Pular para o conteúdo principal

ETHNOS_APP

Início • Busca • Periódicos • Lista 0

Reconsidering the Compatibility Thesis and Eclecticism

Five Proposed Guidelines for Method Use

Dados Bibliográficos

ID9732136
AutoresStephen C Yanchar (0000-0002-2739-5386, Brigham Young University, Department of Instructional Psychology and Technology, Provo, UT 84602; . His areas of specialization are theoretical and philosophical issues in education and psychology, particularly those pertaining to critical thinking, research methods and practices, and leaning and cognition, autor correspondente), David D Williams (0000-0001-8980-6446, Brigham Young University, Department of Instructional Psychology and Technology, Provo, UT 84602; . His areas of specialization are qualitative research methods and international education and evaluation)
Ano2006
Volume35
Fascículo9
Páginas3-12
Data de publicação2006-12-01
Peer ReviewedSim
Open AccessSim
TipoARTICLE
PeriódicoEducational Researcher (JOURNAL)
Identificadores do periódicoISSN: 0013-189X • E-ISSN: 1935-102X
EditoraAmerican Educational Research Association (AERA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.3102/0013189x035009003
OpenAlexW2011059370
IdiomaEN
Citações recebidas27
Referências citadas53

This essay examines calls for methodological eclecticism based on the “compatibility thesis,” arguing that they fail to take seriously the assumptions of method and, in so doing, fail to provide a methodological perspective that adequately incorporates the centrally important task of critically examining the theoretical background of methods and conceptual frameworks for research. The authors offer an alternative view of method use and a set of guidelines that emphasize the importance of contextual sensitivity, creativity, conceptual awareness, coherence, and critical reflection in research and evaluation practices

Creativity · Critical reflection · Eclecticism · Educational research · Engineering ethics · Epistemology · Management science · Mathematics education · Pedagogy · Research methodology · Sociology · Computer Science · Educational Assessment and Improvement · Engineering · Evaluation and Performance Assessment · Health Policy Implementation Science · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • From controlled experiments to formative interventions in studies of agency

    Open Access•Anne Laitinen, Annalisa Sannino et al.•Educação•2016

  • An overview of mixed methods research

    Open Access•Louise Doyle, Anne-Marie Brady et al.•Journal of Research in Nursing•2009

  • Race Has Always Mattered

    Open Access•Denise Yull, Denise G Yull•Education Research International•2014

  • From the abstract to the concrete and beyond

    Open Access•Liubov Vetoshkina, Sami Paavola•Outlines Critical Practice Studies•2021

  • Critical Consciousness in High School Outdoor Experiential Environmental Education

    Open Access•Spirit Brooks, Steven M Braun et al.•Journal of Experiential Education•2022

  • Career-related learning in primary schools

    Deirdre Hughes, Ifza Shakoor et al.•British Journal of Guidance and…•2022

  • Using numerical data in explicitly interpretive, contextual inquiry

    Open Access•Stephen C Yanchar•Theory & Psychology•2011

  • Paranormal Experience in a Medico-Swimming Rescue

    Open Access•Stathis Avramidis•Journal of Religion and Health•2013

  • Educators’ experiences as K-12 students and efficacy for teaching in diverse schools

    Open Access•Joshua Desantis, Cherish Christopher•Journal for Multicultural Education•2021

  • A problematic legacy

    Open Access•Catherine Compton‐lilly, Shuning Liu et al.•Journal for Multicultural Education•2019

  • Articulating choice and deliberation in conducting research – researchers ‘working in the interpretive zone’

    Harm Tillema, Lily Orland Barak et al.•Ethnography & Education•2008

  • Navigating Paradigms in Educational Technology

    Open Access•Royce Kimmons, Kevin Johnstun•TechTrends•2019

  • Axiology and Anomaly in the Practice of Mixed Methods Work

    Open Access•Catharine Biddle, K A Schafft•Journal of Mixed Methods Research•2014

  • Bourdieu’s Reflexive Sociology as a Theoretical Basis for Mixed Methods Research

    Open Access•Christopher J Fries•Journal of Mixed Methods Research•2009

  • The Realist Survey

    Open Access•Judith Schoonenboom•Journal of Mixed Methods Research•2015

  • Teaching as the emergent event of an ecological process

    Open Access•Lyana Virginia Thediga De Miranda, Magda Pischetola•Explorations in Media Ecology•2020

  • From Common Struggles to Common Dreams

    Pei‐Lun Lee, Pei-Lun Lee•Multicultural Perspectives•2012

  • Theorizing inquiry in the moral space of practice

    Stephen C Yanchar, Brent D Slife•Qualitative Research in Psychology•2016

  • Mixed methods, materialism and the micropolitics of the research-assemblage

    Open Access•N J Fox, P Alldred•International Journal of Social…•2017

  • Look to the bottom’

    Laura Azzarito•Sport Education and Society•2019

  • On the pitfalls and promises of using mixed methods in literacy research

    Ian A G Wilkinson, Bea Staley•Research Papers in Education•2019

  • How to Construct a Mixed Methods Research Design

    Open Access•Judith Schoonenboom, R Burke Johnson•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2017

  • (E)pistemological Awareness, Instantiation of Methods, and Uninformed Methodological Ambiguity in Qualitative Research Projects

    Open Access•M Koro, Mirka Koro-Ljungberg et al.•Educational Researcher•2009

  • Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Methodologies in Research on Teachers’ Lives, Work, and Effectiveness

    Open Access•Clive Day, Christopher Day et al.•Educational Researcher•2008

  • Common "Core" Characteristics of Mixed Methods Research

    Open Access•Charles Teddlie, Abbas Tashakkori•American Behavioral Scientist•2012

  • Mixed Methods Research

    Open Access•Sharlene Hesse-Biber, Sharlene Hesse‐biber•Qualitative Health Research•2015

  • Isolating Science from the Humanities

    Open Access•Kenneth R Howe•Qualitative Inquiry•2009

  • Constructing the Subject

    Open Access•Kurt Danziger•Constructing the Subject•1990

  • Beyond Objectivism and Relativism

    Richard J Bernstein•Beyond Objectivism and Relativism•1984

  • Sage Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social & Behavioral Research

    Abbas Tashakkori, Charles Teddlie•Sage Handbook Of Mixed Methods In…•2010

  • What's Behind the Research? Discovering Hidden Assumptions in the Behavioral Sciences

    Brent D Slife, Brent Slife et al.•What's Behind the Research?…•1995

  • On Critical Reflection

    Open Access•Jack Mezirow•Adult Education Quarterly•1998

  • Meaning in Context

    Elliot G Mishler, Elliot Mishler•Harvard Educational Review•1979

  • Toward a Conceptual Framework for Mixed-Method Evaluation Designs

    Open Access•Jennifer C Greene, Valerie J Caracelli et al.•Educational Evaluation and Policy…•1989

  • Qualitative and quantitative methods in evaluation research

    Charles S Reichardt, Thomas D Cook•Qualitative and quantitative…•1979

  • Philosophy and the Human Sciences

    Charles Taylor•Philosophical Papers•1985

  • Of Immortal Mythological Beasts

    Open Access•Christopher D Green•Theory & Psychology•1992

  • Identification of Underlying Assumptions is an Integral Part of Research

    Open Access•Robin Burgess-Limerick, Robin Burgess‐Limerick et al.•Theory & Psychology•1994

