Pular para o conteúdo principal

ETHNOS_APP

Início • Busca • Periódicos • Lista 0

Rejecting, reframing, and reintroducing

Trans People's Strategic Engagement With the Medicalisation of Gender Dysphoria

Dados Bibliográficos

ID2249481
AutoresAustin H Johnson (0000-0003-3547-3863, Kenyon College Gambier Ohio USA, autor correspondente)
Ano2019
Volume41
Fascículo3
Páginas517-532
Data de publicação2019-03-01
Peer ReviewedSim
Open AccessSim
TipoARTICLE
PeriódicoSociology of Health & Illness (JOURNAL)
Identificadores do periódicoISSN: 0141-9889 • E-ISSN: 1467-9566
EditoraWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/1467-9566.12829
PMID30484870
OpenAlexW2903201828
IdiomaEN
Citações recebidas52
Referências citadas46

This article uses ethnographic methods to explore how transgender people engage the medicalisation of transgender experience in a U.S. context under the purview of the American Psychiatric Association. Building on sociological literature related to medicalisation, this paper argues that the lived experience of medicalisation is a non-linear, complex process whereby individual engagement with medical authority is both empowering and constraining in the lives of trans people. Inductive qualitative analysis of 158 hours of participant observation and 33 in-depth interviews with members of a transgender community organisation revealed that transgender individuals (i) reject a medical frame for gender dysphoria, (ii) embrace and stress the importance of gender-affirming medical technologies for individual identity development and social interaction and (iii) strategically reintroduce medical logics and embrace medical authority in order to facilitate medical and social recognition, validation and acceptance

Cognitive reframing · Dysphoria · Gender dysphoria · Gender identity · Political science · Psychiatry · African Sexualities and LGBTQ+ Issues · LGBTQ Health, Identity, and Policy · Psychology · Sexuality, Behavior, and Technology · Social Psychology

  • Medicalization in Global Context

    Open Access•Meredith Bergey•Sociology Compass•2024

  • Mental health practitioners’ narratives about gender transition and the role of diagnosis

    Open Access•Jessica Neri, Antonio Iudici et al.•Health & Social Care in the…•2022

  • Medicalization and Masculinities

    Open Access•Karen Hvidtfeldt, Camilla Bruun Eriksen et al.•Kvinder Køn & Forskning•2020

  • The influence of a hostile environment on a syndemic of depression, stress and chronic limiting illness among LGBTQ+ people during the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Dylan Kneale, Laia Bécares•Sociology of Health & Illness•2024

  • Illness-Care and Validation-Dependency in the Diagnostic Model for Trans Healthcare

    Open Access•Yuumi Konishi•Sociology of Health & Illness•2025

  • Negotiating Care

    Open Access•Karl Atkin, Christine Jackson‐taylor•Sociology of Health & Illness•2025

  • Don't think that we die from Aids

    Open Access•R Farber•Sociology of Health & Illness•2023

  • Experiences and narratives of mandatory psychological assessment in Trans and Nonbinary people

    Open Access•C De Vincenzo, Andrea Garolla et al.•BMC Psychology•2025

  • Effects of medicalization on case outcomes in transgender employment discrimination court decisions

    Open Access•Kyla Bender-Baird, Margaret C Stevenson•Behavioral Sciences & the Law•2024

  • Transgender healthcare, telehealth, venture capital and community

    Gwyn Easterbrook-Smith•Queer Studies in Media & Popular…•2023

  • The power of persuasion

    Open Access•Emily S Mann•SSM - Qualitative Research in…•2022

  • Accounting for Cisnormativity

    Open Access•Nik M Lampe•Social Currents•2023

  • The institution of medicine and transgender identity construction

    Open Access•Lindsay Toman•Sociology Compass•2021

  • Disability at the intersections

    Open Access•Dara Shifrer, Angela Frederick•Sociology Compass•2019

  • Psychologists' representations of gender identity between Spain and Greece

    Open Access•Konstantinos Argyriou•Personal Relationships•2023

  • What to Say and What to Omit? Strategies and Self-Narratives for Obtaining a Diagnosis in Gender Transition

    Open Access•Elena Faccio, Laura Sebastio et al.•Sexuality & Culture•2023

  • (Un)Belonging

    Open Access•G Trey Jenkins•Affilia•2023

  • Exploratory Analysis of the Role of Transnormativity in the Association Between Gender Dysphoria and Psychological Distress

    Open Access•Greyson Mize, Louis Lindley•Sex Roles•2025

  • Sociocultural Messages about Gender Dysphoria (Dis)Align with the Lived Experiences of Trans and Nonbinary Individuals

