A Puzzling 14 C Result Obtained for a Carbonized Wood Sample Embedded in Volcanic Lava

It has been reported that the characteristics of a very old wood charcoal sample are different from those of modern wood charcoal according to its state of preservation (Cohen-Ofri et al. 2006; Rebollo et al. 2008). It can be assumed that these differences may lead to some difficulties when radiocarbon dating very old wood charcoal samples. To investigate this problem, we studied a carbonized trunk of Prunus pendula for. acendens tree buried in lava and found at the Hantan River lava plateau on the Korean Peninsula. The 14 C date of this sample was previously measured as >30,000 BP. However, separate 14 C results of its outer crust and inner wood showed a considerable difference, exceeding the estimated age differences by tree-ring counting. To study the reason for this discrepancy, optical microscopy and FTIR (Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy) were performed to examine the differences in the structural and chemical states of the samples. For reference data and to expand our understanding of very old wood charcoal, we applied the same analysis tools (AMS, FTIR, FE-SEM, EDS, and optical microscopy) to a variety of wood charcoals and original wood. From these analyses, we noticed considerable chemical changes in the outer crust sample, and this might explain the age discrepancy. Although it seems that the age difference might be due to the digestion of 14 C-free CO 2 from a volcanic environment, this explanation would not account for such a large value in the age difference

Charcoal · Crust · Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy · Geochemistry · Lava · Metallurgy · Mineralogy · Physics · Radiocarbon dating · Volcano · Archaeology and ancient environmental studies · Chemistry · Cultural Heritage Materials Analysis · Materials Science · Pacific and Southeast Asian Studies · Geology · Paleontology

• Preservation of fungi in archaeological charcoal

  Open Access•Magdalena Moskal-Del Hoyo, Melvin J Wachowiak et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2010

  Incluir item

• Modern and fossil charcoal

  Open Access•Ilit Cohen‐Ofri, Ilit Cohen-Ofri et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2005

  Incluir item

• Preservation potential of charcoal in alkaline environments

  Open Access•Freek Braadbaart, Imogen Poole et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2009

  Incluir item

• C Activity in Different Sections and Chemical Fractions of Oak Tree Rings, AD 1938–1981

  Open Access•Ingrid U Olsson, Goran Possnert•Radiocarbon•1992

  Incluir item

• A Possible Source of Error in 14 C Dates

  Open Access•Francis Saupé, Osvaldo Strappa et al.•Radiocarbon•1980

  Incluir item

• Structural Characterization of Charcoal Exposed to High and Low Ph

  Open Access•N R Rebollo, I Cohen-Ofri et al.•Radiocarbon•2008

  Incluir item

• Discussion Reporting of 14 C Data

  Open Access•Minze Stuiver, Henry A Polach•Radiocarbon•1977

  Incluir item

• Regional Sources of Volcanic Carbon Dioxide and Their Influence on 14 C Content of Present-Day Plant Material

  Open Access•Michael Bruns, Ingeborg Levin et al.•Radiocarbon•1980

  Incluir item