Cracking the Frame? On the Prospects of Change in a World of Struggle

Critical scholarship classically lays bare the assumptions and choices that people make when they argue. By displaying the consequences of those assumptions and choices, it seeks to instil a sense of responsibility for them. Drawing them out into the open, critical scholarship presents them for contestation, unsettles them, and opens them up for change. In his latest book , A World of Struggle, David Kennedy directs our attention to the background work of expertise – how it rules through arguments, how it shapes the global political economy and how it sustains unjust distributions of gains. Kennedy offers a warm invitation to join the struggle to imagine and remake the world differently. In the present review essay, I discuss this invitation’s specific appeal. More generally, I ask about the prospects of change in international law as well as the activities that might support such change. I submit, first, that carving out background assumptions and choices is not enough. What is needed is an account of transitions – something that Kennedy acknowledges but does not provide. Second, I approach the vexed question of who could effectively crack existing frames – a question that Kennedy ducks. And, third, I discuss the role of violence, rhetoric and reason in the argumentative practice of expert work – distinctions that Kennedy refutes. I am ultimately happy to accept Kennedy’s invitation. It surely comes with immense acuity, subtle side blows and not so subtle punches, always in his signature style. I conclude that, with the aim of inducing change, a core activity of scholars should be to trace changes in concrete contexts and to thereby regain a sense for the possibilities of the past

Aesthetics · Appeal · Argumentative · Carving · Epistemology · Law and economics · Linguistics · Political science · Politics · Rhetoric · Scholarship · Sociology · Global Peace and Security Dynamics · International Relations and Foreign Policy · History · Law · Philosophy

• Auf Dem Weg Zu Einer Neuen Aufklärung

  Anna Katsman, Anna Luisa Lippold et al.•Auf Dem Weg Zu Einer Neuen…•2022

  Add to list

• Possibilities of the Past

  Ingo Venzke•Journal of the History of…•2018

  Add to list