The Reviewer Replies

THE REVIEWER REPLIES EDUARD FARBER As Goran tells it, the personal story on page 98 is incorrect compared with the account that Richard Willstatter gives in his autobiography, page 253. To cite and refute the wrong statements Goran makes about chemical equilibrium would far exceed the space allotted to a brief review; a reviewer who expands on explaining and citing widely known textbook material may perhaps avoid being denounced as haughty but risks being called condescending. The quotation from Paul Karrer’s book does nothing to support Goran in writing that Hofmann “initiated the coal-tar industry”; the industrial coal-tar operation that Ernst Sell had “initiated”—one of sev­ eral—produced the material which Hofmann analyzed. Here as else­ where, Goran simplifies and condenses in an effort to write for a wide readership and ends in presenting an untrue picture. Goran seems un­ aware of this process when he distorts Karrer’s remark into stating that methane is “inert”—and just when he deals with Haber’s efforts to indicate the presence of explosive mixtures containing methane. I did not indicate typographical errors, of which there are several; I mentioned two examples of words wrongly spelled in text and index. With an interest in accuracy, the author would have searched for other examples; he would have been rewarded by finding, for instance, that “Siemanns” on page 159 should be Siemens. Goran has to “take full responsibility” for all these shortcomings, which include his personifying the Zeitgeist to write about a “nine­ teenth-century-induced desire,” or equating Jews with royalty in Ger­ many on page 130; to help him understand and correct these short­ comings was one of the aims I hoped to reach with my review. REJOINDER AND REFUTATION In response to Dr. Farber’s reply, Professor Goran has written as fol­ lows: “As an example of your reviewer’s accuracy I cite my remark on page 130 of my book, ‘His innermost feelings should have been similar Dr. Farber, of Washington, D.C., contributed biographies to Bugge’s Buch der grossen Chemiker and edited Great Chemists. 183

Epistemology · Göran · Humanities · Nothing · Biomedical Text Mining and Ontologies · History and advancements in chemistry · Philosophy · Semantic Web and Ontologies