Nature’s Impartiality, Man’s Inhumanity

This paper compares the terrorist outrages of 11 September 2001 in New York City and Washington to the Lisbon earthquake of 1 November 1755. Both events occurred, literally out of the blue, at critical junctures in history and both struck at the heart of large trading networks. Both affected public attitudes towards disaster as, not only did they cause unparalleled destruction, but they also represented symbolic victories of chaos over order, and of moral catastrophism over a benign view of human endeavour. The Lisbon earthquake led to a protracted debate on teleology, which has some parallels in the debate on technological values in modern society. It remains to be seen whether there will be parallels in the reconstruction and the ways in which major disasters are rationalised in the long term. But despite the differences between these two events — which are obviously very large as nearly 250 years of history separate them and they were the work of different sorts of forces — there are lessons to be learned from the comparison. One of these is that disaster can contribute to a perilous form of self‐absorption and cultural isolation

Archaeology · Context (archaeology · Criminology · Environmental ethics · Impartiality · Parallels · Poison control · Political science · Sociology · Teleology · Terrorism · Engineering · History · Law · Philosophy · Terrorism, Counterterrorism, and Political Violence

• The portrayal of disaster in Western fine art

  David Alexander•Environmental Hazards•2016

  Incluir item

• The Terrible Geographicalness of Terrorism

  Open Access•Daanish Mustafa•Antipode•2005

  Incluir item

• Preparedness for Emergency Response

  Open Access•Ronald W Perry, Michael K Lindell•Disasters•2003

  Incluir item

• The normalisation of terror

  Open Access•Kobi Peleg, James L Regens et al.•Disasters•2010

  Incluir item

• An Exploratory Comparison of Disasters, Riots and Terrorist Acts

  Open Access•Lori Peek, Lori A Peek et al.•Disasters•2003

  Incluir item