Harmonious Accommodation among Coexisting Multicultural Ethical Frameworks through Confrontation

This paper interrogates the skepticism surrounding comparative ethics, particularly the question of its relevance in a world where ethical decision-making processes are primarily presumed to be dictated by one universalist culture. The paper argues that all cultures are inherently intercultural, evidenced by the historical coexistence of ideas and practices. Post-comparative ethics, which emphasizes the situational application of intellectual comparison and integration, is inevitable for postcolonial, non-Western societies. Historically, societies have navigated a variety of ethical frameworks, with some, like medieval Chinese society, embracing a plurality of beliefs. This pluralism is exemplified by the harmonious accommodation (yuanrong 圓融) of Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism. Using the example of Song Dynasty Chan master Dahui Zonggao 大慧宗杲, this article illustrates that intercultural ethics can be both diverse and sincere. Dahui's pluralistic approach demonstrates that sincere commitment to multiple ethical systems is possible in our multicultural situation. I will discuss common approaches to the multicultural situation, such as expedient synthesis, theoretical synthesis, and crude syncretism, before illustrating the advantage of Dahui's kanhua 看話禪method as harmonious accommodation through confrontation. This underscores the importance of shifting the debate from "Why compare?" to "How to compare?" in achieving the accommodation of different ethical frameworks

Accommodation · Buddhism · Constructive · Environmental ethics · Epistemology · Multiculturalism · Political science · Situational ethics · Skepticism · Sociology · Chinese history and philosophy · Cultural Differences and Values · Indian and Buddhist Studies · Philosophy · Psychology

• Buddhism and Taoism Face to Face

  Christine Mollier•Buddhism and Taoism Face to Face•2008

  Incluir item

• How Zen Became Zen

  Morten Schlütter•How Zen became Zen•2008

  Incluir item

• Chan Insights and Oversights

  Bernard Faure•Chan Insights and Oversights•1993

  Incluir item

• The Invention of World Religions

  Tomoko Masuzawa•The Invention of World Religions•2005

  Incluir item