Comparative performance of multiple-list estimators of key population size

Estimates of the sizes of key populations (KPs) affected by HIV, including men who have sex with men, female sex workers and people who inject drugs, are required for targeting epidemic control efforts where they are most needed. Unfortunately, different estimators often produce discrepant results, and an objective basis for choice is lacking. This simulation study provides the first comparison of information-theoretic selection of loglinear models (LLM-AIC), Bayesian model averaging of loglinear models (LLM-BMA) and Bayesian nonparametric latent-class modeling (BLCM) for estimation of population size from multiple lists. Four hundred random samples from populations of size 1,000, 10,000 and 20,000, each including five encounter opportunities, were independently simulated using each of 30 data-generating models obtained from combinations of six patterns of variation in encounter probabilities and five expected per-list encounter probabilities, producing a total of 36,000 samples. Population size was estimated for each combination of sample and sequentially cumulative sets of 2–5 lists using LLM-AIC, LLM-BMA and BLCM. LLM-BMA and BLCM were quite robust and performed comparably in terms of root mean-squared error and bias, and outperformed LLM-AIC. All estimation methods produced uncertainty intervals which failed to achieve the nominal coverage, but LLM-BMA, as implemented in the dga R package produced the best balance of accuracy and interval coverage. The results also indicate that two-list estimation is unnecessarily vulnerable, and it is better to estimate the sizes of KPs based on at least three lists

Bayesian probability · Confidence interval · Coverage probability · Econometrics · Estimation · Estimator · Linear model · Log-linear model · Population · Sample size determination · Small area estimation · Statistics · Census and Population Estimation · Data-Driven Disease Surveillance · Demography · HIV, Drug Use, Sexual Risk · Mathematics

• Model Selection and Multimodel Inference

  Open Access•Fred S Guthery, Kenneth P Burnham et al.•Journal of Wildlife Management•2003

  Incluir item

• Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Worker Population in Tehran, Iran

  Open Access•Manoochehr Karami, Salman Khazaei et al.•AIDS and Behavior•2017

  Incluir item

• Estimating the Size of the MSM Population in Metro Vancouver, Canada, Using Multiple Methods and Diverse Data Sources

  Open Access•Ashleigh J Rich, Nathan Lachowsky et al.•Journal of Urban Health•2017

  Incluir item

• Population Size Estimation of Men Who Have Sex with Men in Ho Chi Minh City and Nghe An Using Social App Multiplier Method

  Open Access•Ali Safarnejad, Nguyen Thien Nga et al.•Journal of Urban Health•2017

  Incluir item

• Homosexuality and bisexuality in different populations

  Open Access•Milton Diamond•Archives of Sexual Behavior•1993

  Incluir item