Why estimates of the peat burned in fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan are unreliable and why it matters

Most recent estimates of carbon emissions from Indonesia's peatland fires are based on extrapolation from a narrow base of empirical evidence, raising concerns about the reliability of fire emissions estimates. Measurements of peat fires during ENSO periods are not representative of fires in other years, yet they underlie many estimates of peat fire emissions in ‘normal’ years. Errors may enter into estimates of area burned, quantity of peat combusted and fire emission factors. Problems arise in extrapolating from a few empirical measurements without accounting for conditions that influence combustibility of peat and the heavy fuels through which surface fires transition to become peat fires. These conditions are influenced by drainage and fire history. Our analysis is based on a critical look at a sample of peat fire and emissions studies, including the two most widely cited ones, as well as at the uses made of those studies. Undue extrapolation from unrepresentative empirical studies contributes significantly to the uncertainty of emissions estimates in studies that rely on models rather than empirical observation. We do not offer our own estimates; rather, we argue that the base of evidence must be broadened. We point to examples of empirically based research that more reliably show the contribution of peat fires to overall peatland carbon emissions

Climatology · Extrapolation · Geography · Greenhouse gas · Peat · Physical geography · Coastal wetland ecosystem dynamics · Environmental Science · Fire effects on ecosystems · Geology · Mathematics · Peatlands and Wetlands Ecology

• Fire governance research in the tropics

  Open Access•Christoph Neger, Claudia Monzón-Alvarado et al.•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2024

  Incluir item

• The Stratigraphy and Fire History of the Kutai Peatlands, Kalimantan, Indonesia

  Open Access•Geoffrey Hope, Unna Chokkalingam et al.•Quaternary Research•2005

  Incluir item

• Current and future CO 2 emissions from drained peatlands in Southeast Asia

  Open Access•A Hooijer, Susan Page et al.•Biogeosciences•2010

  Incluir item

• Global vulnerability of peatlands to fire and carbon loss

  Open Access•Merritt R Turetsky, Brian W Benscoter et al.•Nature Geoscience•2015

  Incluir item

• Global fire emissions and the contribution of deforestation, savanna, forest, agricultural, and peat fires (1997–2009)

  Open Access•Guido R van der Werf, James T Randerson et al.•Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics•2010

  Incluir item

• Committed carbon emissions, deforestation, and community land conversion from oil palm plantation expansion in West Kalimantan, Indonesia

  Open Access•K M Carlson, Lisa M Curran et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2012

  Incluir item

• Communicating uncertainty about facts, numbers and science

  Open Access•Anne Marthe Van Der Bles, Sander Van Der Linden et al.•Royal Society Open Science•2019

  Incluir item

• Fire science for rainforests

  Open Access•Mark A Cochrane•Nature•2003

  Incluir item

• The amount of carbon released from peat and forest fires in Indonesia during 1997

  Open Access•Susan Page, Susan E Page et al.•Nature•2002

  Incluir item

• Land Clearing and the Biofuel Carbon Debt

  Open Access•Joseph Fargione, Jason Hill et al.•Science•2008

  Incluir item

• Beyond slash‐and‐burn

  Open Access•J E Goldstein, Laura Graham et al.•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2020

  Incluir item

• From carbon sink to carbon source

  Open Access•Jukka Miettinen, A Hooijer et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2017

  Incluir item

• Assessing existing peatland models for their applicability for modelling greenhouse gas emissions from tropical peat soils

  Open Access•Jenny Farmer, Robin Matthews et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2011

  Incluir item

• Sources of anthropogenic fire ignitions on the peat-swamp landscape in Kalimantan, Indonesia

  Open Access•Megan E Cattau, Margaret E Harrison et al.•Global Environmental Change•2016

  Incluir item

• Land for the People

  Joe Studwell•Bulletin of Indonesian Economic…•2014

  Incluir item

• Causal Explanation of Indonesian Forest Fires

  Open Access•Andrew P Vayda•Human Ecology•2006

  Incluir item