Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Sufficiency

A systematic literature review

Bibliographic Data

ID12185331
AuthorsJessica Jungell-Michelsson (0000-0002-6204-9614, University of Helsinki, corresponding author), Pasi Heikkurinen (0000-0002-2207-0734, University of Helsinki)
Year2022
Volume195
Pages107380-107380
Publication date2022-02-17
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEcological Economics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0921-8009 • E-ISSN: 1873-6106
PublisherElsevier BV (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1016/j.ecolecon.2022.107380
OpenAlexW4213035980
LanguageEN
Citations received89
References cited107

The making of sustainable economies calls for sufficiency in production and consumption. The discussion, however, lacks a shared understanding on what it means to operationalize sufficiency. In this article, we review and analyze the concept of sufficiency with a focus on its linkages to different economic scales (with a focus on micro- and macroeconomics) and economic actors (particularly consumers and producers). Altogether 307 articles were screened, resulting in a final data set of 94 peer-reviewed articles. In addition to the core assumption of ‘enoughness’, we found three premises describing the concept: (1) complementarity of capitals, (2) social metabolism, and (3) altruism. In the reviewed literature, sufficiency is understood as both an end in itself and a means for bringing consumption and production within ecological limits. By conducting the first systematic literature review on sufficiency, the study explicates a more integrated understanding of sufficiency and highlights the need to treat sufficiency across economic scales and actors. In future research, empirical work should be emphasized to grasp the contextual varieties in the operationalization of sufficiency

Economics · Energy, Environment, and Transportation Policies · Environmental Impact and Sustainability

  • Tourism futures reimagined

    Open Access•Kevin Fuchs, Bruce Prideaux et al.•Tourism Recreation Research•2026

  • Sufficiency values through commoning relationality

    Open Access•Ben Robra, Alicia Trepat Pont et al.•Sustainable Futures•2026

  • Negotiating comfort and conservation

    Open Access•Maria Kola-Bezka, Krzysztof Leki•Energy Research & Social Science•2026

  • Transformative und agile Innovationssysteme

    Open Access•Alfons Botthof, Jakob Edler et al.•Transformative und agile…•2023

  • Advancing Theory and Practice Concerning CO 2 e Emissions

    Open Access•Andrea Thorpe, Frank Figge•Business Strategy and the…•2026

  • The Adoption of Sufficiency Practices in Sustainability‐Oriented Businesses

    Open Access•Maike Gossen, Laura Niessen‐Wade et al.•Business Strategy and the…•2026

  • Towards Strong Sustainability

    Open Access•Maike Gossen, Katrin Pakizer et al.•Business Strategy and the…•2026

  • Thinking With, Not Just About, Nature

    Open Access•Rajat Panwar, Frederik Dahlmann et al.•Business & Society•2026

  • One-stop shops as leverage points for renovation sufficiency

    Open Access•Georgios Pardalis, Migena Sula•Buildings and Cities•2026

  • Sufficiency Initiatives and Municipalities

    Open Access•Michael Buschka, Philipp Schepelmann et al.•Urban Planning•2024

  • Tipping dynamics of consumer lifestyle change

    Open Access•Jeroen Struben•Sustainability Science•2026

  • Le rôle des limites locales dans la sobriété énergétique

    Open Access•Jessica Zaphiropoulo•Lien social et Politiques•2024

  • Understandings of sufficiency

    Open Access•Tina Nyfors•Environmental Values•2026

  • Embodied universalism

    Open Access•Cécile Ezvan, Fiona Ottaviani•Ecological Economics•2026

  • Bridging beyond GDP and degrowth

    Open Access•Felix van Hoften, Nicky Pouw et al.•Ecological Economics•2026

  • Corporate biodiversity risk exposure in China

    Open Access•Peigong Li, Umeair Shahzad•Ecological Economics•2026

  • Analyzing citizens' preferences for sufficiency policy in municipalities — An experimental approach

    Open Access•Tonja Iten, Max Rudolf et al.•Ecological Economics•2026

  • Municipal solid waste generation in Norway

    Open Access•Kim Rainer Mattson, Julia Sborz et al.•Ecological Economics•2026

  • GDP alternatives revisited

    Open Access•Tim Taylor, Tania Smith Taylor et al.•Ecological Economics•2026

  • “Having enough” is not enough

    Open Access•Damaris Castro, Brent Bleys•Ecological Economics•2026

  • Integrating sufficiency-oriented lifestyles and socio-political acceptance of land-use changes in urban sustainability transformations

    Open Access•Eveliina Dunkel, Janina Käyhkö et al.•Landscape and Urban Planning•2026

  • Towards radical circular economy futures

    Open Access•Leandro J Llorente-González, Josep Pinyol Alberich et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2025

  • Integrated framework of intervention points and transformative outcomes for single- and multi-system transitions

    Open Access•Laur Kanger, Bipashyee Ghosh et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2025

  • Can app-based communities support energy sufficiency in households? Evidence from a one-year quasi-experiment in Switzerland

    Open Access•Francesca Cellina, Tiziano Gerosa et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2024

  • Why and how lifestyle change to reduced consumption is an active part of the emerging sustainability transformation

    Open Access•Magnus Boström, Åsa Callmer•Current Sociology•2025

  • From sufficiency principles to circular economy strategies

    Regis Chenavaz, R ́egis Y Chenavaz et al.•International Journal of…•2025

  • Beyond Efficiency

    Open Access•Anne Fischer, Marlen Gabriele Arnold•Sustainable Development•2026

  • Degrowth by law? A critical realist approach to law in transformation

    Open Access•Dorothea Elena Schoppek•Environmental Values•2026

  • Could a minimalist lifestyle reduce carbon emissions and improve wellbeing? A review of minimalism and other low consumption lifestyles

    Open Access•Rebecca Blackburn, Zoe Leviston et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2024

  • Frugal abundance

    Open Access•Adrien Plomteux•Ecological Economics•2024

  • Efficiency, sufficiency and consistency in sustainable development

    Open Access•Marco Rudolf, Mario Schmidt•Ecological Economics•2024

  • What to gain, what to lose? A taxonomy of individual-level gains and losses associated with consumption reduction

    Open Access•Petra Riefler, Charlotte Baar et al.•Ecological Economics•2024

  • A world of shocks

    Giulio Breglia, Marco Modica•Regional Studies•2025

  • Assessing the substantive outputs of deliberative minipublics

    Open Access•Magni Szymaniak-Arnesen, Adela Gąsiorowska•Policy Sciences•2025

  • Integrating sufficiency in the trade and biodiversity agenda of the European Union

    Open Access•Nicolas Le Roux, Johanna Coenen et al.•One Earth•2025

  • How does heritage contribute to inclusive growth

    Brenda Denise Dorpalen, Eirini Gallou•Journal of Cultural Heritage…•2023

  • More Than We Can Return

    Open Access•Alice Stocco, Gianni Barbiero et al.•Ecopsychology•2026

  • Sufficiency in passenger transport and its potential for lowering energy demand

    Open Access•Marlin Arnz, Anton Krumm•Environmental Research Letters•2023

  • Putting sufficiency into practice

    Open Access•Michaela Christ, Jonas Lage et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Wie kann Suffizienzpolitik gelingen? Planung und Umsetzung suffizienzorientierter Stadtentwicklung durch kommunale Verwaltungen

    Open Access•Jonas Lage, Maike Böcker et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2023

  • Sufficiency between producers and consumers

    Open Access•Mauricio Hernández-Pérez, Mauricio Hernández et al.•Ecological Economics•2024

  • To spend or to avoid? A critical review on the role of money in aiming for sufficiency

    Open Access•Fatemeh Jouzi, Jarkko Levänen et al.•Ecological Economics•2024

  • ESG for Sustainability in Hospitality and Tourism

    Open Access•Hakseung Shin, Yujeong Jo et al.•Travel Research Bulletin•2026

  • Sufficiency gains limited attention in Finnish climate policy on household consumption

    Essi Nuorivaara•Consumption and Society•2024

  • Can sufficiency become the new normal? Exploring consumption patterns of low-income groups in Norway

    Open Access•Marius Korsnes, Gisle Solbu•Consumption and Society•2024

  • Provide or prevent? Exploring sufficiency imaginaries within Danish systems of provision

    Open Access•Line Kryger Aagaard, Toke Haunstrup Christensen•Buildings and Cities•2024

  • Structural barriers to sufficiency

    Open Access•Max Koch, Kajsa Emilsson et al.•Buildings and Cities•2024

  • Promoting neighbourhood sharing

    Open Access•Andreas Huber, Harald Heinrichs et al.•Buildings and Cities•2024

  • Energy sufficiency and recognition justice

    Open Access•Alice Guilbert•Buildings and Cities•2024

  • Operationalising building-related energy sufficiency measures in SMEs

    Open Access•Imane Fouiteh, Daniel Cabrera et al.•Buildings and Cities•2024

  • Promoting practices of sufficiency

    Open Access•Toke Haunstrup Christensen, Line Kryger Aagaard et al.•Buildings and Cities•2024

  • Energy sufficiency, space temperature and public policy

    Open Access•Janine Morley•Buildings and Cities•2026

  • Acceptability of sufficiency consumption policies by Finnish households

    Open Access•Essi Nuorivaara, Sanna Ahvenharju•Buildings and Cities•2025

  • Energy sufficiency in buildings and cities

    Open Access•Marlyne Sahakian, Tina Fawcett et al.•Buildings and Cities•2024

  • A Strong Sustainability Framework for Digital Preservation of Cultural Heritage

    Open Access•Evangelia Paschalidou, Charlotte Fafet et al.•Heritage•2022

  • Ten principles for transforming economics in a time of global crises

    Open Access•Jasper O Kenter, Simone Martino et al.•Nature Sustainability•2025

  • Ethical consumption in three stages

    Open Access•Sara Karimzadeh, Magnus Boström•Environmental Sociology•2023

  • When saying “enough” is not enough

    Open Access•Cecile Chamaret, Mathias Guérineau et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2023

  • Citizens call for sufficiency and regulation — A comparison of European citizen assemblies and National Energy and Climate Plans

    Open Access•Jonas Lage, Johannes Thema et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2023

  • Embracing sufficiency to accelerate the energy transition

    Open Access•Fabian Dablander, Clifford Hickey et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2024

  • Rethinking the energy transition

    Open Access•Bruno Bourliaguet•Energy Research & Social Science•2025

  • Beyond predict and provide

    Open Access•Sophie-Marie Ertelt•Energy Research & Social Science•2024

  • How much travel is enough? Minimum levels for sustainable mobility

    Open Access•Marte Peeters, Tine Compernolle et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2026

  • Conceptualizing supply- and demand-side climate change mitigation

    Open Access•Melanie Pichler, Richard Bärnthaler et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2025

  • Decoupling wellbeing from consumption

    Open Access•Fatemeh Jouzi, Jarkko Levänen et al.•Sustainability Science•2026

  • Engagement of citizens in energy governance

    Open Access•Adrien Chanteloup, Lea Diestelmeier et al.•Sustainability Science•2025

  • Sufficiency policy

    Open Access•Tonja Iten, Irmi Seidl et al.•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Regeneration, sufficiency and degrowth

    Open Access•Lotte Levelt, Nicolas Chevrollier et al.•Sustainability Science•2025

  • At the intersections of influence

    Open Access•Laura Maria Wallnoefer, Sahra Svensson-Höglund et al.•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Towards self-sufficiency

    Open Access•Mart van der Kam, Maria Lagomarsino et al.•Sustainability Science•2025

  • Policy for material efficiency in homes and cars

    Open Access•Robert Lifset, Edgar G Hertwich et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2024

  • Is a New Economic System Necessary to Address Climate Change

    Open Access•Diana Stuart, R Gunderson et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2025

  • Interspecies Justice within a Normative Sustainable Development Framework–Animal-Friendly Energy Systems as a Test Case

    Open Access•Leonie Bossert•Journal of Agricultural and…•2024

  • Sufficiency as relations of enoughness

    Open Access•Eric Hartmann•Sustainable Development•2024

  • Social, Technological, Economic, and Policy Factors in the Circular Economy Transition in Brazil

    Open Access•Alejandro Gallego‐Schmid, Ana Belén Guerrero et al.•Sustainable Development•2025

  • Sustainability Strategies

    Open Access•Eric Hartmann•Sustainable Development•2025

  • Sufficiency Economy Across Cultures

    Open Access•Theeranuch Pusaksrikit, Nuttapol Assarut•Sustainable Development•2025

  • Sustainable Consumption and Production

    Open Access•Yanfei Geng, Shuyu Zhao et al.•Sustainable Development•2025

  • Epochal turns

    Open Access•Joachim H Spangenberg, Rudi Kurz•Sustainable Development•2023

  • Towards a systemic view on rebound effects

    Open Access•Daniel Guzzo, B Walrave et al.•Ecological Economics•2023

  • Sufficiency as a matter of care

    Open Access•Laura Beyeler, Melanie Jaeger-Erben et al.•Ecological Economics•2025

  • Meeting housing needs within planetary boundaries

    Open Access•Stefan Horn, Ian Gough et al.•Ecological Economics•2024

  • The benefits of less

    Open Access•Manuel Suter, Simon Rabaa et al.•Ecological Economics•2025

  • Public support for degrowth policies and sufficiency behaviours in the United States

    Open Access•Dallas O’dell, Dallas O'Dell et al.•Ecological Economics•2024

  • Exploring the motivation and challenges for land-users engaged in sustainable grazing in Europe

    Open Access•Julia Rouet-Leduc, Julia Rouet‐Leduc et al.•Land Use Policy•2024

  • When enough is enough

    Open Access•Richard Bärnthaler•AMBIO•2024

  • A call for psychological and behavioural science on degrowth

    Open Access•Dario Krpan, Frédéric Basso et al.•Nature Human Behaviour•2025

  • Households in energy transition

    Open Access•Francesca Cellina, Evelyn Lobsiger-Kägi et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2024

  • Energy-Saving Practices at a Time of Crisis

    Open Access•Senja Laakso•Housing Theory and Society•2025

  • Eco-Sufficiency and Global Justice

    Ariel Salleh•Eco-Sufficiency and Global Justice•2009

  • Environmental Sustainability

    Open Access•Robert Goodland, Herman E Daly et al.•Ecological Applications•1996

  • General Systems Theory—The Skeleton of Science

    Open Access•Kenneth E Boulding•Management Science•1956

  • Approaching a state shift in Earth’s biosphere

    Open Access•Anthony D Barnosky, Elizabeth A Hadly et al.•Nature•2012

  • Sufficiency transitions

    Open Access•Maria Sandberg•Journal of Cleaner Production•2021

  • Towards industrial ecology

    Joseph Huber•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2000

  • Beyond the business case for corporate sustainability

    Open Access•Thomas Dyllick, Kai Hockerts•Business Strategy and the…•2002

  • The material footprint of nations

    Open Access•Thomas Wiedmann, Thomas O Wiedmann et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2015

  • Population, Sustainability, and Earth's Carrying Capacity

    Gretchen C Daily, P R Ehrlich•BioScience•1992

  • Tracking the ecological overshoot of the human economy

    Open Access•Mathis Wackernagel, Niels Schulz et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2002

  • Energy and Economic Myths

    Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen, Nicholas Georgescu‐roegen•Southern Economic Journal•1975

  • A literature and practice review to develop sustainable business model archetypes

    Open Access•Nancy Bocken, N M P Bocken et al.•Journal of Cleaner Production•2014

  • A systematic review of the evidence on decoupling of GDP, resource use and GHG emissions, part II

    Open Access•H Haberl, Dominik Wiedenhofer et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2020

  • The art of writing literature review

    Open Access•Justin Paul, Alex Rialp et al.•International Business Review•2020

  • Towards a Methodology for Developing Evidence‐Informed Management Knowledge by Means of Systematic Review

    Open Access•David Tranfield, David Denyer et al.•British Journal of Management•2003

  • Voluntary Simplicity and the Social Reconstruction of Law

    Open Access•Samuel Alexander•Environmental Values•2013

  • Equality as a Moral Ideal

    Harry G Frankfurt, Harry Frankfurt•Ethics•1987

  • Encouraging consumption reduction

    Open Access•Maike Gossen, Anneli Heinrich•Cleaner and Responsible Consumption•2021

  • Sufficiency and Sustainability

    Open Access•Tommi Lehtonen, Pasi Heikkurinen•Environmental Values•2022

  • From Metabolic Rift to “Metabolic Value”

    Open Access•Ariel Salleh•Organization & Environment•2010

  • Slower Consumption Reflections on Product Life Spans and the “Throwaway Society”

    Open Access•Tim Cooper•Journal of Industrial Ecology•2005

  • Enough is enough

    M R Sivaraman, Madras Sivaraman•International Journal of…•2013

  • Decoupling for ecological sustainability

    Open Access•Tere Vadén, Ville Lähde et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2020

  • Sustainable Consumption Corridors

    Antonietta Di Giulio, Doris Fuchs•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2014

  • Is it up to them? Individual leverages for sufficiency

    Caroline Verfuerth, Laura Henn et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2019

  • Sufficiency, Liberal Societies and Environmental Policy in the Face of Planetary Boundaries

    Adrian Müller, Markus Huppenbauer•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2016

  • Who should waste less? Food waste prevention and rebound effects in the context of the Sustainable Development Goals

    Open Access•Wiebke Hagedorn, Henning Wilts•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2019

  • The sustainable development index

    Open Access•Jason Hickel•Ecological Economics•2020

  • Ecological sufficiency, individual liberties, and distributive justice

    Open Access•Peter Heindl, Philipp Kanschik•Ecological Economics•2016

  • The rebound effect

    Open Access•Steve Sorrell, John Dimitropoulos•Ecological Economics•2008

  • Ecological economics for humanity’s plague phase

    Open Access•William E Rees•Ecological Economics•2020

  • The sufficiency strategy

    Open Access•Blake Alcott•Ecological Economics•2008

  • Three Scenario Narratives for a Resource-Efficient and Low-Carbon Europe in 2050

    Open Access•Karin Schanes, Jill Jäger et al.•Ecological Economics•2019

  • Jevons' paradox

    Open Access•Blake Alcott•Ecological Economics•2005

  • Commons-based peer production for degrowth? - The case for eco-sufficiency in economic organisations

    Open Access•Ben Robra, Pasi Heikkurinen et al.•Sustainable Futures•2020

  • When justice narratives meet energy system models

    Open Access•Ganna Gladkykh, Brynhildur Davíðsdóttir et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2021

  • Talkin’ bout a revolution

    Open Access•Josephine Tröger, Gerhard Reese•Sustainability Science•2021

  • Can ‘Sufficiency’ reconcile social and environmental goals? A Q-methodological analysis of German housing policy

    Open Access•Katharina Bohnenberger•Journal of Housing and the Built…•2020

  • Principles for Sustainability

    Thomas Princen•Global Environmental Politics•2003

  • Framing sufficiency

    Open Access•Ola Persson, Mikael Klintman•Journal of Consumer Culture•2021

  • Strongly sustainable development goals

    Open Access•Karl Johan Bonnedahl, Pasi Heikkurinen et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2022

  • New Conceptions of Sufficient Home Size in High-Income Countries

    Maurie J Cohen•Housing Theory and Society•2020

  • Sufficiency and Material Development

    Open Access•Shanthikumar Hettiarachchi•European Review•2012

  • Rural workers and environmentally sustainable livelihoods in Australia

    Open Access•Helen Masterman-Smith, Helen Masterman‐Smith•Rural Society•2013

  • Needs, wants and values in China

    Open Access•Boqian Yan, Joachim H Spangenberg•Sustainable Development•2018

  • Sustainable development policies and achievements in the context of the agriculture sector in Thailand

    Open Access•Sukallaya Kasem, Gopal B Thapa•Sustainable Development•2010

  • A critical appraisal of Sustainable Consumption and Production research

    Open Access•Frank W Geels, Andrew Mcmeekin et al.•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • The Environmental Impact of Green Consumption and Sufficiency Lifestyles Scenarios in Europe

    Open Access•Gibran Vita, Johan Lundstrom et al.•Ecological Economics•2019

  • Circular futures

    Open Access•Thomas Bauwens, Marko Hekkert et al.•Ecological Economics•2020

  • Paradigms and paradoxes

    Open Access•Udo Pesch•International Journal of…•2018

  • Urban Food Security and Landscape Change

    G Brunori, Francesco Di Iacovo•Landscape Research•2014

  • Renewable energy, sustainability paradox and the post-urban question

    Open Access•Pushpa Arabindoo•Urban Studies•2020

  • Scenarios based on sustainability discourses

    Open Access•Maarten Crivits, Erik Paredis et al.•Futures•2010

  • Towards a sufficiency-driven business model

    Open Access•Nancy Bocken, Samuel W Short•Environmental Innovation and…•2016

  • A good life for all within planetary boundaries

    Open Access•Daniel W O''Neill, Andrew L Fanning et al.•Nature Sustainability•2018

  • Two types of 'enough

    Laura Spengler•Environmental Politics•2016

  • Reconceptualising urbanism, ecology and networked infrastructures

    Mark Swilling•Social Dynamics•2011

Unique citing works89
Citations per year22,25
Citation span2022 - 2026 (5)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 86

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae