The Time-Break Structure of Moby-Dick

Is it possible, at this late date, that the most obvious structural feature in Moby- Dick remains to be explored? Indeed it is, and, as will appear, not only is that structural feature the most obvious, it is also the most illuminating. So far, Moby- Dick has been divided into three, four, five or six parts. The movement, or cresting, of external, or "dramatic," action provides the main basis for the three- to five-part structures. In The Trying-Out of "Moby-Dick" (1949), Howard P. Vincent works with a simple three-part structure: "The Narrative Beginnings" (Chapters 1 ["Loomings"] to 31 ["Queen Nab"]), "The Cetological Center" (Chapters 32 ["Cetology"] to 105 ["Does the Whale's Magnitude Diminish?"]), and "The Narrative Conclusion" (Chapter 106 ["Ahab's Leg"] to the "Epi- logue"). Eight years later, Newton Arvin distinguishes four wave movements: Chapters 1 to 22 ("Merry Christmas"), 23 ("The Lee Shore") to 36 ("The Quarter-deck"), 37 ("Sunset") to 131 ("The Pequod Meets the Delight"), and 132 ("The Symphony") to the "Epilogue"—the long third wave containing six minor crests (Arvin 156-158). Most popular, however is the division into five parts, or perhaps five acts, since the cue for this tack (as ultimately for the three- part Aristotelian beginning, middle and end structure) is provided by the percep- tion of Ahab as a tragic hero, the evidence of Shakespeare's influence, and the dramatic mode of presentation in at least thirteen of the book's chapters.1 Thus, two years before Vincent's book, Charles Olson proposed the following five-act breakdown: chapters 1 to 22, 24 ("The Advocate") to 71 ("The Jeroboam's Story"), 72 ("The Monkey-Rope") to 100 ("Leg and Arm"), 101 ("The Decanter") to 119 ("The Candles"), and 120 ("The Deck") to the "Epilogue." Chapter 23 and chapters 41 and 42 ("Moby Dick" and "The Whiteness of the Whale") are viewed as interludes (66-67). Subsequently, James Miller and Bainard Cowan have agreed on the number five but differed (with Olson and between themselves) as to where at least four of the breaks occur.2

Adventure · Art · Art history · HERO · Literature · Narrative · Narrative structure · Queen (butterfly · History · Literary Theory and Cultural Hermeneutics · Narrative Theory and Analysis · Philosophy · Shakespeare, Adaptation, and Literary Criticism

• The Power of Blackness

  Roy R Male, Harry Levin•Books Abroad•1958

  Incluir item

• The Wake of The Gods

  Walter Dubler, H Bruce Franklin•The New England Quarterly•1963

  Incluir item

• Melville's Reading

  Roger E Stoddard, Merton M Sealts•The New England Quarterly•1967

  Incluir item

• Theodicies in Conflict

  Lawrence Buell, RICHARD FORRER•Journal of American History•1987

  Incluir item

• Exiled Waters

  Martin Bickman, Bainard Cowan•American Literature•1985

  Incluir item

• Careful Disorder

  Herbert G Eldridge•American Literature•1967

  Incluir item

• The Composition of Moby-Dick

  James Barbour•American Literature•1975

  Incluir item

• The Rationale of Deception in Poe

  J Albert Robbins, Jerome Robbins et al.•American Literature•1981

  Incluir item

• The Eccentric Design

  Benjamin T Spencer, Marius Bewley•American Literature•1960

  Incluir item

• The Pattern of the Iliad

  Samuel E Bassett, J T Sheppard•The Classical Weekly•1923

  Incluir item

• The Price of Narrative Fiction

  John Miles Foley•Thought•1984

  Incluir item

• The Two Moby-Dicks

  George R Stewart•American Literature•1954

  Incluir item