Physicalism, Teleology and the Miraculous Coincidence Problem

I focus on Fodor’s model of the relationship between special sciences and basic physics, and on a criticism of this model, that it implies that the causal stability of, e.g., the mental in its production of behaviour is nothing short of a miraculous coincidence. David Papineau and Graham Macdonaldendorse this criticism. But it is far less clear than they assume that Fodor’s picture indeed involves coincidences, which in any case their injection of a teleological supplement cannot explain. Papineau’s and Macdonald’s problem is subtly different from a similar one presented by Adrian Cussins. This is no more effective against Fodor’s picture, but the kind of account of the relation between the physical and the psychological which could constitute a solution to Cussins’ problem is one which, for independent reasons, a physicalist of Fodor’s stripe ought to provide

Coincidence · Epistemology · Metaphysics · Physicalism · Teleology · Medicine · Philosophy · Philosophy and History of Science · Philosophy and Theoretical Science · Quantum Mechanics and Applications

• Rationality and Human Fulfilment Clarified by a Thomistic Metaphysics of Participation

  Open Access•Andy Mullins•Scientia et Fides•2022

  Incluir item

• There is No Question of Physicalism

  Tim Crane, D H Mellor•Mind•1990

  Incluir item

• Matter and Consciousness

  Kathleen Gill, Philosophy Documentation Center•Teaching Philosophy•1987

  Incluir item