Weber's interpretive project and the practical failure of meaningful action

The practical failure to understand in conflicts, where participants routinely challenge each other's attribution of meaning, undermines the key assumption of the Weberian interpretive project: that the subject acts meaningfully. This article revisits Weber's concept of meaning as an object of understanding for a social scientist. Ascertaining the empirical fact of subjective attribution, as Weber advised, may not be sufficient when it comes to understanding action whose meaning is disputed. The article uses the example of E.P. Thompson's interpretation of eighteenth-century English food riots to show that the disputed empirical meaning is a product of rational understanding, which Weber would classify as dogmatic meaning. The social scientist fails to understand what the critic claims to: a failure to act meaningfully in cultural terms. Furthermore, because the subject acts meaningfully without fail, we close off the option of explaining conflict as a rational disagreement

Action (physics · Attribution · Epistemology · Interpretation (philosophy · Linguistics · Meaning (existential · Object (grammar · Sociology · Subject (documents · Computer Science · Philosophy · Political Conflict and Governance · Populism, Right-Wing Movements · Psychology · Social Psychology · Weber, Simmel, Sociological Theory

• Whose Justice? Which Rationality?

  Alasdair Macintyre•New Social Theory Reader•2020

  Incluir item

• Max Weber on the Methodology of the Social Sciences

  Edward Shils, Max Weber•Max Weber on the Methodology of…•2022

  Incluir item

• The Claims of Culture

  Seyla Benhabib•Claims of Culture•2002

  Incluir item

• Conjectures and Refutations

  Karl Popper, Melitta Mew et al.•Conjectures and Refutations•2014

  Incluir item

• Economy and Society

  Claus Wittich, Guenther Roth et al.•Economy and Society•2013

  Incluir item

• Roscher and Knies

  Max Weber•Roscher and Knies•1975

  Incluir item

• Customs in common

  E P Thompson•Customs in common•1991

  Incluir item

• Challenging Codes

  Open Access•Alberto Melucci•Challenging Codes•1996

  Incluir item

• Langage et pouvoir symbolique

  Pierre Bourdieu, John B Thompson•Langage et pouvoir symbolique•2001

  Incluir item

• Economy and Society

  Max Weber•Readings in Economic Sociology•2002

  Incluir item

• Critique of Stammler

  Thomas Burger, Max Weber et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1978

  Incluir item

• The Rites of Violence

  Natalie Zemon Davis•Past & Present•1973

  Incluir item

• From Max Weber

  Max Weber, H H Gerth et al.•From Max Weber•2014

  Incluir item

• Introduction

  Open Access•François Dubet, Henri Lustiger Thaler•Current Sociology•2004

  Incluir item

• Resonance and Radicalism

  Myra Marx Ferree•American Journal of Sociology•2003

  Incluir item

• Movements and media

  Open Access•Ruud Koopmans•Theory and Society•2004

  Incluir item