Regression Toward the Mean in Medical Care Costs

As more Americans choose among insurance plans, the possibility of biased selection increases in importance. Although regression toward the mean is recognized as a common problem in evaluating social programs, it has generally been ignored in studies of biased selection. Suppose that people are included in a group simply because they had expenditures in one year $100 below the mean; that is, health status or other risk factors are not part of the selection criteria. Empirically, the expected difference in the following year is about $20 and appears to fall in each subsequent year. This pattern holds for the elderly and nonelderly. Evidence of lower pre-enrollment expenditure of prepaid group practice (PGP) enrollees can be interpreted in several ways. Under one interpretation, PGP enrollees are assumed to be a random sample conditional on pre-enrollment expenditure, such that biased selection is one fifth of estimates based on 1 year of data and one half of estimates based on 4 years of data. This article cannot resolve the issue of alternative interpretations; it only raises it

Actuarial science · Econometrics · Economics · Health care · Health insurance · Interpretation (philosophy) · Medical Expenditure Panel Survey · Regression · Regression analysis · Regression toward the mean · Sample (material) · Selection (genetic algorithm) · Selection bias · Sociology · Statistics · Computer Science · Demography · Health Systems, Economic Evaluations, Quality of Life · Healthcare Policy and Management · Mathematics · Medicine · Primary Care and Health Outcomes · Psychology

• Selection Bias in Tefra At-Risk HMOs

  Richard Lichtenstein, J W Thomas et al.•Medical Care•1991

  Incluir item

• Persistence in Health Expenditures in the Short Run

  Alan C Monheit•Medical Care•2003

  Incluir item

• Medicare Managed Care Enrollment by Disability-Eligible and Age-Eligible Veterans

  Matthew L Maciejewski, Sarah Birken et al.•Medical Care•2009

  Incluir item

• Towards a capitation formula for competing health insurers. An empirical analysis

  Open Access•Renéc J A Van Vliet, Wynand P M M Van De Ven•Social Science & Medicine•1992

  Incluir item

• The Growth of HMOs

  David Mechanic, Norma Weiss et al.•Medical Care•1983

  Incluir item

• An Analysis of the Use of Medicare Services by the Continuously Enrolled Aged

  Nelda McCall, Hoi S Wai•Medical Care•1983

  Incluir item

• The Manitoba Longitudinal Study on Aging

  Noralou P Roos, Evelyn Shapiro•Medical Care•1981

  Incluir item