Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Aggregation, Clickbait and Their Effect on Perceptions of Journalistic Credibility and Quality

Bibliographic Data

ID12909780
AuthorsLogan Molyneux (0000-0001-7382-3065, Temple University, corresponding author), Mark Coddington (0000-0001-6664-6152, Washington and Lee University)
Year2019
Volume14
Issue4
Pages429-446
Publication date2019-06-16
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournalism Practice (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1751-2786 • E-ISSN: 1751-2794
PublisherTaylor & Francis (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/17512786.2019.1628658
OpenAlexW2949535404
LanguageEN
Citations received46
References cited45

Many journalists and industry observers lament that aggregating news underneath sensational headlines will erode credibility and turn off readers. While some scholarly work has studied journalists’ perspectives of this practice, little has been done to understand what audiences think of aggregation and clickbait. This study uses published original and aggregated news articles as stimuli in two online experiments to test readers’ perceptions of news aggregation and clickbait. Aggregation itself has little effect on perceptions of credibility and quality; instead, writing proficiency is more closely linked to these perceptions. Results also suggest clickbait headlines may lower perceptions of credibility and quality

Advertising · Business · Credibility · Epistemology · Journalism · Perception · Political science · Public relations · Quality (philosophy · Source credibility · Law · Media Studies and Communication · Misinformation and Its Impacts · Psychology · Social Media and Politics · Social Psychology

  • La praxis del «clickbait» y de The Trust Project

    Open Access•Jesus Miguel Flores-Vivar, Ana María Zaharía•Anàlisi•2022

  • In the Service of Good Journalism and Audience Interests? How Audience Metrics Affect News Quality

    Open Access•Silke Fürst•Media and Communication•2020

  • Exploring audience perceptions of, and preferences for, data-driven ‘quantitative’ journalism

    Open Access•Florian Stalph, Neil Thurman et al.•Journalism•2023

  • Here’s What to Know About Clickbait

    Fred Vultee, G Scott Burge et al.•Journalism Practice•2020

  • Periodismo, experticia y toma de decisiones técnicas

    Open Access•Manuela Irarrázabal Elliott•Conexión•2021

  • Government risk communication and response networks

    Open Access•Lihua Wang, Shengyi Jiang•International Journal of Disaster…•2025

  • Clickbait-style headlines and journalism credibility in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Flora Wanda Judith, Samson Chipanjilo Baraka et al.•Journal of Media and Communication…•2021

  • Valoración profesional del sector periodístico sobre el efecto de la desinformación y las fake news en el ecosistema mediático

    Open Access•Alberto Martín García, Álex Buitrago•Revista ICONO14•2022

  • The Impact of Sensational News Towards Public Perception on The Malaysian News Industry

    Open Access•Jin Xuan Oon•Jurnal Pengajian Media Malaysia•2023

  • Deontología periodística en el tratamiento informativo del intento secesionista catalán

    Open Access•Sara Dorado Lago, José Sixto García•Ámbitos Revista Internacional de…•2021

  • Unpacking the Epistemology of Ethiopian Digital Journalism

    Behailu Atinafu Dessie, Abera Yenework Kebede•Journal of Media Ethics•2025

  • The algorithmic trap

    Open Access•Ansar Suherman•Frontiers in Communication•2025

  • Social Media Metrics in the Digital Marketplace of Attention

    Jieun Shin, Katherine Ognyanova•Digital Journalism•2022

  • Emotion Sells

    Jieun Shin, Chris Defelice et al.•Digital Journalism•2025

  • Decoding Clickbait

    Open Access•Yikai Wang, Bin Hu et al.•Cyberpsychology Behavior and…•2025

  • Audience engagement with news on Chinese social media

    Open Access•Geqi Wu, Chunlei Pan•Discourse & Communication•2022

  • Factors Affecting Turnover and Turnaway Intention of Journalists in South Korea

    Open Access•Haeyeop Song, Jaemin Jung•Journalism & Mass Communication…•2022

  • Engager, cliquer, liker. L’éditorialisation des contenus journalistiques sur les plateformes numériques

    Open Access•Sara Germain, Camille Alloing•Quaderni•2022

  • When falsehood wins? Varied effects of sensational elements on users’ engagement with real and fake posts

    Open Access•Mingxiao Sui, Ian Hawkins et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2023

  • I cue you liking me

    Open Access•Wanjiang Jacob Zhang, Jingjing Yi et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2023

  • News story aggregation and perceived credibility

    Open Access•Stan Diel, Chris Roberts•Newspaper Research Journal•2021

  • The Immediate and Delayed Beliefs in Headlines With High-arousal Sentence Starters

    Open Access•Xiaoyu Zhou, Tan Zhang et al.•Communication Research•2025

  • Information Quality in Latin American Digital Native Media

    Open Access•Claudia Rodríguez-Hidalgo, Diana Rivera-Rogel et al.•Media and Communication•2020

  • Securing the Future of UK Public-Interest News

    Open Access•François Nel, Kamila Rymajdo•Media and Communication•2024

  • The expectation-evaluation gap

    Open Access•Steve Guo, Steve Zhongshi Guo et al.•Global Media and China•2026

  • The Impact of Transmedia Processes on the Linguistic Personality of the Web Communicant

    Open Access•Galina Trofimova, Roman Savastenko et al.•Vestnik Volgogradskogo…•2022

  • The Language Means of Comicality in Clickbait Headings

    Open Access•Natalia Prokofeva, Irina Akulovich•Vestnik Volgogradskogo…•2021

  • All the President’s Lies

    Marília Gehrke, Marcelo Träsel et al.•Journalism Practice•2023

  • Grabbing Wall Street’s Attention

    Bo Xu, Lee Miller et al.•Journalism Practice•2025

  • What Comes After the Algorithm? An Investigation of Journalists’ Post-editing of Automated News Text

    Open Access•Sina Thäsler-Kordonouri•Journalism Practice•2024

  • Claim Negations vs. Fact Affirmations

    Ferre Wouters, Michael Opgenhaffen et al.•Journalism Practice•2025

  • A naturalização do assédio moral no jornalismo digital

    Open Access•Thales Vilela Lelo•Media & Jornalismo•2021

  • Clickbait news and algorithmic curation

    Open Access•Juliane A Lischka, Marcel Garz•New Media & Society•2021

  • Different stakes, different struggles, and different practices to survive

    Open Access•Jane Yeahin Pyo•New Media & Society•2022

  • Seeing is not always believing

    Open Access•Wenping Zhang, Wei Du et al.•Internet Research•2020

  • Muddying the waters on climate change

    Open Access•Rachel Carberry, Lyndon C S Way et al.•Social Semiotics•2025

  • Clickbait

    Open Access•Daniel Jácobo-Morales, Mauro Marino-Jiménez•Online Journal of Communication…•2024

  • References to nationality in crime reporting

    Open Access•Marlene Kunst•Studies in Communication and Media•2021

  • Figuring Digital Cascades

    Open Access•Nathalie Casemajor, Sylvain Rocheleau•Journal of Digital Social Research•2021

  • Does Numeracy in Digital Journalism Increase Story Believability

    Open Access•G Gondwe, Evan Rowe et al.•Journal of Digital Social Research•2021

  • Fake news as fake politics

    Open Access•André Lemos, André Luiz Martins Lemos et al.•Media Culture & Society•2021

  • The Unequal Challenge of Learning from Under-Informative News

    Open Access•Andrew Trexler•British Journal of Political…•2026

  • Misleading Polls in the Media

    Open Access•Matthew H Graham, D Sunshine Hillygus et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2024

  • Nota Introdutória

    Open Access•Sandra Marinho, Luís Miguel Loureiro et al.•Comunicação e Sociedade•2023

  • Responsabilização e Qualidade do Jornalismo

    Open Access•Júlia Miranda•Comunicação e Sociedade•2023

  • The majority of fact-checking labels in the United States are intense and this decreases engagement intention

    Open Access•Haoning Xue, Jingwen Zhang et al.•Human Communication Research•2024

  • The Life Informatic

    D Boyer•Life Informatic•2013

  • Exploring Receivers' Criteria for Perception of Print and Online News

    Open Access•Sundar, S Shyam Sundar•Journalism & Mass Communication…•1999

  • Differential Criteria for Evaluating Credibility of Newspapers and TV News

    Open Access•John E Newhagen, John Newhagen et al.•Journalism Quarterly•1989

  • Effective Headlines of Newspaper Articles in a Digital Environment

    Open Access•Jeffrey Kuiken, Anne Schuth et al.•Digital Journalism•2017

  • Using Is Believing

    Open Access•T Johnson, Thomas J Johnson et al.•Journalism & Mass Communication…•2000

  • Trust in News Media

    Open Access•Matthias Kohring, Jörg Matthes•Communication Research•2007

  • Media Credibility Reconsidered

    Open Access•Erik P Bucy•Journalism & Mass Communication…•2003

  • Attentive Turkers

    Open Access•David Hauser, Norbert Schwarz•Behavior Research Methods•2016

  • The effects of subtle misinformation in news headlines.

    Ullrich K H Ecker, Lewandowsky et al.•Journal of Experimental…•2014

  • Inside the Turk

    Open Access•Gabriele Paolacci, Joan Chandler et al.•Current Directions in Psychological…•2014

  • Cruising is Believing

    Open Access•Thomas J Johnson, Barbara K Kaye•Journalism & Mass Communication…•1998

  • Measuring Message Credibility

    Open Access•Alyssa Appelman, Sundar•Journalism & Mass Communication…•2015

  • Measuring the Concept of Credibility

    Open Access•Cecilie Gaziano, Kristin McGrath•Journalism Quarterly•1986

  • Conceptualizing sources in online news

    Open Access•Sundar, S S Sundar et al.•Journal of Communication•2001

  • Credibility for the 21st Century

    Miriam J Metzger, Andrew J Flanagin et al.•Annals of the International…•2003

  • Enter the Robot Journalist

    Christer Clerwall•Journalism Practice•2014

  • Public Trust or Mistrust? Perceptions of Media Credibility in the Information Age

    Spiro Kiousi•Mass Communication & Society•2001

  • Credibility in Context

    Kjerstin Thorson, Emily K Vraga et al.•Mass Communication & Society•2010

  • Blogs and Journalistic Authority

    Matt Carlson•Journalism Studies•2007

  • Effects of Civility and Reasoning in User Comments on Perceived Journalistic Quality

    Fabian Prochazka, Patrick Weber et al.•Journalism Studies•2016

  • The role of site features, user attributes, and information verification behaviors on the perceived credibility of web-based information

    Open Access•Andrew J Flanagin, Miriam J Metzger•New Media & Society•2007

  • A Boost or Bust for Democracy

    Open Access•Thomas J Johnson, Barbara K Kaye•Harvard International Journal of…•2003

  • Media-generated Shortcuts

    Open Access•Blake Andrew, Blake C Andrew•Harvard International Journal of…•2007

  • Influence of Story Structure on Perceived Story Bias and News Organization Credibility

    Frederick Fico, J David Richardson et al.•Mass Communication & Society•2004

  • Rebuilding the News

    C W Anderson•Rebuilding the news•2013

  • Revisiting Narrative Journalism as One of The Futures of Journalism

    Erik Neveu•Journalism Studies•2014

  • Here’s What BuzzFeed Journalists Think of Their Journalism

    Edson C Tandoc, Cassie Yuan Wen Foo•Digital Journalism•2017

  • News Quality from the Recipients' Perspective

    Juliane Urban, Wolfgang Schweiger•Journalism Studies•2013

  • Journalism is twerking? How web analytics is changing the process of gatekeeping

    Open Access•Edson C Tandoc•New Media & Society•2014

  • Audience Perceptions of Editing Quality

    Fred Vultee•Digital Journalism•2015

  • The Mind of a Journalist

    Jim Willis•The Mind of a Journalist•2010

  • What we do is not actually journalism

    Open Access•Igor Vobič, Ana Milojević•Journalism•2013

  • Online news flow

    Open Access•Sujin Choi, Jeongseob Kim•Journalism•2016

  • Gathering evidence of evidence

    Open Access•Mark Coddington•Journalism•2018

  • Readers’ perception of computer-generated news

    Open Access•Andreas Graefe, Mario Haim et al.•Journalism•2016

  • What aggregators do

    Open Access•C W Anderson, CW Anderson•Journalism•2013

  • The Influence of Source Credibility on Communication Effectiveness

    Carl I Hovland, Walter Wei et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•1951

  • On newspaper headlines as relevance optimizers

    Open Access•Daniel Dor•Journal of Pragmatics•2003

Unique citing works46
Citations per year7,67
Citation span2020 - 2026 (7)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 46

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae