Pular para o conteúdo principal

ETHNOS_APP

Início • Busca • Periódicos • Lista 0

Transdisciplinary research in natural resources management

Towards an integrative and transformative use of co‐concepts

Dados Bibliográficos

ID12307704
AutoresViola Hakkarainen (0000-0001-8965-0947, Bioeconomy and Environment Unit Natural Resources Institute Finland Helsinki Finland, autor correspondente), Katri Mäkinen‐Rostedt (0000-0002-1502-2902, Politics Unit, Faculty of Management and Business Tampere University Tampere Finland), Andra-Ioana Horcea-Milcu (0000-0003-1757-6615, Babeș-Bolyai University), Andra Horcea‐Milcu (Hungarian Department of Biology and Ecology Babes‐Bolyai University Cluj‐Napoca Romania), Dalia D’amato (0000-0002-3992-7263, University of Helsinki), Johanna Jämsä (Department of Geography and Geology, Faculty of Science and Engineering University of Turku Turku Finland), Katriina Soini (0000-0002-8617-9165, Bioeconomy and Environment Unit Natural Resources Institute Finland Helsinki Finland)
Ano2021
Volume30
Fascículo2
Páginas309-325
Data de publicação2021-12-26
Peer ReviewedSim
Open AccessSim
TipoARTICLE
PeriódicoSustainable Development (JOURNAL)
Identificadores do periódicoISSN: 0968-0802 • E-ISSN: 1099-1719
EditoraWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1002/sd.2276
OpenAlexW4200294350
IdiomaEN
Citações recebidas35
Referências citadas154

Transdisciplinary research often utilizes collaborative ways of knowledge production to enable deliberate transformations towards sustainability. Multiple concepts with varying definitions are applied, leading to confusion in the aims and uses of these concepts. In this article, we review five concepts relevant to the current debate on the new collaborative ways of knowledge production in transdisciplinary research. We focus on the concepts of co‐creation, co‐production, co‐design, co‐learning, and adaptive co‐management in the context of natural resources management (NRM). This study couples a literature review and a conceptual analysis, and aims to clarify definitions, use, the interlinkages of these concepts and to shed light on their intertwined nature. We propose an integrative understanding of the concepts to facilitate collaborative modes and to enable the transformative aims of research processes. To this end, we discuss how to harvest the transformative potential of the “co‐concepts” by focusing on reflexivity, power analysis and process orientation

Conceptual framework · Context (archaeology · Engineering ethics · Epistemology · Knowledge management · Reflexivity · Social science · Sociology · Sustainability · Transformative learning · Community Development and Social Impact · Computer Science · Engineering · Forest Management and Policy · Sustainability and Climate Change Governance · Ecology

  • Local Knowledge for Ecological Restoration

    Open Access•Veronica del Rosario Avalos, Luis Manuel Hernández-Simón et al.•Human Ecology•2027

  • Doing research together

    Open Access•Sami Chen, S Y Chen et al.•Conservation Ecology•2023

  • Meeting needs & requirements

    Open Access•Tahnee Prior, Anne Chahine et al.•The Polar Journal•2026

  • Shaping Transdisciplinary Research with Partners on Climate Projects

    Open Access•Ana M Polgár, Jiaming Cheng et al.•Innovative Higher Education•2026

  • From reflexive co-production to diffractive co-becoming

    Open Access•L Jamila Haider, Josef “Präa Sepp” Rieser•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Fostering local sustainability

    Open Access•Ha B Vien, Edoardo Eichberg et al.•Sustainability Science•2026

  • Knowledge governance for the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Serge Clément•Global Policy•2022

  • Knowledge co-production in the Helge å catchment

    Open Access•Katja Malmborg, Ida Wallin et al.•Ecosystems and People•2022

  • Ways forward in transdisciplinary research

    Open Access•Mello Ngr, Peter Christie et al.•Sustainable Futures•2025

  • Medicinal Plant Production System Management in Rural Java, Indonesia

    Sri Astutik, Vianny Ahimbisibwe et al.

  • Introducing listening as a weak method for advancing sustainability and interdisciplinary scholarship

    Open Access•Artur Branny, Marvin Maurer et al.•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Academics for sustainable development

    Open Access•Sjors Witje, Sjors Witjes et al.•Sustainable Development•2021

  • Push and pull in the sustainable development of ecological landscape and ecological resources

    Open Access•Kui Yi, Jing Zhu et al.•Sustainable Development•2023

  • Evaluating transformative policies in complex land-use systems

    Open Access•N Droste, Huntley Brownell et al.•Ecological Economics•2025

  • The people of Techiman eat Teporo

    Open Access•Branwen Peddi, Nicholas Adams et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2025

  • Political ecology III

    Open Access•Farhana Sultana•Progress in Human Geography•2023

  • Foregrounding Amazonian women through decolonial and process-relational perspectives for transdisciplinary transformation

    Open Access•Tais Sonetti-González, Taís Sonetti González et al.•Ecosystems and People•2023

  • Co-design approaches in land use related sustainability science – A systematic review

    Open Access•Maria Busse, Jana Zscheischler et al.•Land Use Policy•2023

  • Exploring the role of transdisciplinary research in accelerating sustainability transition

    Open Access•Zoltán Csedő, Máté Zavarkó et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2025

  • New paths for modelling freshwater nature futures

    Open Access•Lilith Kramer, Sven Teurlincx et al.•Sustainability Science•2023

  • Learn to listen and listen to learn

    Open Access•Carolin Seiferth, Agnes B Olin et al.•Sustainability Science•2026

  • Being’ and ‘doing’

    Open Access•Viola Hakkarainen, Ulla Ovaska et al.•Sustainability Science•2023

  • Wildfire narratives

    Open Access•Michal Russo, Alexandra Paige Fischer et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Fostering sustainable and resilient coastal communities through combining Nature-based Solutions and empowerment tools

    Open Access•Ina Maren Sieber, A Rita Carrasco et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2026

  • Drivers and barriers to knowledge exchange through an envisioned online platform for transdisciplinary research projects

    Open Access•Vivian Juliette Cortes Arevalo, Robert‐Jan den Haan et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • Mapping barriers to food, energy, and water systems equity in the United States

    Open Access•Haleigh N Summers, Tiffanie F Stone et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Making transdisciplinarity happen

    Open Access•Andra-Ioana Horcea-Milcu, Julia Leventon et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2022

  • Engaging diverse experts in the global science-policy interface

    Open Access•Katri Mäkinen‐Rostedt, Viola Hakkarainen et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • Enhancing stakeholder engagement in sustainable forest management

    Open Access•Zhang Yiwen, Shashi Kant et al.•Sustainable Development•2024

  • Context matters

    Open Access•Katriina Soini, Carl C Anderson et al.•Land Use Policy•2023

  • Co-creation of economic value in peri-urban protected areas

    Open Access•José A Albaladejo-García, Federico Martínez-Carrasco Pleite et al.•Habitat International•2025

  • The forest beyond the trees

    Open Access•Roman Isaac, Graeme S Cummings et al.•AMBIO•2025

  • Getting personal with collaborative sustainability experimentation

    Open Access•B Ne, Darin Wahl•AMBIO•2022

  • Collaborative science and knowledge co-production in struggles for territory and life

    Open Access•Josué Federico Pérez Domínguez, Jaime Paneque-Gálvez•Tapuya Latin American Science…•2025

  • Critical Stakeholder Engagement

    Open Access•Aparna Bamzai-Dodson, Amanda E Cravens et al.•Annals of the American…•2024

  • Routledge International Handbook of Participatory Design

    Jesper Simonsen, Toni Robertson•Routledge international handbook…•2012

  • A review of assertions about the processes and outcomes of social learning in natural resource management

    Open Access•Georgina Cundill, Romina Rodela•Journal of Environmental Management•2012

  • A Guide to Understanding Social Science Research for Natural Scientists

    Open Access•Katie Moon, Deborah Blackman•Conservation Biology•2014

  • Transforming Sustainability Science to Generate Positive Social and Environmental Change Globally

    Open Access•Paul Shrivastava, Mark Stafford Smith et al.•One Earth•2020

  • Co-Producing Sustainability

    Open Access•Carina Wyborn, Amber Datta et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2019

  • A critical review of the theory and application of social learning in participatory natural resource management processes

