A Critical Examination of the Historical Origins of Connexive Logic

It is often assumed that Aristotle, Boethius, Chrysippus, and other ancient logicians advocated a connexive conception of implication according to which no proposition entails, or is entailed by, its own negation. Thus Aristotle claimed that the proposition ‘if B is not great, B itself is great [...] is impossible’. Similarly, Boethius maintained that two implications of the type ‘If p then r’ and ‘If p then not-r’ are incompatible. Furthermore, Chrysippus proclaimed a conditional to be ‘sound when the contradictory of its consequent is incompatible with its antecedent’, a view which, in the opinion of S. McCall, entails the aforementioned theses of Aristotle and Boethius. Now a critical examination of the historical sources shows that the ancient logicians most likely meant their theses as applicable only to ‘normal’ conditionals with antecedents which are not self-contradictory. The corresponding restrictions of Aristotle’s and Boethius’ theses to such self-consistent antecedents, however, turn out to be theorems of ordinary modal logic and thus don’t give rise to any non-classical system of genuinely connexive logic.

Antecedent (behavioral psychology) · Deontic logic · Epistemology · Linguistics · Negation · Proposition · Classical Philosophy and Thought · Medieval and Classical Philosophy · Philosophy · Psychology

• Connexivity and the Pragmatics of Conditionals

  Open Access•Andreas Kapsner•Erkenntnis•2022

  Incluir item

• What Follows from the Impossible

  Wolfgang Lenzen•History and Philosophy of Logic•2022

  Incluir item

• Connexivity in Aristotle’s Logic

  Fabian Ruge•History and Philosophy of Logic•2023

  Incluir item

• An Introduction to Non-Classical Logic

  Open Access•Graham Priest•Introduction to Non-Classical Logic•2008

  Incluir item

• Leibniz's laws of consistency and the philosophical foundations of connexive logic

  Open Access•Wolfgang Lenzen•Logic and Logical Philosophy•2019

  Incluir item

• The complete works of Aristotle

  Open Access•Bernard H Baumrin•Metaphilosophy•1986

  Incluir item

• Boethius

  John Marenbon•Boethius•2003

  Incluir item

• Boethius. His Life, Thought and Influence

  Open Access•J Mcevoy•Irish Theological Quarterly•1983

  Incluir item

• On systems containing Aristotle's thesis

  Open Access•Richard Routley, Hugh Montgomery•The Journal of Symbolic Logic•1968

  Incluir item

• A History Of Connexivity

  Open Access•Storrs Mccall•Logic•2012

  Incluir item

• The Propositional Logic of Boethius

  Karl Dürr•The propositional logic of Boethius•1951

  Incluir item