Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Transdisciplinary sustainability research in real-world labs

Success factors and methods for change

Bibliographic Data

ID12950463
AuthorsMatthias Bergmann (0000-0002-6090-4429, Institute for Social-Ecological Research, corresponding author), N Schäpke (0000-0003-2232-1430, University of Freiburg), Oskar Marg (0000-0002-9265-5244, Institute for Social-Ecological Research), Franziska Stelzer (0000-0002-5326-147X, Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy), Daniel J Lang (0000-0001-5435-1488, Leuphana University of Lüneburg), Michael Bossert (Concordia University), Marius Gantert, Elke Häußler (Karlsruhe University of Applied Sciences), Editha Marquardt (0000-0002-0173-9582, German University of Administrative Sciences), Felix M Piontek (Helmholtz-Institute Ulm), Thomas Potthast (0000-0001-5238-4964, University of Tübingen), Regina Rhodius (0000-0002-7835-1578, University of Freiburg), Matthias Rudolph (0000-0002-0331-8394, Staatliche Akademie der Bildenden Künste Stuttgart), Michael Ruddat (0000-0002-9625-9062, University of Stuttgart), Andreas Seebacher (0000-0003-2100-8178, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology), Nico Sußmann (Heilbronn University)
Year2021
Volume16
Issue2
Pages541-564
Publication date2021-01-02
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSustainability Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1862-4057 • E-ISSN: 1862-4065
PublisherSpringer Science+Business Media (PUBLISHER • DE)
DOI10.1007/s11625-020-00886-8
OpenAlexW3119619653
LanguageEN
Citations received84
References cited54

The transdisciplinary research mode has gained prominence in the research on and for sustainability transformations. Yet, solution-oriented research addressing complex sustainability problems has become complex itself, with new transdisciplinary research formats being developed and tested for this purpose. Application of new formats offers learning potentials from experience. To this end, we accompanied fourteen research projects conceptualized as real-world labs (RwLs) from 2015 to 2018. RwLs were part of a funding program on ‘Science for Sustainability’ in the German federal state of Baden-Württemberg. Here, we combine conceptual and empirical work to a structured collection of experiences and provide a comprehensive account of RwLs. First, we outline characteristics of RwLs as transformation oriented, transdisciplinary research approach, using experiments, enabling learning and having a long-term orientation. Second, we outline eleven success factors and concrete design notes we gained through a survey of the 14 RwLs: (1) find the right balance between scientific and societal aims, (2) address the practitioners needs and restrictions, (3) make use of the experimentation concept, (4) actively communicate, (5) develop a ‘collaboration culture’, (6) be attached to concrete sites, (7) create lasting impact and transferability, (8) plan for sufficient time and financial means, (9) adaptability, (10) research-based learning, and (11) recognize dependency on external actors. Characteristics and success factors are combined to illustrate practical challenges in RwLs. Third, we show which methods could be used to cope with challenges in RwLs. We conclude discussing the state of debate on RwLs and outline future avenues of research

Adaptability · Business · Engineering ethics · Knowledge management · Management · Management science · Plan (archaeology · Political science · Process management · Public relations · Social sustainability · Sociology · Sustainability · Sustainability science · Transferability · Computer Science · Engineering · Innovation, Technology, and Society · Innovative Approaches in Technology and Social Development · Interdisciplinary Research and Collaboration

  • The self in the mirror

    Open Access•Janne Von Seggern, Jorrit Holst et al.•Conservation Ecology•2023

  • From collaboration to high-quality evidence for the energy transition

    Open Access•C Kacperski, M Bielig et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2026

  • Hackathon

    Open Access•Sonia Massari, Sara Roversi et al.•Handbook Transdisciplinary Learning•2023

  • Flexible Dienstleistungsarbeit gesundheitsförderlich gestalten

    Open Access•Guido Becke•Flexible Dienstleistungsarbeit…•2023

  • Zukunft gestalten mit Sozialen Innovationen

    Open Access•Jürgen Howaldt, Miriam Kreibich et al.•Zukunft gestalten mit Sozialen…•2022

  • Doing Research - Wissenschaftspraktiken zwischen Positionierung und Suchanfrage

    Open Access•Sandra Hofhues, Sandra Hofhue et al.•Doing Research - Wissenschaftsprakt…•2022

