The Tower of Babel of public sector accounting

Purpose This research analyses how public sector entities account for heritage assets managed by a private sector not-for-profit organization under a management contract, and how these assets are disclosed. Design/methodology/approach A documental analysis was carried out based on management contracts, financial statements and extra-accounting reports from Brazilian states that have contracted out the management of heritage assets. Findings Results show that although some heritage assets are disclosed, inconsistency is observed regarding the recognition and disclosure criteria in the financial statements and extra-accounting reports among states and within each state. In cases where heritage assets were recognized, no information on fair value measurement procedures and on subsequent expenditures treatment was found. Originality/value The need to control, preserve and recognize heritage assets has raised heated discussions in the public sector accounting field. Accounting issues related to their recognition, measurement and disclosure are intensified when these assets are the subject of a partnership between governments and private not-for-profit organizations, given that these contracts increase the information demand for decision-making and accountability. This research adds evidence that current accounting requirements for heritage assets are not leading to comparability of public sector financial statements, including when they are under third parties' management, instead generating a Tower of Babel-like scenario

Accounting management · Assets under management · Comparability · Cultural heritage · Private sector · Public sector · Accounting and Organizational Management · Cultural Heritage Management and Preservation · Facilities and Workplace Management

• T he F inancial V alue O f C ultural , H eritage A nd S cientific C ollections

  Open Access•Garry D Carnegie, Peter W Wolnizer•Australian Accounting Review•1995

  Incluir item

• An Overlooked Cost of Contracting Out

  Open Access•Gyeo Reh Lee, Sergio Fernandez et al.•Public Personnel Management•2021

  Incluir item

• Heritage assets in financial reporting

  Open Access•Lucia Biondi, Fabio Giulio Grandis et al.•Journal of Public Budgeting…•2021

  Incluir item

• Accountability in outsourced public service delivery

  Deshani Chathurangani Hettiarachchi, Dessalegn Mihret et al.•Public Management Review•2025

  Incluir item

• Public Value Management

  Open Access•Gerry Stoker•The American Review of Public…•2006

  Incluir item

• A replication of “Contracting out

  Open Access•Lachezar G Anguelov, Benjamin M Brunjes•Public Administration•2023

  Incluir item

• The effect of Ipsas on reforming governmental financial reporting

  Open Access•Johan Christiaens, Christophe Vanhee et al.•International Review of…•2015

  Incluir item

• A Public Management for All Seasons

  Open Access•Christopher Hood•Public Administration•1991

  Incluir item