Fewer Procedures, More Reflection

A Rejoinder to Duşa and Marx

Dados Bibliográficos

ID2407697
AutoresAlrik Thiem (0000-0002-4769-2185, University of Lucerne, autor correspondente), Lusine Mkrtchyan (0000-0003-3931-7462, University of Lucerne)
Ano2024
Volume36
Fascículo1
Páginas74-79
Data de publicação2024-02-01
Peer ReviewedSim
Open AccessSim
TipoARTICLE
PeriódicoCAM (JOURNAL)
Identificadores do periódicoISSN: 1087-8513 • E-ISSN: 1552-3969
EditoraSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1525822x231159461
PMID38126025
OpenAlexW4327729173
IdiomaEN
Citações recebidas1
Referências citadas17

We thank Adrian Dus ̧a and Axel Marx for their comment on our evaluation of Marx and Dus ̧a (2011; hereafter MD).We believe that such exchanges are indispensable for developing a full understanding of many procedures in qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) that have for too long remained entirely unquestioned.We welcome this exchange, but we will also demonstrate in our rejoinder why Dus ̧a and Marx's comment once more underlines the urgent need for more reflection on QCA, all the more so because QCA's algorithmic core-Boolean optimization-has been swiftly imported in the 1980s from electrical engineering without much reflection at all. 1 Contrary to our expectations, Dus ̧a and Marx do not take issue with the core part of Thiem and Mkrtchyan (2023): the extensive simulations we have carried out and their results that have been summarized in Figure 2. Instead, their comment focuses on: (1) our failure to propose an enhancement of their benchmarks; (2) our use of constants in QCA; (3) our neglect of logical remainders; and (4) our reanalysis of the applied study by Muriaas et al. (2022).We successively address each of these points.(1) "[T]heir paper does not present any replacement solution over MD, nor do they somehow improve on MD."If your doctor tells you that smoking is unhealthy, the best thing to do is to quit, not to replace cigarettes with cigars or to "improve" your cigarettes with

Economics · Epistemology · Positive economics · Psychoanalysis · Reflection (computer programming · Sociology · Computer Science · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Philosophy · Policy Transfer and Learning · Psychology · Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research