    Open Access•Louis Lindley, Joonwoo Lee et al.•Sex Roles•2024

  • Cultivated co-production

    Open Access•Steven Epstein•Social Studies of Science•2021

  • More Necessary than Medical

    Elizabeth Dietz•International Journal of Feminist…•2020

  • Current vs. Desired

    Open Access•Maric Martin Lorusso, Christian Compare et al.•Sexuality Research and Social…•2023

  • Perspectives of Thai Transgender Adults on Diagnostic Criteria for Transsexualism, Gender Incongruence, and Gender Dysphoria

    Open Access•Thanapob Bumphenkiatikul, Somboon Hataiyusuk et al.•International Journal of Sexual…•2024

  • Identifying coping strategies used by patients at a transgender health clinic through analysis of free‐text autobiographical narratives

    Open Access•Angela Zottola, Lucy Jones et al.•Health Expectations•2021

  • “If I accept it is all a symptom, I won't be able to do my job”

    Open Access•Kentaro Ishijima•SSM - Qualitative Research in…•2026

  • Forced to adapt

    Open Access•Harry Barbee, Jordan Ramnarine et al.•SSM - Qualitative Research in…•2026

  • “Welcome! Oh, wait…” Transgender Military Service in a Time of Uncertainty

    Open Access•M Sheridan Embser-Herbert, Máel Embser‐Herbert•Sociological Inquiry•2019

  • Finding natural variation

    Open Access•Cal Lee Garrett•BioSocieties•2022

  • Trans youth in Portugal

    Open Access•Ana Patrícia Hilário, Ana Cristina Marques•Culture Health & Sexuality•2020

  • The sociology of prescribing

    Open Access•A K Smith•Social Science & Medicine•2025

  • Framing discomfort on YouTube

    Open Access•Letizia Paglialunga•Revista Alicantina de Estudios…•2024

  • Dissociation as Dislocation From Violence

    Open Access•John Logan, Jenny Logan et al.•Humanity & Society•2023

  • Understanding Sex as Leisure Among Transgender Men Using Foucauldian Theorization

    Xue Yan, Liza Berdychevsky•Leisure Sciences•2026

  • Das Unbehagen an der Ordinalisierung

    Open Access•Alex V Barnard, Marion Fourcade•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2021

  • I Can be a Voice for People

    Austin H Johnson, Baker A Rogers et al.•Social movement studies•2025

  • "That's not at all what I needed" trans adults' perspectives on trans-affirming primary care and eating disorders

    Open Access•Emil K Smith, Erin N Harrop•Social Science & Medicine•2024

  • The struggle with transnormativity

    Open Access•Stef Murawsky•Social Science & Medicine•2023

  • We have knowledge that is unique

    Open Access•Inna Blus-Kadosh, G Hartal•Social Science & Medicine•2024

  • Accounting for neuronormativity in transgender medicine

    Open Access•Nic Rios•Social Science & Medicine•2025

  • Waiting to be seen

    Christy E Newman, A K Smith et al.•Health Sociology Review•2021

  • For whom is ignorance bliss? Ignorance, its functions and transformative potential in trans health

    Open Access•Magdalena Mikulak•Journal of Gender Studies•2021

  • A little bubble of utopia

    Alex Ker, Gertrude Fraser et al.•Health Sociology Review•2021

  • Pursuing Gender Euphoria

    Open Access•Kai W Mckinney, David G Ortiz•Gender & Society•2025

  • Coming Into Identity

    Open Access•Sonny Nordmarken•Gender & Society•2023

  • Gender Identity, the Sexed Body, and the Medical Making of Transgender

    Open Access•T Gonsalves•Gender & Society•2020

  • Continuity and Change in Gender Frames

    Open Access•Nik M Lampe, K Carter et al.•Gender & Society•2019

  • Pills Don't Teach Skills

    Open Access•Meredith Bergey•Journal of Health and Social…•2024

  • Health and Health Care of Sexual and Gender Minorities

    Open Access•N Hsieh, Stef M Shuster•Journal of Health and Social…•2021

  • We're the Normal Ones Here

    Open Access•Austin H Johnson, Baker A Rogers•Sociological Inquiry•2020

  • Expanding Transgender Studies in Sociology

    Open Access•J E Sumerau•Sociological Inquiry•2020

  • Trans Enough

    Open Access•David Kyle Sutherland•Social Problems•2023

  • Foreclosing Fluidity at the Intersection of Gender and Sexual Normativities

    Open Access•J E Sumerau, Lain A B Mathers et al.•Symbolic Interaction•2020

  • Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders

    American Psychiatric Association American Psychiatric Association, Ewer Ewer•Diagnostic And Statistical Manual…•2013

  • The Medicalization of Society

    Peter Conrad•The Medicalization of Society•2007

  • Social determinants of mental health

    Jessica Allen, Reuben Balfour et al.•International Review of Psychiatry•2014

  • Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders

    NA &NA•Alzheimer Disease & Associated…•1988

  • Minding the body

    Jack Drescher, Peggy T Cohen-Kettenis et al.•International Review of Psychiatry•2012

  • Toward an anthropology of women.

