The Effect of the Diffusion of the Surgical Robot on the Hospital-level Utilization of Partial Nephrectomy

INTRODUCTION: The rapid diffusion of the surgical robot has been controversial because of the technology's high costs and its disputed marginal benefit. Some, however, have suggested that adoption of the robot may have improved care for patients with renal malignancy by facilitating partial nephrectomy, an underutilized, technically challenging procedure believed to be less morbid than radical nephrectomy. We sought to determine whether institutional acquisition of the robot was associated with increased utilization of partial nephrectomy. METHODS: We used all payer data from 7 states to identify 21,569 nephrectomies. These patient-level records were aggregated to the hospital-level then merged with the American Hospital Association Annual Survey and publicly available data on timing of robot acquisition. We used a multivariable difference-in-difference model to assess at the hospital-level whether robot acquisition was associated with an increase in the proportion of partial nephrectomy, adjusting for hospital nephrectomy volume, year of surgery, and several additional hospital-level factors. RESULTS: In the multivariable-adjusted differences-in-differences model, hospitals acquiring a robot between 2001 and 2004 performed a greater proportion of partial nephrectomy in both 2005 (29.9% increase) and 2008 (34.9% increase). Hospitals acquiring a robot between 2005 and 2008 also demonstrated a greater proportion of partial nephrectomy in 2008 (15.5% increase). In addition, hospital nephrectomy volume and urban location were also significantly associated with increased proportion of partial nephrectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Hospital acquisition of the surgical robot is associated with greater proportion of partial nephrectomy, an underutilized, guideline-encouraged procedure. This is one of the few studies to suggest robot acquisition is associated with improvement in quality of patient care

Kidney · Nephrectomy · Robot · Surgical robot · Computer Science · Internal Medicine · Medicine · Renal cell carcinoma treatment · Soft Robotics and Applications · Surgery · Surgical Simulation and Training

• Simpson's paradox in psychological science

  Open Access•Rogier Kievit, Willem E Frankenhuis et al.•Frontiers in Psychology•2013

  Incluir item

• Comorbidity Measures for Use with Administrative Data

  Anne Elixhauser, Claudia Steiner et al.•Medical Care•1998

  Incluir item

• Quality, Cost, and Health

  Avedis Donabedian, John R C Wheeler et al.•Medical Care•1982

  Incluir item

• Hospital Adoption of Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy

  A MARK FENDRICK, José J Escarce et al.•Medical Care•1994

  Incluir item