Taking detours toward the Aufhebung of Religion

This article responds to Roland Boer's Marxism and Theology (2007-13) that offers a unique contribution to understanding the current impasse in revolutionary Left politics and illustrates the importance of the numerous references to theology in Marxist literature. In this response, I focus on Boer's argument of Marxism and Judaeo-Christian theology occupying a similar contested space with respect to their uses of "political myth." I argue that the key to Boer's critical project is a two-pronged approach: "materializing" theology and "theologizing" historical materialism. For this critical endeavor to make inroads, it relies not just on the ambivalence of political myth, but also that myths are essential to Marxist theories of emancipation, as well as to Marx's notion of "the Aufhebung of Religion." I focus on two figures: Ernst Bloch as a Marxist who emphasizes myth's emancipatory qualities; and Theodor Adorno as wary of myth while adhering to the theological motif of the bilderverbot. From this analysis, we can begin to see how much Boer's project depends on a wager on political myth itself

Critical theory · Emancipation · Epistemology · Marxist philosophy · Materialism · Mythology · Political science · Political theology · Politics · Sociology · Theology · Critical Theory and Philosophy · Law · Philosophy · Political Economy and Marxism · Religious studies · Walter Benjamin Studies Compilation

• Criticism of Heaven

  Roland Boer•Criticism of Heaven•2007

  Incluir item

• Criticism of Religion

  Roland Boer•Criticism of religion•2009

  Incluir item

• Political Myth

  Roland Boer, Creston Davis et al.•Political Myth•2020

  Incluir item

• Criticism of Earth

  Roland Boer•Criticism of Earth•2012

  Incluir item

• Criticism of Theology

  Roland Boer•Criticism of theology•2011

  Incluir item