    M Muro, Paul Jeffrey•Journal of Environmental Planning…•2008

  • Science's new social contract with society

    Open Access•Mary Gibbons, Michael Gibbons•Nature•1999

  • Beyond the third mission

    G Trencher, Masaru Yarime et al.•Science and Public Policy•2014

  • The art of co-production of knowledge in environmental sciences and management

    Open Access•I N S Djenontin, Alison M Meadows•Environmental Management•2018

  • Navigating complexity through knowledge coproduction

    Open Access•Belinda Reyers, Jeanne L Nel et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2015

  • Adaptive co‐management for social–ecological complexity

    Open Access•Derek R Armitage, Derek Armitage et al.•Frontiers in Ecology and the…•2009

  • Co-management

    Open Access•Lars Carlsson, F Berkes•Journal of Environmental Management•2005

  • Rethinking Community‐Based Conservation

    Open Access•F Berkes•Conservation Biology•2004

  • A Systematic Review of Co-Creation and Co-Production

    W H Voorberg, V J J M Bekkers et al.•Public Management Review•2015

  • Evolution of co-management

    Open Access•F Berkes•Journal of Environmental Management•2009

  • Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach

    Open Access•Zachary Munn, Micah D J Peters et al.•BMC Medical Research Methodology•2018

  • Knowledge systems for sustainable development

    Open Access•David W Cash, William C Clark et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2003

  • Realising local food policies

    Alessandra Manganelli•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2020

  • Transdisciplinarity as a discipline and a way of being

    Open Access•Cyrille Rigolot•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2020

  • States of Knowledge

    Sheila Jasanoff•States of Knowledge•2004

  • A relational turn for sustainability science? Relational thinking, leverage points and transformations

    Open Access•West, L Jamila Haider et al.•Ecosystems and People•2020

  • Engaging with the pragmatics of relational thinking, leverage points and transformations – Reply to West et al

    Open Access•Christopher M Raymond, Roope O Kaaronen et al.•Ecosystems and People•2021

  • Bridging Adaptive Learning and Desired Natural Resource Management Outcomes

    Silvia Serrao-Neumann, Melanie Cox et al.•Planning Practice and Research•2019

  • Giving and Reciprocity in Natural Resource Management and Consensus Building

    Sandra Lee Pinel, Sandra Pinel•Human Organization•2013

  • How Traditional Knowledge Comes to Matter in Atlantic Salmon Governance in Norway and Finland

    Open Access•Camilla Brattland, Tero Mustonen•ARCTIC•2018

  • Sustainability science in action

    Open Access•Arnim Wiek, John Harlow et al.•Sustainability Science•2015

  • Creating relevant knowledge in transdisciplinary research projects - Coping with inherent tensions

    Open Access•Andrea Schikowitz•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2019

  • Advances in monitoring the human dimension of natural resource systems

    Open Access•Neil Marshall, N A Marshall et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2016

  • Jointly Experimenting for Transformation? Shaping Real-World Laboratories by Comparing Them

    Open Access•N Schäpke, Franziska Stelzer et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Conflicts in Transdisciplinary Research

    Open Access•Bernd Siebenhüner•Ecological Economics•2018

  • A resilience-based framework for evaluating adaptive co-management

    Open Access•Ryan Plummer, Derek Armitage•Ecological Economics•2007

  • A review of transdisciplinary research in sustainability science

    Patric Brandt, Anna Ernst et al.•Ecological Economics•2013

  • Transdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Thomas Jahn, Matthias Bergmann et al.•Ecological Economics•2012

  • Developing and applying a framework to evaluate participatory research for sustainability

    Open Access•Kirsty Blackstock, K L Blackstock et al.•Ecological Economics•2007

  • The art of co-creation

    Open Access•Carsten Herrmann-Pillath, Carsten Herrmann Pillath•Ecological Economics•2020

  • Bridging barriers to advance global sustainability

    Open Access•Elena G Irwin, Patricia J Culligan et al.•Nature Sustainability•2018

  • Sustainability and resilience for transformation in the urban century

    Open Access•Thomas Elmqvist, Erik Andersson et al.•Nature Sustainability•2019

  • Principles for knowledge co-production in sustainability research

    Open Access•Albert V Norström, Christopher Cvitanovic et al.•Nature Sustainability•2020

  • To co-produce or not to co-produce

    Open Access•Maria Carmen Lemos, James Arnott et al.•Nature Sustainability•2018

  • Ten essentials for action-oriented and second order energy transitions, transformations and climate change research

