Randomisation by cluster and the problem of social class bias

For randomised population trials the unit of randomisation is normally the individual person. In some situations, however, investigators take other groups as basic unit and one such design is cluster randomisation. Considerable attention has been given to this design recently in statistical and epidemiological literature. The Edinburgh randomised trial of breast cancer screening is an example which takes general practices as clusters of patients. The experience of this trial is reported here. Mortality from all causes, cardiovascular disease and lung cancer over the first 5 year period of follow up are examined. We found that spurious mortality differences were present in the analyses, which do not allow for socio-economic status. From examination of methods of adjusting for this, we conclude that allowance can be made at the analysis stage, and it is intended that this approach will be adopted when breast cancer mortality is analysed in the Edinburgh trial. Nevertheless, we recommend that for future studies with outcome related to socio-economic status, randomisations which use this design be stratified by socio-economic criteria where this is feasible

Allowance (engineering) · Breast cancer · Cancer · Cluster (spacecraft) · Cluster randomised controlled trial · Disease · Environmental health · Pathology · Population · Randomized controlled trial · Social class · Socioeconomic status · Spurious relationship · Statistics · Demography · Epidemiology · Health Systems, Economic Evaluations, Quality of Life · Medicine · Statistical Methods and Bayesian Inference · Statistical Methods in Clinical Trials · Surgery · Gerontology

• Reduction in Mortality From Breast Cancer After Mass Screening With Mammography

  Open Access•Làszló Tabár, A Gad et al.•The Lancet•1985

  Add to list

• Mortality Decline and Widening Social Inequalities

  Open Access•Michael Marmot, M G Marmot et al.•The Lancet•1986

  Add to list

• The Conclusion of a Ten-Year Study of Water Fluoridation

  David B Ast, Edward R Schlesinger•American Journal of Public Health…•1956

  Add to list