Consumer Responses to Health Plan Report Cards in Two Markets

BACKGROUND: Health plans can compete on quality when consumers have helpful information. Report cards strive to meet this need, but consumer responses have not been measured. OBJECTIVES: The objectives of this study were (1) to compare consumer responses to report cards in 2 markets, (2) to determine how personal characteristics relate to exposure, and (3) to assess the perceived helpfulness of the report cards. RESEARCH DESIGN: A postenrollment survey was used. SUBJECTS: The study included 784 employees of Monsanto (St Louis, 1996) and 670 employees of a health care purchasing cooperative (Denver, 1997). DEPENDENT MEASURES: The dependent measures were (1) exposure, specifically remembering the report card, and intensity of reading it and (2) perceived helpfulness in learning about plan quality and in deciding to stay or switch. RESULTS: Except for remembering seeing the report card (Denver, 47%; St Louis, 55%), the 2 groups did not differ. Forty percent read most or all of the report card; 82% found the report helpful in learning about quality; and 66% found it helpful in deciding to stay or switch. Employees who used patient survey information in their plan decision were more likely to remember seeing the report card (odds ratio [OR], 4.85), to read it intensely (OR, 2.84), and to find it helpful in learning about plan quality (OR, 3.04) and deciding whether to stay or switch plans (OR, 2.64). CONCLUSIONS: Although the 2 samples differed markedly, their responses to report cards were similar. Exposure and helpfulness were related more to employee preferences for the type of information than to their health care decision needs

Business · Economic growth · Economics · Geography · Health care · Health plan · MEDLINE · Plan (archaeology) · Political science · Healthcare Policy and Management · Marketing · Patient Satisfaction in Healthcare · Patient-Provider Communication in Healthcare

• Using Performance Measurement to Drive Improvement

  Robert Galvin, Robert S Galvin et al.•Medical Care•2003

  Incluir item

• Similarities and Differences in Choosing Health Plans

  Pamela Farley Short, Lacey Mccormack et al.•Medical Care•2002

  Incluir item

• The History and Principles of Managed Competition

  Alain C Enthoven•Health Affairs•1993

  Incluir item

• Consumerism in Health Care Prevalence and Predictors

  Judith H Hibbard, Edward C Weeks•Medical Care•1987

  Incluir item

• Epilogue

  Kristin L Carman, Pamela Farley Short et al.•Medical Care•1999

  Incluir item

• The Quest for Accountability

  Open Access•I David Welch•Journal of Teacher Education•1974

  Incluir item