The Dilemma of Anti-Xenophobia Discourse in the Aftermath of Violence in De Doorns

In this article we examine the rhetoric and functions of anti-xenophobic discourse, in particular as it was deployed in the aftermath of a violent attempt by South Africans to expel the Zimbabwean migrant labouring community from the informal settlements of De Doorns, a grape-farming town in the Western Cape. While acknowledging that anti-xenophobia discourse constitutes a well-intentioned attempt to counter anti-foreigner violence, we critique it on two counts. In Part I we critique the way that such discourse in the academy presents the ‘xenophobic’ agents of such violence as morally or psychologically depraved and politically beyond the pale. We argue that such representations are unhelpful for understanding what was actually ‘going on’ in the De Doorns episode. In Part II we narrate the events of November 2009 in De Doorns, making use of research conducted by the Forced Migration Studies Program (FMSP), and offering an alternative version of what was ‘going on’ in the De Doorns violence according to the informal settlement residents we interviewed in our own research. In Part III we critique the anti-xenophobic discourse that was employed by role players after the De Doorns violence for the way it largely overlooked the problem that farmers' pronouncements of anti-xenophobic morality served simultaneously to defend a system which produced some of the very conditions for this violence to occur in the first place. We suggest that FMSP's report elided this dilemma because of its self-professed commitment to an anti-xenophobic position

Criminology · Dilemma · Epistemology · Morality · Political science · Racism · Rhetoric · Sociology · Xenophobia · African studies and sociopolitical issues · Gender Studies · Law

• Wage Employment in Africa

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• High-Yielding Variety Policies in Africa

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• The Trade Imperative

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• Technical Change and Agricultural Productivity

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• Uneven, Contradictory, and Brutal Economic Development in Africa

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• Varieties of Common Sense

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• Unbalanced Development

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• Investment, Wage Goods, and Industrial Policy

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• Working Out the Solution to Rural Poverty

  Open Access•Christopher Cramer, John Sender et al.•African Economic Development•2020

  Incluir item

• An Assessment of Xenophobic/Afrophobic Attacks in South Africa (2008–2015)

  Lere Amusan, Siphiwe Mchunu•Society in Transition•2017

  Incluir item

• Economic threat, new nationalism and xenophobia in South Africa

  Darlington Mutanda•African Security Review•2022

  Incluir item

• Xenophobic Violence and Struggle Discourse in South Africa

  Open Access•Philippa Kerr, K Durrheim et al.•Journal of Asian and African…•2019

  Incluir item

• Becoming and unbecoming farm workers in Southern Africa

  Maxim Bolt•Anthropology Southern Africa•2017

  Incluir item

• Farm worker identities contested and reimagined

  Åsa Eriksson•Anthropology Southern Africa•2017

  Incluir item

• Everyday Politics and Collective Mobilization Against Foreigners in a South African Shack Settlement

  Open Access•Tamlyn Monson•Africa•2015

  Incluir item