Historical Inferences from Guttman Scales

Inferences about historical sequences are frequently drawn from Guttman scales, on the supposition that each item in the scale serves as a "functional prerequisite" for successive items. The validity of such inferences is here called into question on both theoretical and empirical grounds. Logically, such inferences are subject to the same limitations as inferences about the age of a trait based on its geographic distribution (the discredited "age-area" hypothesis). This is true even if specific scale items are seen as indices of broader evolutionary "stages," or if the unidimensional nature of the Guttman scale serves only as the basis for inferring some underlying unilinear evolutionary process. To test these notions empirically, 40 Mexican communities, varying widely in location, population, economic base, and social attributes, were investigated. Within each, data were gathered on the presence or absence of 24 traits typically selected for Guttman scaling, together with their actual historical sequence. A Guttman scale of high reproducibility was constructed from these trait lists, though some issues concerning the reliability of scaling were also raised. The developmental sequence inferred from this scale was then correlated with the historical sequences. Few correlations were negative, but the majority fell below .7, thus accounting for less than 50% of the variance. An alternative explanation for even this level of correlation was provided in the association found between population size and scale step (.83). An examination of the historical data also suggested that the actual processes occurring in Mexican communities resemble more closely a "multilinear" or a "systems" model of developmental growth than the unilinear model which Guttman scales are sometimes thought to imply

Cartography · Geography · Guttman scale · Population · Scale (ratio · Sociology · Statistics · Trait · Birth, Development, and Health · Computer Science · Demography · Genetic and phenotypic traits in livestock · Insurance, Mortality, Demography, Risk Management · Mathematics · Psychology · Social Psychology

• Too Many Types

  Open Access•G M Feinman, Gary Feinman et al.•Advances in archaeological method…•1984

  Incluir item

• Reply to the ‘comments on computers in archaeology’

  Mario Borillo•Norwegian Archaeological Review•1971

  Incluir item

• Guttman Scaling

  David B Kronenfeld•Man•1972

  Incluir item

• Process, statistics and anthropological theory

  Douglas R White•Reviews in Anthropology•1975

  Incluir item

• Foundations of the Age-Area Hypothesis

  Open Access•M J Baker•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2021

  Incluir item

• Sarg

  The Members Of Sarg, The Members of SARG The Members of SARG•World Archaeology•1974

  Incluir item

• Incipient Development and Vocational Evolution in Dominica

  William Rodgers, William Blake Rodgers•Human Organization•1971

  Incluir item

• The Reality of Differences between Small Communities in Michoacán, Mexico

  Open Access•Mary Lee Nolan•American Anthropologist•1974

  Incluir item

• Using Guttman Scaling to Rank Wealth

  Open Access•Greg Guest•CAM•2000

  Incluir item