Overcoming Word-Centrism

This article attempts to rethink the understanding of language as a “set of words” that correspond to the “objects” of external reality, which is characteristic of Western philosophy and lay perception. The following arguments are offered against this approach: the concept of “word” (like the actual division into morphology and syntax) has no metalinguistic status; the classification of parts of speech is languagespecific, so that the prototypical referential function of a “noun” cannot lay claim to the status of a universal linguistic function; and the idea of language as a “set of words” only reflects the specific metapragmatic awareness of speakers of European languages. Through examining the facts of linguistic diversity and linguistic functions in light of grammatical typology, the author shows that the most adequate interpretation of the relationship between language and reality is an understanding that characterizes language as a large-scale device for forcing its users towards a specific depiction of events. The author also emphasizes the fundamental specificity of the grammatical structure and usage models of each concrete linguistic system. In order to promote a philosophical understanding of language, it is necessary to move from a naïve model that operates with “word – reference – object” to a more realistic model involving “language (as a set of morphosyntactic patterns of conceptualization) – correspondence – event (as a complex situation involving meaning).”

Cognition · Conceptualization · Epistemology · Grammatical category · Linguistic relativity · Linguistics · Noun · Syntax · Word order · Computer Science · Historical Linguistics and Language Studies · Language, Metaphor, and Cognition · linguistics and terminology studies · Philosophy · Psychology

• The indeterminacy of word segmentation and the nature of morphology and syntax

  Martin Haspelmath•Folia Linguistica•2011

  Incluir item

• Language, Thought, and Reality

  Benjamin Lee Whorf, John B Carroll et al.•Language, Thought, and Reality•2015

  Incluir item

• Abnormal types of speech in Nootka

  E Sapir•1915

  Incluir item

• Parts of speech and dependent clauses in Functional Discourse Grammar

  Kees Hengeveld, Eva Van Lier•Studies in Language•2008

  Incluir item

• Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things

  George Lakoff•Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things•1987

  Incluir item