    Open Access•I Fazey, N Schäpke et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • One world or two? Science–policy interactions in the climate field

    Göran Sundqvist, Des Gasper et al.•Critical Policy Studies•2017

  • Can science on transformation transform science? Lessons from co-design

    Open Access•Susanne C Moser•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2016

  • Making room and moving over

    Open Access•Nicole Latulippe, Nicole Klenk•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2019

  • Transdisciplinary global change research

    Open Access•Wolfram Mauser, Gernot Klepper et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2013

  • The politics of co-production

    Open Access•Esther Turnhout, Tamara Metze et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2019

  • Feedbacks as a bridging concept for advancing transdisciplinary sustainability research

    Open Access•Jessica Blythe, Kirsty L Nash et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2017

  • Co-design of transformative research for rangeland sustainability

    Open Access•Kathleen Galvin, Robin S Reid et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2016

  • Alternative approaches to co-design

    Open Access•Megan Parsons, Kathryn Fisher et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2016

  • Actionable knowledge and the art of engagement

    Open Access•Katharine J Mach, Maria Carmen Lemos et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2020

  • Great expectations? Reconciling the aspiration, outcome, and possibility of co-production

    Open Access•Kripa Jagannathan, James Arnott et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2020

  • Action, research and participation

    Open Access•Julia M Wittmayer, N Schäpke•Sustainability Science•2014

  • Transdisciplinary research in sustainability science

    Open Access•Daniel J Lang, Arnim Wiek et al.•Sustainability Science•2012

  • Values in transformational sustainability science

    Open Access•Andra-Ioana Horcea-Milcu, David J Abson et al.•Sustainability Science•2019

  • Constructing sustainability science

    Open Access•Thomas R Miller•Sustainability Science•2012

  • Exploring enabling resources for place-based social entrepreneurship

    Open Access•Angela Moriggi•Sustainability Science•2019

  • Conflicting roles of researchers in sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Ellen Bulten, L K Hessels et al.•Sustainability Science•2021

  • Learning to collaborate while collaborating

    Open Access•Rebecca Freeth, Guido Caniglia•Sustainability Science•2019

  • How knowledge enables governance

    Open Access•Franke van der Molen•Environmental Science & Policy•2018

  • A synthesis of the frameworks available to guide evaluations of research impact at the interface of environmental science, policy and practice

    Open Access•Elena Louder, Carina Wyborn et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2020

  • Participation-effect pathways in transdisciplinary sustainability research

    Open Access•L Fritz, Thorsten Schilling et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2019

  • Transdisciplinary co-production of knowledge and sustainability transformations

    Open Access•Flurina Schneider, Markus Giger et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2019

  • Knowledge co-production in practice

    Open Access•Daniel Puente-Rodríguez, Erik Van Slobbe et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2015

  • Grounding Ipbes experts’ views on the multiple values of nature in epistemology, knowledge and collaborative science

    Open Access•Viola Hakkarainen, Christopher B Anderson et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2019

  • Framework for participative reflection on the accomplishment of transdisciplinary research programs

    Open Access•Dirk J Roux, Richard Stirzaker et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2010

  • Scientist and stakeholder perspectives of transdisciplinary research

    Open Access•Mary Anne Thompson, Susan Owens et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2017

  • Performing a linear model

    Open Access•Kamilla Karhunmaa•Environmental Science & Policy•2020

  • Co-production in global sustainability

    Open Access•Cheryl Allyn Miller, Carina Wyborn•Environmental Science & Policy•2018

  • Climate change and transdisciplinary science

    Open Access•Nicole Klenk, Katie Meehan•Environmental Science & Policy•2015

  • Measuring sustainability

    Open Access•Stephen Williams, Steve Williams et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2019

  • Responsibilization and state territorialization

    Open Access•Violeta Gutiérrez-Zamora, Mara Hernández Estrada•Forest Policy and Economics•2020

  • Making actors, paradigms and ideologies visible in governance for sustainability

    Open Access•Peter Söderbaum•Sustainable Development•2009

  • Co-management and the co-production of knowledge

    Open Access•Derek Armitage, F Berkes et al.•Global Environmental Change•2011

  • The co-production of science and policy in integrated climate assessments

    Open Access•Maria Carmen Lemos, Barbara J Morehouse•Global Environmental Change•2005