  • On the Nature of a Critical Methodology

    Open Access•Stephen C Yanchar, Edwin E Gantt et al.•Theory & Psychology•2005

  • Postmodernism and the human sciences

    P Lather•The Humanistic Psychologist•1990

  • Toward a theoretical psychology

    Brent D Slife, Richard N Williams•American Psychologist•1997

  • Methodology for the Human Sciences

    Open Access•John R Mergendollar•Phenomenology + Pedagogy•1984

  • With a Splash of Soda, Please

    Open Access•Jennifer C Greene•Evaluation•2002

  • The Merits of Mixing Methods in Evaluation

    Open Access•Jennifer C Greene, Lehn M Benjamin et al.•Evaluation•2001

  • Post-structuralism and policy research in education

    Walter Humes, Tom Bryce et al.•Journal of Education Policy•2003

  • Mixed Methodology

    Shelia R Cotten, Abbas Tashakkori et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1999

  • Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought

    Thomas F Gieryn, Gerald Holton•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1976

  • Notes on the Methodology of Scientific Research

    Jerry B Michel, Walter B Weimer•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1980

  • Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought

    Thomas F Gieryn, Gerald Holton•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1976

  • Developing Critical Thinkers

    W Lee Humphreys, Stephen Brookfield et al.•Teaching Sociology•1989

  • The Methodological Imperative in Psychology

    Open Access•Kurt Danziger•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•1985

  • Beyond Objectivism and Relativism

    Charles Larmore, Richard J Bernstein•The Philosophical Review•1985

  • Deciphering Attempts to Decipher Postmodern Educational Research

    Open Access•Wanda S Pillow•Educational Researcher•2000

  • Research News And Comment

    Open Access•Mark A Constas•Educational Researcher•1998

  • Drawing Valid Meaning from Qualitative Data

    Open Access•Matthew B Miles, A Michael Huberman•Educational Researcher•1984

  • Meaning in Method

    William A Firestone•Educational Researcher•1987

  • Closing Down the Conversation

    John K Smith, Lous Heshusius•Educational Researcher•1986

  • Against the Quantitative-Qualitative Incompatibility Thesis or Dogmas Die Hard

    Kenneth R Howe•Educational Researcher•1988

  • The Call for Intelligibility in Postmodern Educational Research

    Open Access•E A St Pierre•Educational Researcher•2000

  • What Good are Statistics that Don’t Generalize

    Open Access•David Williamson Shaffer, Ronald C Serlin•Educational Researcher•2004

  • The Changing Nature of Educational Research and a Critique of Postmodernism

    Mark A Constas•Educational Researcher•1998

  • Evidence on “What Works”

    Open Access•Madhabi Chatterji•Educational Researcher•2004

  • Discovering Successful Pathways in Children's Development

    Open Access•Steven Groarke•British Journal of Sociology•2005

  • Phenomenological research methods for counseling psychology

    Frederick J Wertz•Journal of Counseling Psychology•2005

  • Causal Explanation, Qualitative Research, and Scientific Inquiry in Education

    Open Access•Joseph A Maxwell•Educational Researcher•2004

  • Mixed Methods Research

    Open Access•R Burke Johnson, Anthony J Onwuegbuzie•Educational Researcher•2004

  • Confession, catharsis, or cure? Rethinking the uses of reflexivity as methodological power in qualitative research

    Wanda S Pillow, Wanda Pillow•International Journal of…•2003

  • Research as Praxis

    P Lather•Harvard Educational Review•1986

  • Qualitative research in counseling psychology

    Joseph G Ponterotto•Journal of Counseling Psychology•2005

  • Rethinking the Laboratory Experiment

    Open Access•F M Moghaddam, Rom Harré•American Behavioral Scientist•1992

  • The Discursive Expression of Human Freedom

    Open Access•Malcolm R Westcott•American Behavioral Scientist•1992

Obras citantes distintas27
Citações por ano1,5
Intervalo de citações2008 - 2022 (15)
Velocidade de citaçãohistorical
Altamente citadoNão
Tipos de citaçãoNeutras: 26
Ethnos_APP • Projeto Open Source • Licença MIT • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacidade e Cookies • Documentação da API: api.ethnos.app/docs • Código da API: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Código do Frontend: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae