Historicism and Critique in H erder's Another Philosophy of History

In Another Philosophy of History , J . G . H erder claims that his aim is not to compare and judge different cultures, but merely to describe and explain how each came into being and thus to adopt the standpoint of an impartial observer. I argue, however, that there is a tension between H erder's understanding of his own project—his stated doctrine of historicism and cultural relativism—and the way in which it is actually put into practice. That is, despite H erder's stated aims, he is nevertheless unable to avoid justifying premodern forms of life and making context‐transcending evaluative judgments in the process of trying to understand cultures on their own terms and holding them up as exemplars vis à vis the Enlightenment. This tension presents the challenge of accounting for it in the most charitable and illuminating way. I argue that this goal can be achieved by appealing to the resources of the philosophical hermeneutics of H ans‐ G eorg G adamer, which enables us to disclose two enabling conditions for H erder's project of which he was not explicitly aware, viz., the internal connection between understanding and justification and the enabling character of prejudice as the condition for the possibility of understanding as such.

Context (archaeology) · Doctrine · Enlightenment · Epistemology · Hermeneutics · Historicism · Prejudice (legal term) · Relativism · Sociology · Theology · Classical Philosophy and Thought · Historical Philosophy and Science · Philosophical Ethics and Theory · Philosophy · Psychology · Social Psychology

• Kantian Dignity and its Difficulties

  Karl Ameriks•Kantian Dignity and its…•2024

  Incluir item

• Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective

  Donald Davidson, Donald Herbert Davidson•Subjective, intersubjective,…•2001

  Incluir item

• Rationality and Relativism

  Ian Charles Jarvie•Rationality and Relativism•2015

  Incluir item

• The Fate of Reason

  Open Access•Frederick C Beiser•Fate of Reason•1987

  Incluir item