  • University partnerships for co-designing and co-producing urban sustainability

    Open Access•G Trencher, Xuemei Bai et al.•Global Environmental Change•2014

  • A social–ecological systems analysis of impediments to delivery of the Aichi 2020 Targets and potentially more effective pathways to the conservation of biodiversity

    Open Access•Rosemary Hill, George A Dyer et al.•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • Is Adaptive Co-management Delivering? Examining Relationships Between Collaboration, Learning and Outcomes in Unesco Biosphere Reserves

    Open Access•Ryan Plummer, Julia Baird et al.•Ecological Economics•2017

  • Managing Impressions and Forests

    Elin Ångman, Lars Hallgren et al.•Society & Natural Resources•2011

  • Community Biodiversity Inventories as Entry Points for Local Ecosystem Stewardship in a South African Communal Area

    Christo Fabricius, Taryn Pereira•Society & Natural Resources•2015

  • Beyond Epistemology

    Open Access•Sheila Jasanoff•Social Studies of Science•1996

  • The Dark Side of Transformation

    Open Access•Jessica Blythe, Jennifer J Silver et al.•Antipode•2018

  • Connecting Diverse Knowledge Systems for Enhanced Ecosystem Governance

    Open Access•Maria Tengö, E S Brondizio et al.•AMBIO•2014

  • Resilience and Sustainable Development

    Carl Folke, Steve Carpenter et al.•AMBIO•2002

  • Postmodern? No, simply amodern! Steps towards an anthropology of science

    Open Access•Bruno Latour•Studies in History and Philosophy…•1990

  • Improving philosophical dialogue interventions to better resolve problematic value pluralism in collaborative environmental science

    Open Access•Bethany K Laursen, Chad Gonnerman et al.•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2021

  • Consulting versus participatory transdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Malin Mobjörk•Futures•2010

  • Transdisciplinary co-production

    Open Access•Merritt Polk•Futures•2015

  • Scientists’ situated knowledge

    Open Access•Judith Rosendahl, Matheus A Zanella et al.•Futures•2015

  • Beginning at the end

    Open Access•Cynthia Mitchell, Dana Cordell et al.•Futures•2015

  • Charting the emergence of a ‘knowing system’ for climate change adaptation in Australian regional natural resource management

    Open Access•Philip J Wallis, Karyn Bosomworth et al.•Geoforum•2017

  • Critical video engagements

    Open Access•Crystal Tremblay, L Harris•Geoforum•2018

  • The Adaptive Co-Management Process

    Open Access•Ryan Plummer•Conservation Ecology•2009

  • Experience and Education

    John Dewey•The Educational Forum•1986

  • Consumers as Coproducers of Public Services

    Open Access•Roger B Parks, Paula Baker et al.•Policy Studies Journal•1981

  • Dilemmas in a general theory of planning

    Open Access•Horst W J Rittel, Melvin M Webber•Policy Sciences•1973

  • Why is research-practice collaboration so challenging to achieve? A creative tourism experiment

    Open Access•Nancy Duxbury, Fiona Eva Bakas et al.•Tourism Geographies•2021

  • Learning from collaborative research on sustainably managing fresh water

    Open Access•Margaret L Ayre, Philip J Wallis et al.•Conservation Ecology•2018

  • Sustainability transformations

    Open Access•Per Olsson, Victor Galaz et al.•Conservation Ecology•2014

  • What is Social Learning

    Open Access•Myer S Reed, Mark S Reed et al.•Conservation Ecology•2010

  • Exploring and expanding transdisciplinary research for sustainable and just natural resource management

    Open Access•Margaret Gascoyne Wolff, Jessica J Cockburn et al.•Conservation Ecology•2019

  • A research process for integrating Indigenous and scientific knowledge in cultural landscapes

    Open Access•Leanne C Cullen‐unsworth, Rosemary Hill et al.•Geographical Journal•2012

Obras citantes distintas35
Citações por ano7
Intervalo de citações2021 - 2027 (7)
Velocidade de citaçãorecent
Altamente citadoNão
Tipos de citaçãoNeutras: 33
Ethnos_APP • Projeto Open Source • Licença MIT • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacidade e Cookies • Documentação da API: api.ethnos.app/docs • Código da API: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Código do Frontend: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae