What to Gain from Technical Sophistication

In a recent article in this journal, James McGregor (1993) criticizes political scientists for practicing regression analysis without recognizing the limitations in the regression technique. McGregor argues that the technique is inappropriate for political science research in many cases and suggests that we pay close attention to both the substantive (e.g., linearity and additivity) and statistical aspects of the technique. While acknowledging that many of us have not done enough to meet the statistical assumptions of regression analysis, George Krause (1994) argues that McGregor has underestimated the value of the technique to political science research. To support his argument, Krause directs our attention to a number of complicated regression models, including those designed for situations in which the dependent measure is a discrete variable (logit, probit, ordered probit, multinomial logit, Poisson, negative binomial and generalized event count) or the independent effects on the dependent variable are lagged distributed (polynomial distributed lag). He also mentions the recent developments related to event history regression, bootstrapping (a nonparametric approach to statistical inference), and vector autoregression (VAR, a creative use of OLS in simultaneous time series data). Krause deserves credit for his attempt to show us that the scope of the regression technique is not as narrow as McGregor might have assumed. However, in rejecting McGregor's pessimism, Krause does not realize that McGregor's major concern with regression analysis, as he illuminates by applying OLS to certain laws of nature, is not about the type of dependent variable but about relationships

Econometrics · Economics · Logit · Multinomial logistic regression · Polynomial regression · Probit · Probit model · Regression analysis · Regression diagnostic · Statistics · Variables · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Mathematics · Political Conflict and Governance · Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research

• Specification searches

  Edward E Leamer•Specification searches•1978

  Incluir item

• Is Regression Analysis Really Leading Political Science Down a Blind Alley

  Open Access•George Krause•PS Political Science & Politics•1994

  Incluir item

• Procrustus and the Regression Model

  Open Access•James P Mcgregor•PS Political Science & Politics•1993

  Incluir item

• Statistical Foundations of Econometric Modelling

  Hedley Rees, Aris Spanos•The Economic Journal•1988

  Incluir item

• The Relationship between Seats and Votes in Two-Party Systems

  Open Access•Edward R Tufte•American Political Science Review•1973

  Incluir item

• Enhancing Democracy Through Legislative Redistricting

  Open Access•Andrew Gelman, Gary King•American Political Science Review•1994

  Incluir item

• The Election of Blacks to City Councils

  Open Access•Richard L Engstrom, Michael D Mcdonald•American Political Science Review•1981

  Incluir item