Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

After Unipolarity

China's Visions of International Order in an Era of U.S. Decline

Bibliographic Data

ID11261835
AuthorsRandall L Schweller (Randall L. Schweller is Professor of Political Science and Director of the Mershon Center's Series on National Security Studies at Ohio State University.), Xiaoyu Pu (0000-0001-5059-3324, Xiaoyu Pu is a doctoral candidate in the Department of Political Science at Ohio State University.)
Year2011
Volume36
Issue1
Pages41-72
Publication date2011-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Security (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0162-2889 • E-ISSN: 1531-4804
PublisherMIT Press - Journals (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1162/isec_a_00044
OpenAlexW2091345718
LanguageEN
Citations received229
References cited63

The emerging transition from unipolarity to a more multipolar distribution of global power presents a unique and unappreciated problem that largely explains why, contrary to the expectations of balance of power theory, a counterbalancing reaction to U.S. primacy has not yet taken place. The problem is that, under unipolarity and only unipolarity, balancing is a revisionist, not a status quo, behavior: its purpose is to replace the existing unbalanced unipolar structure with a balance of power system. Thus, any state that seeks to restore a global balance of power will be labeled a revisionist aggressor. To overcome this ideational hurdle to balancing behavior, a rising power must delegitimize the unipole's global authority and order through discursive and cost-imposing practices of resistance that pave the way for the next phase of full-fledged balancing and global contestation. The type of international order that emerges on the other side of the transition out of unipolarity depends on whether the emerging powers assume the role of supporters, spoilers, or shirkers. As the most viable peer competitor to U.S. power, China will play an especially important role in determining the future shape of international politics. At this relatively early stage in its development, however, China does not yet have a fixed blueprint for a new world order. Instead, competing Chinese visions of order map on to various delegitimation strategies and scenarios about how the transition from unipolarity to a restored global balance of power will develop

Balance (ability · Blueprint · China · Economic system · Economics · Order (exchange · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Power (physics · Sociology · Status quo · Transition (genetics · Vision · Engineering · Global Peace and Security Dynamics · International Development and Aid · International Relations and Foreign Policy · Law · Psychology

  • The Financial Crisis, Contested Legitimacy, and the Genesis of Intra-BRICS Cooperation

    Oliver Stuenkel•Global Governance A Review of…•2013

  • Strategy on the Upward Slope

    Joshua Shifrinson•Oxford Handbook of Grand Strategy•2021

  • China, the un, and Human Protection

    Rosemary Foot•China, the un, and Human Protection•2020

  • Revisiting Regionalism and the Contemporary World Order

    Marko Juutinen, Terry Mcdonald et al.•Revisiting Regionalism and the…•2019

  • China's Strategic Multilateralism

    Chad Rector, Margaret M Pearson et al.•China's Strategic Multilateralism•2018

  • The Rise of the BRICS

    Open Access•Marcus Power•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2015

  • The Distribution of Identity and the Future of International Order

    Bentley B Allan, Bentley Allan et al.•2017

  • East Asia’s Power Shift

    Linus Hagström, Björn Jerdén•Asian perspective•2014

  • Conceiving of Future War

    Open Access•Timothy J Junio, Thomas G Mahnken•International Studies Review•2013

  • Rising Powers in World Politics

    Sandra Destradi•International Relations•2017

  • Domestic Politics, China’s Rise, and the Future of the Liberal International Order

    Open Access•Jessica Chen Wei, Jessica L Wallace et al.•SSRN Electronic Journal•2020

  • International Hierarchy and Functional Differentiation of States

    Open Access•Alexander D Nesmashnyi, Vera Zhornist et al.•MGIMO Review of International…•2022

  • The Challenge of Implementing the Belt and Road Initiative in the Middle East

    Open Access•Yoram Evron•The China Quarterly•2019

  • The Cold War analogy’s misrepresentation of the essence of US–China strategic competition

    Open Access•Jiwu Yin•China International Strategy Review•2020

  • Power in International Relations

    Open Access•Enrico Fels•Shifting Power in Asia-Pacific?•2017

  • Rising Powers

    Open Access•Brian C Schmidt, Nabarun Roy•After Liberalism?•2013

  • Rethinking the Rise of China and Its Implications on International Order

    Open Access•Ciwan M Can, Anson Chan•Chinese Journal of International…•2020

  • Emerging Powers and Status

    Oliver Stuenkel•Asian perspective•2014

  • Theory of Unipolar Politics

    Open Access•Nuno P Monteiro•Theory of unipolar politics•2014

  • Contesting Revisionism

    Steve Chan, Huiyun Feng et al.•Contesting Revisionism•2021

  • Status Signaling, Multiple Audiences, and China’s Blue-Water Naval Ambition

    Open Access•Xiaoyu Pu, Randall L Schweller•Status in World Politics•2014

  • The EU-China partnership

    Open Access•Gustaaf Geeraerts•Asia Europe Journal•2019

  • Strategic Deception of Rising States From China

    Open Access•Changkun Hou•Foreign Policy Analysis•2025

  • The Loud Dissenter and its Cautious Partner' - Russia, China, global governance and humanitarian intervention

    Aglaya Snetkov, Marc Lanteigne•International Relations of the…•2014

  • What Isn't a Norm? Redefining the Conceptual Boundaries of “Norms” in the Human Rights Literature

    Open Access•Michelle Jurkovich•International Studies Review•2019

  • Introducing Organizational (Dis)Entanglements

    Open Access•Stephanie C Hofmann, Yuqian Cai et al.•International Studies Review•2025

  • Forum

    Open Access•Mark A Boyer, Cameron G Thies et al.•International Studies Perspectives•2021

  • Creating Status Loss

    Open Access•Alex Yu-Ting Lin•International Studies Quarterly•2025

  • Seeking support beyond alliance? Rethinking great power partner politics after the Cold War

    Open Access•Ding Lu, Lu Ding et al.•International Relations of the…•2020

  • A Role Theory Approach to Grand Strategy

    Open Access•Cagla Demirduzen, Cameron G Thies•Journal of Global Security Studies•2021

  • Rational Origins of Revisionist War

    Open Access•Richard Jordan•International Studies Review•2022

  • Contested American hegemony and regional order in postwar Asia

    Open Access•Jiyoung Lee, Ji-Young Lee•International Relations of the…•2017

  • Balance of payments and power

    Ian Tsung-Yen Chen•International Relations of the…•2014

  • The prospects of human rights in US–China relations

    Open Access•Hun Joon Kim•International Relations of the…•2018

  • Building Bridges or Breaking Bonds? The Belt and Road Initiative and Foreign Aid Competition

    Open Access•Krishna Chaitanya Vadlamannati, Samuel Brazy et al.•Foreign Policy Analysis•2023

  • Contesting Roles

    Open Access•Courtney J Fung, Shing‐hon Lam•Journal of Global Security Studies•2020

  • The Human Factor

    Open Access•Caterina Carta, Élisa Narminio•International Studies Perspectives•2021

  • Rethinking the IR theory of empire in late imperial China

    John Mackay•International Relations of the…•2014

  • Unfaithful allies? US security clients in China-led international institutions

    Open Access•Dong Jung Kim•International Relations of the…•2018

  • The United States, China, and the Politics of Hegemonic Ordering in East Asia

    Open Access•Beverley Loke•International Studies Review•2021

  • Applying offensive realism to the rise of China

    Xiaoting Li•International Relations of the…•2015

  • Diverging China Strategies in the West

    Open Access•Lunting Wu•Global Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Retracted Article

    Open Access•Bora Ly, Richard Meissner•Cogent Social Sciences•2020

  • Neither a New Cold War nor a New Peloponnesian War

    Open Access•Nicholas Ross Smith, Ruairidh J Brown•Vestnik RUDN International…•2021

  • Assessing the Ability of a “Free and Open Indo-Pacific” Strategy

    Open Access•Gaurav Raja Dahal•Journal of South Asian Studies•2023

  • The Grand Strategy of China Towards Central Asia

    Open Access•Ali Hashim, Hashim Ali et al.•Journal of South Asian Studies•2021

  • Nepal’s Strategic Hedging Behaviour

    Open Access•Gaurav Raja Dahal•Journal of South Asian Studies•2021

  • Transitions in Global Polarity and the United States of America’s Strategy Toward South Asia

    Open Access•Ahmed Ijaz Malik, Muhammad Nadeem Mirza et al.•Humanities & Social Sciences…•2020

  • China’s Balancing Behaviour Against the United States and the Special Importance of Myanmar

    Open Access•Md Abdul Mannan•Journal of Asian Security and…•2020

  • India, Japan and the Indo-Pacific

    Open Access•Jojin V John•Journal of Asian Security and…•2024

  • Continuity in Indonesia’s Strategy in the South China Sea Under Joko Widodo

    Open Access•Prabhat Patnaik, Angguntari Sari•Journal of Asian Security and…•2021

  • The Adjustment of International Institutions to Global Power Shifts

    Open Access•Andreas Kruck, Bernhard Zangl•Global Policy•2020

  • The United States–China ‘tech war’

    Open Access•Maria Ryan, Stephen Burman•Global Policy•2024

  • Colombia's role in great power competition

    Open Access•Kristen Jones•Global Policy•2024

  • The Legitimacy of International Institutions among Rising and Established Powers

    Open Access•Jonas Tallberg, Soetkin Verhaegen•Global Policy•2020

  • ‘Most Potent and Irresistible Moral Influence’

    Open Access•Paul K Macdonald•Global Policy•2020

  • How Do States Renegotiate International Institutions? Japan’s Renegotiation Diplomacy Since World War II

    Open Access•Phillip Y Lipscy•Global Policy•2020

  • Alternative Order Without Alternative Norms

    Open Access•Yong-Soo Eun•Fudan Journal of the Humanities…•2022

  • Legitimacy Through Diversity

    Open Access•Brice Tseen Fu Lee, Juan Pablo Sims•Fudan Journal of the Humanities…•2025

  • Multipolarity, Alliances and Internal Balancing

    Open Access•Gustavo Fornari Dall’agnol, Graciela De Conti Pagliari•OASIS•2024

  • Alternative World Orders? Russia’s Ukraine War and the Domestic Politics of the BRICS

    Open Access•Stefan A Schirm•The International Spectator•2023

  • Unilateral actions in the development of the law of the sea

    Open Access•Shuo Li•Marine Policy•2023

  • Theoretical domains of exploring energy security as a global challenge in international relations

    Open Access•Gordana Mišev•Socioloski pregled•2020

  • Prospects for Canadian-Russian Engagements beyond Common-Sense Civilizations and Geopolitical Conflict

    Ray Silvius•International Journal of Canadian…•2017

  • Beyond the ‘RtoP’

    Open Access•Charlotte Wagnsson•International Politics Reviews•2015

  • China and the Islamic World

    Robert R Bianchi•China and the Islamic World•2019

  • A gendered analysis of US decline

    Open Access•Clara Eroukhmanoff•International Relations•2025

  • China's Identity Construction in Global Data Governance

    Open Access•Danni Zhang, Xuechen Chen et al.•Journal of Current Chinese Affairs•2026

  • China’s global health governance in Africa before Covid-19

    Open Access•Igor Sevenard, Richard J Cook•Journal of International…•2026

  • Language ideologies and practices of international students in a course in Chinese for Academic Purposes(CAP)

    Open Access•Juan Dong, Yawen Han et al.•Language Problems & Language…•2026

  • Asia’s Lesser Powers Confront US–China Threat to the Regional Order

    T J Pempel•Issues & Studies•2020

  • Is China Spoiling the Rules-Based Liberal International Order? Examining China’s Rising Institutional Power in a Multiplex World Through Competing Theories

    Youcheer Kim•Issues & Studies•2020

  • Finnish–Chinese investment negotiation

    Santa Stopniece•Economic and Political Studies•2018

  • Institutionalised Societal Diplomacy

    Open Access•Xinrui Ni•Chinese Political Science Review•2025

  • Measuring Strategic Hedging Capability of Second-Tier States Under Unipolarity

    Open Access•Gustaaf Geeraerts, Mohammad Salman•Chinese Political Science Review•2016

  • Side Effects of Creating a Major Regional Development Bank

    Open Access•Volha Kryvets•Chinese Political Science Review•2022

  • China’s International Leadership

    Open Access•Xiaoyu Pu•Chinese Political Science Review•2017

  • Telling the China Story Well

    Open Access•Seng In Chan, Weiqing Song•Chinese Political Science Review•2020

  • Strategic Hedging and Changes in Geopolitical Capabilities for Second-Tier States

    Open Access•Nikolas Vander Vennet, Mohammad Salman•Chinese Political Science Review•2018

  • Great Power Divergence

    Open Access•Asad Ullah, Li Xinlei•Chinese Political Science Review•2025

  • Escalated Policy Space Conflict

    Open Access•Qinyi Xu, Chuanjing Guan•Chinese Political Science Review•2020

  • Towards an autonomous European defense? A comparative analysis of French, Polish and German perspectives in the post-Brexit era

    Didem Buhari Gulmez, Seçkin Barış Gülmez•Global Affairs•2020

  • Reconceptualizing Technological Leadership

    Open Access•Yuanyuan Fang, Shenghao Zhang•Politics and Governance•2025

  • Discourse power

    Y Zhai•Territory Politics Governance•2019

  • The Duterte method

    Open Access•Michael Intal Magcamit•Asian Journal of Comparative…•2019

  • Not just ‘convenient’

    Open Access•Michael Cox•Asian Journal of Comparative…•2016

  • Disinformation in international politics

    Open Access•Alexander Lanoszka•European Journal of International…•2019

  • American and Chinese leadership during the global financial crisis

    Open Access•Carla Norrlof, Simon Reich•International Area Studies Review•2015

  • New Regionalism and Norm Creation

    Open Access•Anadi Choudhari•Journal of Strategic Security•2024

  • The BRICS and the Future of R2P

    Oliver Stuenkel•Global Responsibility to Protect•2014

  • China’s Influence in Asia

    Open Access•Jinrui Xi, Christopher Primiano•East Asia•2020

  • Unwitting Agents

    Open Access•Wu Xie•East Asia•2023

  • The Year of Сrises

    Jozef Hrabina•Russia in Global Affairs•2021

  • Could Russia Utilize Cryptocurrencies in Its Foreign Policy Grand Strategizing

    Nicholas Ross Smith•Russia in Global Affairs•2019

  • The Syrian Conflict’s Influence on the Chinese Role in the Middle East

    Hocine Laarid•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2022

  • Backlash against human rights shaming

    Open Access•Jack Snyder•International Theory•2019

  • Trading privileges for support

    Open Access•Andreas Kruck, Bernhard Zangl•International Theory•2019

  • The Taming of The Red Dragon

    Open Access•Xiaoting Li•Foreign Policy Analysis•2012

  • Northeast Asia and the International Criminal Court

    Open Access•Alexander Dukalskis•Journal of East Asian Studies•2017

  • The American securitization of China and Russia

    Thomas Ambrosio, Carson Schram et al.•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2019

  • Nations in conflict

    Nazli Choucri•Nations in conflict•1975

  • Long Cycles in World Politics

    Open Access•George Modelski•Long Cycles in World Politics•1987

  • Parity and War

    Open Access•Jacek Kugler, Douglas Lemke•Parity and War•1996

  • Social States: China in International Institutions, 1980-2000

    Alastair Iain Johnston•Social States•2008

  • Aggression

    Leonard Berkowitz•Aggression•1993

  • Cosmopolitanism

    Anthony Appiah•Cosmopolitanism•2007

  • Deadly imbalances

    Randall L Schweller•Deadly imbalances•1998

  • The Origins of Revisionist and Status-quo States

    Open Access•J Davidson, Jason W Davidson•Origins of Revisionist and…•2006

  • Back to the Future

    John J Mearsheimer•National and International Security•2018

  • Legitimacy, hypocrisy, and the social structure of unipolarity

    Open Access•Martha Finnemore•International Relations Theory…•2011

  • World Out of Balance

    Stephen G Brooks, William C Wohlforth•World Out of Balance•2008

  • Outline of a Theory of Practice

    Open Access•Pierre Bourdieu, Richard Nice•On Violence•2007

  • Why civil resistance works

    Maria J Stephan, Erica Chenoweth•Choice Reviews Online•2012

  • Domination and the Arts of Resistance

    James C Scott•Domination and the Arts of…•2017

  • Langage et pouvoir symbolique

    Pierre Bourdieu, John B Thompson•Langage et pouvoir symbolique•2001

  • Negotiated Orders and Organizational Cultures

    Gary Alan Fine•Annual Review of Sociology•1984

  • Dragon’s underbelly

    Open Access•Yanzhong Huang, Sheng Ding•East Asia•2006

  • International Society as a Process

    Qin Yaqing•The Chinese Journal of…•2010

  • Xun Zi's Thoughts on International Politics and Their Implications

    Y Xuetong•The Chinese Journal of…•2008

  • China in International Society

    Barry Buzan•The Chinese Journal of…•2010

  • China

    Min Tang•African and Asian Studies•2007

  • Power and International Relations

    Open Access•Richard Rosecrance•International Studies Perspectives•2006

  • Why is there no Chinese international relations theory

    Yi Qin•International Relations of the…•2007

  • Chinese Visions of World Order

    Open Access•William A Callahan•International Studies Review•2008

  • Breaking and Making Norms

    Open Access•Ian Hurd•International Politics•2007

  • Toward a Consultative Rule of Law Regime in China

    Wei Pan•Journal of Contemporary China•2003

  • Entropy and the trajectory of world politics

    Randall L Schweller•Cambridge Review of International…•2010

  • Regime types and status quo evaluations

    Douglas Lemke, William Reed et al.•International Interactions•1996

  • Understanding the Geopolitical Implications of the Global Financial Crisis

    Wu Xinbo•The Washington Quarterly•2010

  • Shaping the Choices of a Rising China

    Thomas J Christensen•The Washington Quarterly•2009

  • The remaking of a unipolar world

    Robert Jervis•The Washington Quarterly•2006

  • China Engages Asia

    David Shambaugh•International Security•2005

  • Is China a Status Quo Power

    Alastair Iain Johnston•International Security•2003

  • The Emerging Structure of International Politics

    Kenneth N Waltz•International Security•1993

  • Bad Debts

    Daniel W Drezner, Daniel Drezner•International Security•2009

  • Posing Problems Without Catching Up

    Thomas J Christensen•International Security•2001

  • The Unipolar Illusion Revisited

    Christopher Layne•International Security•2006

  • The Unipolar Illusion

    Christopher Layne•International Security•1993

  • Back to the Future

    John J Mearsheimer•International Security•1990

  • Why Civil Resistance Works

    Maria J Stephan, Erica Chenoweth•International Security•2008

  • Structural Realism after the Cold War

    Kenneth N Waltz•International Security•2000

  • Fostering Stability or Creating a Monster? The Rise of China and U.S. Policy toward East Asia

    Thomas J Christensen•International Security•2006

  • Leading Sectors and World Powers

    Tony Porter, George Modelski et al.•International Journal Canada s…•1996

  • Pivotal States and U.S. Strategy

    Robert S Chase, Emily B Hill et al.•Foreign Affairs•1996

  • Envisioning China?s Political Future

    Open Access•Daniel C Lynch•International Studies Quarterly•2007

  • Soft power

    Joseph S Nye•Soft power•2004

  • Taming American Power

    Stephen M Walt•Taming American Power•2006

  • Socialism

    Zygmunt Bauman•Socialism•1976

  • After victory

    G John Ikenberry•After victory•2001

  • Legitimacy, Hypocrisy, and the Social Structure of Unipolarity

    Open Access•Martha Finnemore•World Politics•2009

  • Where Hobbes Meets Hobson

    Brian M Pollins, Kevin P Murrin•International Studies Quarterly•1999

  • Beneath the Commerce of Nations

    David A Lake•International Studies Quarterly•1984

  • Regime dynamics

    Open Access•Oran R Young, Oran Young•International Organization•1982

  • When Do Power Shifts Lead to War

    Woosang Kim, James D Morrow•American Journal of Political…•1992

  • Rightful Resistance

    Open Access•Kevin J O’brien•World Politics•1996

  • The Real New World Order

    Anne-Marie Slaughter•Foreign Affairs•1997

  • China's Search for Stability with America

    Wang Jisi•Foreign Affairs•2005

  • The Iraq Syndrome

    John Mueller•Foreign Affairs•2005

  • Rethinking Empire from a Chinese Concept 'All-under-Heaven' (Tian-xia)

    Zhao Tingyang, Tingyang Zhao•Social Identities•2006

  • The Long Cycle of Global Politics and the Nation-State

    Open Access•George Modelski•Comparative Studies in Society…•1978

Unique citing works229
Citations per year16,36
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 228

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae