Reflections on the work of John Wansbrough

At least some of the negative reactions to and neglect of Wansbrough's work is due to the breadth of his erudition and the turgidity of his style. However, these do not detract from the intriguing methods and theories that he brings to the study of early Islamic texts. Wansbrough's literary method is as problematic for what he believes it suggests about the development of early Islam as for his assertion about what it cannot tell us. Two of his speculative historical reconstructions produced by this method deserve special note. His theory concerning the relatively late canonization of the Qur ̧ān has certainly generated considerable opposition. His argument that Near Eastern monotheism played a much greater role in the formation of Islam accounts for the many affinities between Islam and Judaism and Christianity, but perhaps not for Islam's distinctiveness. These contributions, among others, are of such great significance, that no student of Islamic origins can afford to ignore them

Argument (complex analysis · Assertion · Epistemology · Islam · Judaism · Literature · Monotheism · Optimal distinctiveness theory · Theology · Education and Islamic Studies · Historical and Linguistic Studies · Islamic Studies and History · Philosophy

• Quranic Studies

  John Wansbrough•Quranic Studies•2004

  Añadir item

• Hagarism

  Patricia Crone•Hagarism•1977

  Añadir item

• The Quest of the Historical Muhammad

  Open Access•F E Peters•International Journal Middle East…•1991

  Añadir item

• Rewriting the Timetable of Early Islam

  John Burton, Norman Calder•Journal of the American Oriental…•1995

  Añadir item