building Practice Through Competition
Despite the attention evaluation capacity building (ECB) has received over the past several decades, surprisingly few opportunities for learning about ECB exist. In response to this need, the Max Bell School of Public Policy at McGill University, in collaboration with ECB scholars across Canada, created a case competition focused exclusively on ECB—the Evaluation Capacity Case Challenge (EC 3 ). Twenty individuals interested in learning about ECB…
Learning From Evaluation Data
Evaluation competitions, a process that has existed for more than three decades, are a mechanism to promote program evaluation and enhance evaluation capacity. Integrating these competitions into evaluation education extends traditional teaching models beyond theory-dense learning contexts. This practice note delves into the Evaluation Case Competition Challenge (EC 3 ), a case challenge designed to advance knowledge on evaluation capacity buildi…
Meeting the Challenge
This practice note shares key learnings from the inaugural Evaluation Capacity Case Challenge (EC 3 ) held by the Max Bell School of Public Policy in April 2023. The purpose is to give readers an opportunity to consider how to shape evaluation capacity in general and within a municipal context. Evaluation capacity building (ECB) is a multifaceted concept to support shared learning about and understanding of evaluation. Strands of learning about E…
Mapping Evaluation Use
Factors influencing evaluation use has been a primary concern for evaluators. However, little is known about the current conceptualizations of evaluation use including what counts as use, what efforts encourage use, and how to measure use. This article identifies enablers and constraints to evaluation use based on a scoping review of literature published since 2009 ( n = 47). A fulsome examination to map factors influencing evaluation use identif…
Behind the Virtual Curtain
In this practice note, the authors discuss techniques they used to bring the collaborative approaches to evaluation (CAE) principles to life in a virtual setting. Following their CAE evaluation of an extracurricular post-secondary program, the authors examined artifacts of their work using CAE as a deductive framework. Their analysis highlighted numerous strategies to enact the CAE principles and the importance of modern technologies to facilitat…
Learning Through Tensions
Learning and Leading
This practice note describes the benefits of integrating mixed methods in a collaborative approach to evaluation with school districts and community partners in southwestern Ontario. We discuss the ways in which the integration of qualitative and quantitative data generated a multi-faceted perspective about a new mental health professional role as a complex educational phenomenon. The insights related to recognizing the role of context, supportin…
Why a Focus on Integration and Complex Mixed Methods Evaluation Designs
Introductory Editorial
Co-production and arts-informed inquiry as creative power for knowledge mobilisation
Background: Interest in using arts-informed approaches within research to increase stakeholder engagement is growing; however, there is little work describing how these approaches are operationalised across contexts. This article addresses that gap by exploring the use of arts-informed approaches across three projects. Aims and objectives: We explore how conceptualising research and evaluation as creative endeavours, particularly in arts-informed…
Collaborative Evaluation Designs as an Authentic Course Assessment
Strategies for optimizing evaluator education involve ongoing discussions within the field of evaluation. There remains unrealized potential for authentic assessments to support and measure learning that demonstrates the integration of evaluation theory with practice. In this practice note, we advance collaborative evaluation designs as a useful authentic assessment for generating the type of applied learning evidence required within an evaluatio…
Competency-Based Evaluation Education
Evaluator education must provide robust opportunities to support and assess the progressive, lifelong development of relevant knowledge and skills. If we wish to keep pace with the increasingly complex contexts in which evaluators operate, we need to better align our educational approaches with the global movement toward practice competencies guiding the profession. Key among the challenges is the lack of instructional guidance specific to a comp…
Media Review
Toward a pedagogy for slow and significant learning about assessment in teacher education
Assessing competency-based evaluation course impacts
Scope Creep and Purposeful Pivots in Developmental Evaluation
This practice note illustrates a situation where, as program evaluators, we crept beyond the provisional boundaries set by our Developmental Evaluation (DE) goals to facilitate learning. Our DE was initially focused on one program which was being designed for online delivery in higher education. During the DE of this program, questions and themes arose which had larger organizational applicability; we were asked to help design a strategic learnin…
A Case Study of the Guiding Principles for Collaborative Approaches to Evaluation in a Developmental Evaluation Context
Recently, Shulha, Whitmore, Cousins, Gilbert, and al Hudib (2015) proposed a set of evidence-based principles to guide collaboration. Our research undertakes a case study approach to explore these principles in a developmental evaluation context. Data were collected at two points in an 18-month period where an evaluation group collaborated with the program team from a national organization. This article explores the contributions of selected coll…
Optimizing Use in the Field of Program Evaluation by Integrating Learning from the Knowledge Field
It has been almost 20 years since Shulha and Cousins (1997) published their seminal paper exploring evaluation use. The paper examined a decade, 1986 to 1996, of theory, practice, and research on evaluation use. Since that time there have been significant developments related to the phenomenon of evaluation use. Outside of evaluation a new and burgeoning field has focused on the use of research in practice and policy; in health care the term know…
Introduction — Setting the Evaluation Use Context
International service learning and critical global citizenship
Capturing the Imagination
Qualitative approaches in evaluation continue to expand, and this article focuses on the potential for the Arts to contribute to innovation in evaluation. Arts-informed inquiry is an approach that works within, augments, and extends traditional forms of qualitative approaches. This study documents an educational program evaluation that intentionally plans for, uses, and reflects upon arts-informed inquiry. Three considerations found central to ar…
Evaluation for learning
International service learning and critical global citizenship
Co-production and arts-informed inquiry as creative power for knowledge mobilisation
Background: Interest in using arts-informed approaches within research to increase stakeholder engagement is growing; however, there is little work describing how these approaches are operationalised across contexts. This article addresses that gap by exploring the use of arts-informed approaches across three projects. Aims and objectives: We explore how conceptualising research and evaluation as creative endeavours, particularly in arts-informed…
Toward a pedagogy for slow and significant learning about assessment in teacher education
Media Review
Evaluation for learning
Capturing the Imagination
Qualitative approaches in evaluation continue to expand, and this article focuses on the potential for the Arts to contribute to innovation in evaluation. Arts-informed inquiry is an approach that works within, augments, and extends traditional forms of qualitative approaches. This study documents an educational program evaluation that intentionally plans for, uses, and reflects upon arts-informed inquiry. Three considerations found central to ar…
A Case Study of the Guiding Principles for Collaborative Approaches to Evaluation in a Developmental Evaluation Context
Recently, Shulha, Whitmore, Cousins, Gilbert, and al Hudib (2015) proposed a set of evidence-based principles to guide collaboration. Our research undertakes a case study approach to explore these principles in a developmental evaluation context. Data were collected at two points in an 18-month period where an evaluation group collaborated with the program team from a national organization. This article explores the contributions of selected coll…
Optimizing Use in the Field of Program Evaluation by Integrating Learning from the Knowledge Field
It has been almost 20 years since Shulha and Cousins (1997) published their seminal paper exploring evaluation use. The paper examined a decade, 1986 to 1996, of theory, practice, and research on evaluation use. Since that time there have been significant developments related to the phenomenon of evaluation use. Outside of evaluation a new and burgeoning field has focused on the use of research in practice and policy; in health care the term know…
Introduction — Setting the Evaluation Use Context
International service learning and critical global citizenship
Assessing competency-based evaluation course impacts
Scope Creep and Purposeful Pivots in Developmental Evaluation
This practice note illustrates a situation where, as program evaluators, we crept beyond the provisional boundaries set by our Developmental Evaluation (DE) goals to facilitate learning. Our DE was initially focused on one program which was being designed for online delivery in higher education. During the DE of this program, questions and themes arose which had larger organizational applicability; we were asked to help design a strategic learnin…
Collaborative Evaluation Designs as an Authentic Course Assessment
Strategies for optimizing evaluator education involve ongoing discussions within the field of evaluation. There remains unrealized potential for authentic assessments to support and measure learning that demonstrates the integration of evaluation theory with practice. In this practice note, we advance collaborative evaluation designs as a useful authentic assessment for generating the type of applied learning evidence required within an evaluatio…
Competency-Based Evaluation Education
Evaluator education must provide robust opportunities to support and assess the progressive, lifelong development of relevant knowledge and skills. If we wish to keep pace with the increasingly complex contexts in which evaluators operate, we need to better align our educational approaches with the global movement toward practice competencies guiding the profession. Key among the challenges is the lack of instructional guidance specific to a comp…
Media Review
Toward a pedagogy for slow and significant learning about assessment in teacher education
Learning Through Tensions
Learning and Leading
This practice note describes the benefits of integrating mixed methods in a collaborative approach to evaluation with school districts and community partners in southwestern Ontario. We discuss the ways in which the integration of qualitative and quantitative data generated a multi-faceted perspective about a new mental health professional role as a complex educational phenomenon. The insights related to recognizing the role of context, supportin…
Why a Focus on Integration and Complex Mixed Methods Evaluation Designs
Introductory Editorial
Co-production and arts-informed inquiry as creative power for knowledge mobilisation
Background: Interest in using arts-informed approaches within research to increase stakeholder engagement is growing; however, there is little work describing how these approaches are operationalised across contexts. This article addresses that gap by exploring the use of arts-informed approaches across three projects. Aims and objectives: We explore how conceptualising research and evaluation as creative endeavours, particularly in arts-informed…
Behind the Virtual Curtain
In this practice note, the authors discuss techniques they used to bring the collaborative approaches to evaluation (CAE) principles to life in a virtual setting. Following their CAE evaluation of an extracurricular post-secondary program, the authors examined artifacts of their work using CAE as a deductive framework. Their analysis highlighted numerous strategies to enact the CAE principles and the importance of modern technologies to facilitat…
Evaluation Capacity Building
There is a growing need for evaluation capacity building (ECB) in community organizations; however, learning opportunities for both organizations and post-secondary students are limited, particularly opportunities to apply evaluation concepts in practice. This practice note describes four initiatives and highlights the ways in which experiential learning can be leveraged through community-university collaborations to provide responsive, hands-on …
Strengthening Evaluation Capacity Building Practice Through Competition
Despite the attention evaluation capacity building (ECB) has received over the past several decades, surprisingly few opportunities for learning about ECB exist. In response to this need, the Max Bell School of Public Policy at McGill University, in collaboration with ECB scholars across Canada, created a case competition focused exclusively on ECB—the Evaluation Capacity Case Challenge (EC 3 ). Twenty individuals interested in learning about ECB…
Learning From Evaluation Data
Evaluation competitions, a process that has existed for more than three decades, are a mechanism to promote program evaluation and enhance evaluation capacity. Integrating these competitions into evaluation education extends traditional teaching models beyond theory-dense learning contexts. This practice note delves into the Evaluation Case Competition Challenge (EC 3 ), a case challenge designed to advance knowledge on evaluation capacity buildi…
Meeting the Challenge
This practice note shares key learnings from the inaugural Evaluation Capacity Case Challenge (EC 3 ) held by the Max Bell School of Public Policy in April 2023. The purpose is to give readers an opportunity to consider how to shape evaluation capacity in general and within a municipal context. Evaluation capacity building (ECB) is a multifaceted concept to support shared learning about and understanding of evaluation. Strands of learning about E…
Mapping Evaluation Use
Factors influencing evaluation use has been a primary concern for evaluators. However, little is known about the current conceptualizations of evaluation use including what counts as use, what efforts encourage use, and how to measure use. This article identifies enablers and constraints to evaluation use based on a scoping review of literature published since 2009 ( n = 47). A fulsome examination to map factors influencing evaluation use identif…
Evaluation and Performance Assessment (19 works) · Psychology (15 works) · Computer Science (14 works) · Sociology (14 works) · Engineering (13 works) · Political science (11 works) · Knowledge management (10 works) · Engineering ethics (9 works) · Pedagogy (8 works) · Context (archaeology (6 works)