    Rayna R Reiter•Toward an anthropology of women.•1977

  • Deviance and medicalization

    Peter Conrad•Deviance and medicalization•1985

  • Black on Both Sides

    C Riley Snorton•Black on both sides•2017

  • Challenges of implementing collaborative models of decision making with trans‐identified patients

    Open Access•Jodie M Dewey•Health Expectations•2015

  • Beyond Conundrum

    Kelley Winters, Randall D Ehrbar•Journal of Gay & Lesbian Mental…•2010

  • Normative Accountability

    Open Access•Austin H Johnson•Sociology Compass•2015

  • Response of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health to the Proposed DSM 5 Criteria for Gender Incongruence

    Griet De Cuypere, Gail Knudson et al.•International Journal of…•2010

  • Female Gender Dysphoria in Context

    Open Access•Holly Devor, Aaron Devor•Annual Review of Sex Research•1996

  • "Transsexuals' Narrative Construction of the "True Self

    Douglas Mason-Schrock•Social Psychology Quarterly•1996

  • (Dys) Functional Diagnosing

    Open Access•Jodie M Dewey, Melissa M Gesbeck•Humanity & Society•2017

  • The Case for the World Health Organization’s Commission on Social Determinants of Health to Address Gender Identity

    Frank Pega, Jaimie F Veale•American Journal of Public Health•2015

  • Stigma as a Fundamental Cause of Population Health Inequalities

    Mark L Hatzenbuehler, Jo C Phelan et al.•American Journal of Public Health•2013

  • Queer Diagnoses

    Open Access•Jack Drescher•Archives of Sexual Behavior•2010

  • Deep down where the music plays

    Open Access•T Meadows•Sexualities•2011

  • Standards of Care for the Health of Transsexual, Transgender, and Gender-Nonconforming People, Version 7

    Eli Coleman, Walter Bockting et al.•International Journal of…•2012

  • Knowledge Legitimacy

    Open Access•Jodie M Dewey•Qualitative Health Research•2008

  • Stigma

    Open Access•Linda M Whiteford, Luis O González et al.•Social Science & Medicine•1995

  • Medicalization, Ambivalence and Social Control

    Open Access•Claudia Malacrida•Health An Interdisciplinary…•2004

  • Medicine as an Institution of Social Control

    Open Access•Irving Kenneth Zola•The Sociological Review•1972

  • YouTube as a Site of Counternarratives to Transnormativity

    Jordan Forrest Miller•Journal of Homosexuality•2019

  • Socialising Disease

    Open Access•Joanna Latimer•The Sociological Review•2000

  • Social Conditions As Fundamental Causes of Disease

    Bruce G Link, Jo C Phelan et al.•Journal of Health and Social…•1995

  • Conformity Pressures and Gender Resistance among Transgendered Individuals

    Patricia Gagné, Richard Tewksbury•Social Problems•1998

  • Doing Gender

    Open Access•Candace West, Don H Zimmerman•Gender & Society•1987

  • On the Limits of 'Trans Enough

    Open Access•Spencer Garrison•Gender & Society•2018

  • Giving Sex

    Open Access•Georgiann Davis, Jodie M Dewey et al.•Gender & Society•2016

  • A Rose is a Rose

    Open Access•T Meadows•Gender & Society•2010

  • Medicalization and Social Control

    Peter Conrad•Annual Review of Sociology•1992

  • Transnormativity

    Open Access•Austin H Johnson•Sociological Inquiry•2016

  • Knowledge and Power, Body and Self

    Open Access•Patricia Gagné, Richard Tewksbury•Sociological Quarterly•1999

  • Social movements in health

    Open Access•Phil Brown, Zavestoski et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2004

  • Medicalisation reconsidered

    Open Access•Dorothy H Broom, Roslyn V Woodward et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•1996

  • Illnesses you have to fight to get

    Open Access•Joseph Dumit•Social Science & Medicine•2006

Obras citantes distintas52
Citações por ano7,43
Intervalo de citações2019 - 2026 (8)
Velocidade de citaçãocurrent
Altamente citadoNão
Tipos de citaçãoNeutras: 45
Ethnos_APP • Projeto Open Source • Licença MIT • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacidade e Cookies • Documentação da API: api.ethnos.app/docs • Código da API: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Código do Frontend: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae