Indian and Pakistani views on nuclear deterrence

While officials in India and Pakistan have been virtually silent on the issue of nuclear deterrence in South Asia, a small number of nonofficial strategists in both countries are moving to fill the void. They describe the current low‐level nuclear standoff as “recessed deterrence.” Nuclear weapons advocates within this group have voiced their dissatisfaction with the status quo, ostensibly because nuclear ambiguity undermines stability. This has led them to promote the concept of “minimum deterrence,” described essentially as a scaled‐down version of the superpower assured destruction doctrine. Generally, strategists that favor nuclear deployment have high confidence that India and Pakistan would be responsible nuclear powers. They also contend that just as nuclear deterrence stabilized U.S.‐Soviet relations, so too can it work for South Asia. Other analysts are more skeptical, both of the premise behind minimum deterrence and the observance of nuclear restraint in the subcontinent. They likewise question the applicability of the superpower model of deterrence for India and Pakistan

China · Deterrence theory · Doctrine · Economics · International trade · Law and economics · Nuclear ethics · Nuclear weapon · Political economy · Political science · Premise · Superpower · Global Peace and Security Dynamics · International Relations and Foreign Policy · Law · Nuclear Issues and Defense · Philosophy

• Command and control challenges in South Asia

  Clayton P Bowen, Daniel Wolvén•The Nonproliferation Review•1999

  Add to list

• Pakistani Nuclear Doctrine and The Dangers of Strategic Myopia

  Timothy D Hoyt•Asian Survey•2001

  Add to list

• Nuclear weapons in South Asia

  John Arquilla•Comparative Strategy•1997

  Add to list

• Nuclear Weapons and Indian Strategic Culture

  Open Access•Rajesh M Basrur, Rajesh Basrur•Journal of Peace Research•2001

  Add to list

• Old quarrels and new realities

  Rodney W Jones•The Washington Quarterly•1992

  Add to list

• A Nuclear Third Way in South Asia

  George Perkovich•Foreign Policy•1993

  Add to list