  • Beteiligung interkulturell gestalten

    Open Access•Autor*innen-Kollektiv Autor*innen-Kollektiv INTERPART•Beteiligung Interkulturell…•2021

  • Multi-level stakeholders' perspectives on implementation and scaling up community-based health promotion in Germany

    Open Access•Leonie Birkholz, Philipp Weber et al.•Health Promotion International•2023

  • An embedded agency perspective on exploring context, mechanisms of change, and impact of real-world labs

    Open Access•Karoline Augenstein, P M Bögel et al.•Sustainability: Science, Practice…•2026

  • Agricultural living labs

    Open Access•Michelle Bonatti, Franziska Ollendorf et al.•The Journal of Agricultural…•2026

  • Understanding why refuse-derived fuel biomass projects fail through the lens of adaptive capacity in rural Bali

    Open Access•I Wayan Koko Suryawan, Nova Ulhasanah et al.•Energy for Sustainable Development•2026

  • Reading between the lines

    Open Access•Veronika Stein, Tatiana Merino-Benítez et al.•Scientometrics•2026

  • Implementing Multistage Transdisciplinary Modeling for Policy Interventions

    Open Access•Liliya Satalkina, Nicole Hynek et al.•Systems Research and Behavioral…•2026

  • Convening for ocean memory

    Open Access•Heather R Spence, Stephen M Fiore et al.•Elementa Science of the…•2026

  • Capacity development for locally-led knowledge co-production processes in Real World Labs for managing climate and disaster risk

    Open Access•Lydia Cumiskey, Janne Parviainen et al.•International Journal of Disaster…•2025

  • Online Podcast Production as Co-Creation for Intercultural Participation in Neighbourhood Development

    Open Access•Robert Barbarino, Bianca Herlo et al.•Urban Planning•2022

  • Navigating four junctions

    Open Access•Nina Maria Frölich, Regina Rhodius et al.•Sustainability Science•2026

  • A Catalyst for Innovation? A Conceptual Framework for Analyzing the Potential of Urban Experiments to Transform Urban Planning Practices

    Franziska Schreiber, Josefine Fokdal et al.•Planning Theory & Practice•2023

  • Realizing the Transformative Potential of Experimentation in Planning

    Open Access•Luca Bertolini•Planning Theory & Practice•2025

  • Strategic boundary management in university‐based living labs

    Open Access•Hacer Tercanli, Ben Jongbloed et al.•Higher Education Quarterly•2024

  • Navigating across individual and deliberative values

    Open Access•Miguel Á Cebrián-Piqueras, Konrad Gray et al.•People and Nature•2025

  • Promising futures

    Open Access•Ami Crowther, Chris Foulds et al.•Futures•2026

  • Value landscapes in interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research and assessment

    Open Access•Anne-Sophie Schaltegger, Bianca Vienni-Baptista•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2026

  • Co-defining research priorities to address knowledge gaps for future management

    Open Access•Rereatara Taiarui Marguerite, Jean Wencélius et al.•Marine Policy•2025

  • Mapping the evolving research landscape of sustainability science from 2006 to 2023

    Open Access•Mesfin Sahle, Shruti Ashish Lahoti et al.•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Different perspectives on a common goal? The Q-method as a formative assessment to elucidate varying expectations towards transdisciplinary research collaborations

    Open Access•Verena Radinger-Peer, Elisabeth Schauppenlehner-Kloyber et al.•Sustainability Science•2022

  • Standardization in the context of transdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Knut Blind•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Building a conceptual spatial framework

    Open Access•Henrietta Palmer•Sustainability Science•2025

  • Empowering citizens for the energy transition

    Open Access•Helena Trenks, P M Bögel•Sustainability Science•2024

  • From attitudes to behaviour

    Open Access•Nora Delvendahl, Lynn Wagner et al.•Sustainability Science•2026

  • Degrowth scenarios for biodiversity? Key methodological steps and a call for collaboration

    Open Access•Iago Otero, Stanislas Rigal et al.•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Testing the quality of transformative science methods

    Open Access•Salina Spiering, María Del Valle Barrera•Sustainability Science•2021

  • Implementing post-normal science with or for EU policy actors

    Open Access•Kirsty Blackstock, Kerry Waylen et al.•Sustainability Science•2023

  • Governing University Living Labs for sustainability transformations

    Open Access•Paris Hadfield, D Sharp et al.•Sustainability Science•2025

  • Action research for transformative change

    Open Access•Thami Croeser, Serge Clément et al.•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Learning and community building in support of collective action

    Open Access•Kathleen A Mar, N Schäpke et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2023

  • Raising standards for stakeholder engagement in Nature-based Solutions

    Open Access•Alhassan Ibrahim, Keith Marshall et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Conceptualising boundary work activities to enhance credible, salient and legitimate knowledge in sustainability transdisciplinary research projects

    Open Access•L Andrews, Lisa M Andrews et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Bridging the knowledge-action gap

    Open Access•Aleksi Räsänen, Simo Sarkki et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Analyzing the political impact of Real-world laboratories for urban transformation in eight German ‘Cities of the Future’

    Open Access•Teresa Kampfmann, Daniel J Lang et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • What about citizens? A literature review of citizen engagement in sustainability transitions research

    Open Access•Suvi Huttunen, Maria Ojanen et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2022

  • The role of spatial and relative proximity while transforming towards an edible city – The case of the City of the Future Dresden (Germany)

    Open Access•Kristin Reiß, Martina Artmann•Environmental Innovation and…•2023

  • Establishing an accompanying approach in social sciences and humanities

    Elvira Crois, Geert Vandermeersche et al.•International Journal of Social…•2025

  • Mobility transition through labs in real-world contexts. The contribution of transdisciplinary approaches in creating sustainable transportation systems

    Open Access•Jan-Marc Joost, Martin Lanzendorf et al.•Journal of Transport Geography•2025

  • Reinventing the teaching-research nexus to foster university education in the twenty-first century

    Yanru Xu, Qiang Zha et al.•Compare A Journal of Comparative…•2025

  • Sustainability dialogues in Brazil

    Open Access•Fábio Rúbio Scarano, Ebba Brink et al.•Global Sustainability•2024

  • Shared pooled mobility

    Open Access•Felix Creutzig, Alexander Schmaus et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2024

  • Die Stadt als Labor. Wie Do-it-yourself-Kulturen Wege transdisziplinären Lernens eröffnen

    Thomas Philipp, Robert Jende•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2025

  • Reallabor versus Realexperiment

    Open Access•Oliver Parodi, Susanne Ober et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Labbing for sustainability transformations

    Open Access•Jetske Charlotte Erisman, L Feenstra et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Formative evaluation of transdisciplinary research for systematic impact orientation in real-world laboratories

    Open Access•Jasmin Wiefek, Emilia Nagy et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Exploring fruitful links between real-world laboratory and disciplinary research

    Open Access•Annika Weiser, Matthias Wanner et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2023

  • Creating and observing impacts in transdisciplinary projects ‐ Insights from the social design lab

    Open Access•Marlene Franck, Nadja Hempel et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Lessons from transdisciplinary urban research to promote sustainability transformation in real-world labs

    Open Access•Michael Kreß-Ludwig, Oskar Marg et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Impacts beyond experimentation ‐ Conceptualising emergent impacts from long-term real-world laboratory processes

    Open Access•Philip Bernert, Annika Weiser et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Herausforderung Reallabor

    Open Access•Oliver Parodi, Susanne Ober et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2021

  • Impacts of real-world labs in sustainability transformations

    Open Access•N Schäpke, Felix Wagner et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Impacts of urban real-world labs

    Open Access•Matthias Wanner, Karoline Augenstein et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Beyond scalable impacts

    Open Access•Manuel Jung, Alexander Wentland•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2024

  • Design principles for advancing higher education sustainability learning through transformative research

    Open Access•Philip Bernert, Matthias Wanner et al.•Environment Development and…•2022

  • Designing interventions for sustainable change in a real-world laboratory

    Open Access•Rea Pärli, Michael Stauffacher et al.•Environment Development and…•2022

  • Co-creating urban transformation

    Open Access•Pauline Heger, Christoph Bieber et al.•Buildings and Cities•2025

  • Sharing energy renovations know-how through citizen–professional knowledge networks

    Open Access•Chris Foulds, Sarah Royston et al.•Buildings and Cities•2026

  • Who do we mobilise? Applied transformative mobilities research in a real-world laboratory

    Open Access•Martin Kohler, Katharina Manderscheid•Applied Mobilities•2024

  • Exploring the role of transdisciplinary research in accelerating sustainability transition

    Open Access•Zoltán Csedő, Máté Zavarkó et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2025

  • Upscaling sustainable energy technology

    Open Access•Bart Bossink, Marlous Blankesteijn et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2023

  • Scientific policy advice on sustainable development

    Open Access•Nataliia Sokolovska, Anne Ellersiek et al.•Journal of Environmental Studies…•2024

  • Transdisciplinary learning as a key leverage for sustainability transformations

    Open Access•Matthias Barth, Amanda Jiménez-Aceituno et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2023

  • Five priorities to advance transformative transdisciplinary research

    Open Access•Karoline Augenstein, David PM Lam et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2024

  • Intercultural networks deepen learning for transformative sustainability education

    Open Access•Danielle Spence, Maureen G Reed et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2025

  • Governance for urban sustainability through real-world experimentation – Introducing an evaluation framework for transformative research involving public actors

    Open Access•Teresa Kampfmann, Philip Bernert et al.•Cities•2024

  • Equalizer

    Open Access•Karin Book, Elisabeth Högdahl•Leisure Studies•2024

  • Collaboration through environmental assessment networks

    Open Access•Lone Kørnøv, Sanne Vammen Larsen et al.•Environmental Impact Assessment…•2022

  • How to integrate youth in regional sustainability transformation processes

    Open Access•Cornelia Fischer, Verena Radinger-Peer•AMBIO•2024

  • A transdisciplinary approach to nuclear waste management

    Open Access•Roman Seidl, Cord Drögemüller et al.•AMBIO•2026

  • Structuring and advancing solution-oriented research for sustainability

    Open Access•Daniel J Lang, Arnim Wiek•AMBIO•2022

  • Getting personal with collaborative sustainability experimentation

    Open Access•B Ne, Darin Wahl•AMBIO•2022

  • The politics of transdisciplinary research on societal transitions

    Open Access•Jonas House, Natalie R Davis et al.•Futures•2024

  • Reconfiguring commuting - Using practice theory in real-world laboratories

    Open Access•Laura Trost, Luca Nitschke•Mobilities•2026

  • Sustainability-oriented labs in transitions

    Open Access•Gavin Mccrory, Johan Holmén et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2022

  • Incumbents’ in/ability to drive endogenous sustainability transitions in livestock farming

    Open Access•Jonathan Friedrich, Heiko Faust et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2023

  • Dynamic food procurement and cross-sectoral tensions

    Daniel Keech, Damian Maye et al.•Food and Foodways•2025

  • Why now? Questioning the confidence in eco-political experimentation in civil society

    Open Access•Hauke Dannemann, Margaret Haderer et al.•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2024

  • Kaleidoscopic integration

    Open Access•Lea Lösch, Wendy Willems et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2023

  • The Action Research Planner

    Open Access•Stephen Kemmi, Stephen Kemmis et al.•The Action Research Planner•2014

  • Urban Transition Labs

    Open Access•Frank Nevens, Niki Frantzeskaki et al.•Journal of Cleaner Production•2013

  • Adaptive Comanagement for Building Resilience in Social?Ecological Systems

    Open Access•Per Olsson, Carl Folke et al.•Environmental Management•2004

  • Impacts of urban living labs on sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Timo Von Wirth, Lea Fuenfschilling et al.•European Planning Studies•2019

  • Experiments and evidence in sustainability science

    Open Access•Guido Caniglia, N Schäpke et al.•Journal of Cleaner Production•2017

  • Sustainability Transitions Research

    Open Access•Derk Loorbach, Derk A Loorbach et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2017

  • Urban living labs for sustainability and low carbon cities in Europe

    Open Access•Yuliya Voytenko Palgan, K Mccormick et al.•Journal of Cleaner Production•2016

  • Learning through evaluation – A tentative evaluative scheme for sustainability transition experiments

    Open Access•Christopher Luederitz, N Schäpke et al.•Journal of Cleaner Production•2017

  • The Experimental Turn in Environmental Sociology

    Christine Overdevest, Alena Bleicher et al.•Environmental Sociology•2010

  • Transdisziplinär und transformativ forschen

    Open Access•Rico Defila, Antonietta Di Giulio•Transdisziplinär und transformativ…•2018

  • Transdisziplinär und transformativ forschen, Band 2

    Open Access•Rico Defila, Antonietta Di Giulio•Transdisziplinär und transformativ…•2019

  • Wissenschaftssoziologie

    P Weingart•Wissenschaftssoziologie•2003

  • Exploring the Potential of Developmental Work Research and Change Laboratory to Support Sustainability Transformations

    Mutizwa Mukute, Kuda Mudokwani et al.•Mind Culture and Activity•2018

  • Empfehlungen für die Förderung und Weiterentwicklung von Reallaboren

    Open Access•Oliver Parodi, Astrid Ley et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • How Much of the Real-World Laboratory Is Hidden in Current Transdisciplinary Research

    Open Access•Sebastian Rogga, Jana Zscheischler et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Urban BaWü-Labs

    Open Access•N Schäpke, Franziska Stelzer et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2017

  • Transdisziplinäre Forschung in Reallaboren

    Martina Ukowitz•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2017

  • Insights into and Recommendations from Three Real-World Laboratories

    Open Access•Oliver Parodi, Colette Waitz et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • What Is It Good For? Reflecting and Systematizing Accompanying Research to Research Programs

    Open Access•Rico Defila, Antonietta Di Giulio•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Reallabore zwischen Beliebtheit und Beliebigkeit

    Felix Mathias Wagner, Felix Wagner et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2019

  • Reallabore

    Open Access•Beate Zimpelmann•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Jointly Experimenting for Transformation? Shaping Real-World Laboratories by Comparing Them

    Open Access•N Schäpke, Franziska Stelzer et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Learning in Real-World Laboratories

    Open Access•Mandy Singer-Brodowski, Richard Beecroft et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Reallabore im Kontext transdisziplinärer Forschung

    Open Access•Thomas Jahn, Florian Keil•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2016

  • BaWü-labs on Their Way

    Felix Wagner, N Schäpke et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2016

  • Designing Real-World Laboratories for the Reduction of Residential Energy Use

    Open Access•Eva Heiskanen, Senja Laakso et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Von der Programmatik zur Praxis

    Open Access•Melanie Jaeger‐Erben, Emilia Nagy et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2018

  • Beyond projects

    Open Access•Thomas Weith, Sebastian Rogga et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2019

  • Transdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Thomas Jahn, Matthias Bergmann et al.•Ecological Economics•2012

  • Ten essentials for action-oriented and second order energy transitions, transformations and climate change research

    Open Access•I Fazey, N Schäpke et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • Transformative spaces in the making

    Open Access•Laura Pereira, Niki Frantzeskaki et al.•Sustainability Science•2019

  • The success of transdisciplinary research for sustainable land use

    Open Access•Jana Zscheischler, Sebastian Rogga et al.•Sustainability Science•2018

  • Transdisciplinary research in sustainability science

    Open Access•Daniel J Lang, Arnim Wiek et al.•Sustainability Science•2012

  • Learning for change

    Open Access•Matthias Barth, Gerd Michelsen•Sustainability Science•2012

  • Opening up knowledge systems for better responses to global environmental change

    Open Access•Cornell, Frans Berkhout et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2013

  • Societal effects of transdisciplinary sustainability research—How can they be strengthened during the research process

    Open Access•Alexandra Lux, Martina Schäfer et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2019

  • Linking modes of research to their scientific and societal outcomes. Evidence from 81 sustainability-oriented research projects

    Open Access•Jens Newig, Stephanie Jahn et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2019

  • Prospects for transdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Julie Thompson Klein•Futures•2004

  • Transition versus transformation

    Open Access•Katharina Hölscher, Julia M Wittmayer et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2018

  • An agenda for sustainability transitions research

    Open Access•Jonathan Köhler, Frank W Geels et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2019

  • What is Social Learning

    Open Access•Myer S Reed, Mark S Reed et al.•Conservation Ecology•2010

  • Social Learning through Participatory Integrated Catchment Risk Assessment in the Solomon Islands

    Open Access•Suzanne Hoverman, Helen Ro et al.•Conservation Ecology•2011

  • The Politics of Reflexive Governance

    Open Access•Jan-Peter Voß, Basil Bornemann•Conservation Ecology•2011

  • Promoting agency for social-ecological transformation

    Open Access•Lakshmi Charli-Joseph, J Mario Siqueiros-Garcia et al.•Conservation Ecology•2018

Unique citing works84
Citations per year16,8
Citation span2021 - 2026 (6)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 82

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae