Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Managed Civil Society and Police Oversight in Russia

Regional Police–Public Councils

Bibliographic Data

ID12298917
AuthorsLauren A Mccarthy (0000-0001-9169-4375, corresponding author), Katherine Stolerman, Anton V Tikhomirov
Year2020
Volume72
Issue9
Pages1498-1522
Publication date2020-10-20
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueEurope Asia Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0966-8136 • E-ISSN: 1465-3427
PublisherRoutledge (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/09668136.2020.1832964
OpenAlexW3096314609
LanguageEN
Citations received9
References cited35

This article examines the official police oversight bodies, the ‘public councils’ under the Ministry of Internal Affairs (obshchestvennyi sovet pri MVD), using publicly available data from 40 regional councils. We find that council members are loyal and highly regarded individuals likely to be friendly to state interests. Councils primarily focus on promoting state goals, using the media to perpetuate a positive image of the police, and encouraging traditional values rather than more critical oversight. However, councils also work on non-contentious everyday problems such as improving road safety, preventing crime, and engaging with local youth. This article shows how the Russian state is reconstituting its relationship with society through these state-sanctioned bodies

Civil society · Criminal justice · Police science · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Crime Patterns and Interventions · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Policing Practices and Perceptions · Public Administration

  • Polarization, Shifting Borders and Liquid Governance

    Open Access•Anja Mihr, Chiara Pierobon•Polarization, Shifting Borders…•2024

  • Les paradoxes du recours au droit dans les mobilisations contre les violences policières en Russie

    Open Access•Anne Le Huérou•Champ pénal•2022

  • Consultative Authoritarianism in Central Asia

    Colin Knox, Dina Sharipova•Europe Asia Studies•2024

  • Prisons of Poverty and Politics

    Open Access•Olga Zeveleva•International Journal of Politics…•2023

  • Oversight of the Legal System in an Authoritarian Regime

    Open Access•Lauren A Mccarthy•Journal of Law and Courts•2025

  • Supporting Democratic Policing in Central Asia

    Cornelius Friesendorf•Europe Asia Studies•2022

  • Digital activism and authoritarian legitimation in post-Soviet Central Asia

    Bakhytzhan Kurmanov, Colin Knox•The Information Society•2024

  • You’re a disgrace to the uniform!” Lev Protiv’s challenge to the police in Moscow streets and on YouTube

    Gilles Favarel-Garrigues, Gilles Favarel‐garrigue et al.•Post-Soviet Affairs•2022

  • Turning on the lights? Publicity and defensive legal mobilization in protest-related trials in Russia

    Open Access•Renata Mustafina•Law & Society Review•2022

  • State Building in Putin’s Russia

    Brian D Taylor•State Building in Putin's Russia•2011

  • The Weakness of Civil Society in Post-Communist Europe

    Open Access•Marc M Howard•Weakness of Civil Society in…•2003

  • Coping with the failure of the police in post-Soviet Russia

    Margarita Zernova•Police Practice and Research•2012

  • Public assistance of police during criminal investigations

    Olga Semukhina•Police Practice and Research•2016

  • Trafficking Justice

    Lauren A Mccarthy•Trafficking justice•2015

  • The state and civil society in Post-Soviet Russia

    Open Access•Sergej Ljubownikow, Jo Crotty et al.•Progress in Development Studies•2013

  • The Ministry of Civil Society

    James Richter•Problems of Post-Communism•2009

  • Russian citizens' perceptions of corruption and trust of the police

    Olga Semukhina, K Michael Reynolds•Policing & Society•2013

  • Russian NGOs and Their Struggle for Legitimacy in the Face of the ‘Foreign Agents’ Law

    Evelyn Moser, Anna Skripchenko•Europe Asia Studies•2018

  • Crowding Out Civil Society

    Leah Gilbert•Europe Asia Studies•2016

  • Law enforcement and civil society in Russia

    Brian D Taylor•Europe Asia Studies•2006

  • Competing Ideologies of Russia's Civil Society

    Elena Chebankova•Europe Asia Studies•2015

  • Civil Society under the Law ‘On Foreign Agents’

    Open Access•Maria S Tysiachniouk, Svetlana Tulaeva et al.•Europe Asia Studies•2018

  • In the Shadow of the Ombudsman

    Freek Van Der Vet•Europe Asia Studies•2017

  • The Non-profit Sector in Today’s Russia

    Yulia Skokova, Ulla Pape et al.•Europe Asia Studies•2018

  • The Struggle for Meaning of Obshchestvennyi Kontrol’ in Contemporary Russia

    Catherine Owens•Europe Asia Studies•2017

  • Policing Soviet Society

    Open Access•Louise I Shelley, Louise Shelley•Law & Social Inquiry•1990

  • Organizing Civil Society in Russia and China

    Open Access•James Richter, Walter Hatch et al.•International Journal of Politics…•2013

  • Nashi, Youth Voluntarism, and Potemkin NGOs

    J Hemment•Slavic Review•2012

  • Local-level law enforcement

    Lauren A Mccarthy•Post-Soviet Affairs•2014

  • Police reform in Russia

    Brian D Taylor•Post-Soviet Affairs•2014

  • Faking performance together

    Ella Paneyakh•Post-Soviet Affairs•2014

  • Putin and the Public Chamber

    James Richter•Post-Soviet Affairs•2009

  • Resurgent authoritarianism

    Geir Flikke•Post-Soviet Affairs•2016

  • Civic Participation in a Hybrid Regime

    Open Access•Catherine Owens, Catherine Owen et al.•Government and Opposition•2019

  • Russian welfare reform and social NGOs

    Anna Tarasenko•East European Politics•2015

  • Consentful contention” in a corporate state

    Catherine Owens•East European Politics•2015

  • State–society relations in contemporary Russia

    Open Access•Ammon Cheskin, Luke March•East European Politics•2015

  • The state, civil society and social rights in contemporary Russia

    Eleanor Bindman•East European Politics•2015

  • A Genealogy of Kontrol' in Russia

    Open Access•Catherine Owens, Catherine Owen•Slavic Review•2016

  • Public Experiences of Police Violence and Corruption in Contemporary Russia

    Open Access•T P Gerber, Sarah E Mendelson•Law & Society Review•2008

  • Managing Boundaries

    Open Access•Sergej Ljubownikow, Jo Crotty•Sociology•2017

Unique citing works9
Citations per year2,25
Citation span2022 - 2025 (4)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 9
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae