Mixed Messages

If, as many historians and theorists now believe, narrative is the formproper to historical explanation, this raises the problem of the terms in which such narratives areto be evaluated. Without a clear account of evaluation, the status of historical knowledge (both initself and in all those social, political, and other contexts in which appeal to historical explanationis made) remains obscure. Beginning with the view, found in Hayden White and others, thathistorical narrative constitutes a meaning not reducible to the factual content it engages, thisessay argues that such meaning can arise only through a synthesis of cognitive and normativediscourses. Narrative combines "heterogeneous" language games in such a waythat neither appeal to "truth content" nor to "justice" suffices todecide the question of which of two competing historical explanations is, as a whole, superior.Examining in critical detail the opposed positions on this issue articulated by two recenttheorists-Frank Ankersmit ("narrative idealism") and David Carr("narrative realism")-the paper concludes that the debate between thosewho hold that historical narratives should be judged in essentially cognitive terms and those whohold that they should be judged in essentially political terms cannot be resolved and that aphilosophical view of historical narrative that is neither realist nor idealist needs to be developed

Aesthetics · Appeal · Carr · Epistemology · Idealism · Linguistics · Meaning (existential · Narrative · Narrative criticism · Narrative history · Narrative inquiry · Narrative network · Narrative psychology · Political science · Politics · Realism · Sociology · White (mutation · Law · Philosophy · Philosophy, History, and Historiography

• Scholar’s Symposium

  Open Access•Steven Crowell•Human Studies•2007

  Incluir item

• Digital archives, e‐books and narrative space

  Open Access•George Revill, Kim Hammond et al.•Area•2020

  Incluir item

• Frank Ankersmit

  Ewa Domańska•Rethinking History•2009

  Incluir item

• As Independências do Brasil

  Open Access•Jurandir Malerba•História (São Paulo•2005

  Incluir item