Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Creating an academic landscape of sustainability science

An analysis of the citation network

Bibliographic Data

ID12950801
AuthorsYuya Kajikawa (0000-0003-3577-5167, The University of Tokyo, corresponding author), Junko Ohno (The University of Tokyo), Yoshiyuki Takeda (The University of Tokyo), Katsumori Matsushima (The University of Tokyo), Hiroshi Komiyama (The University of Tokyo)
Year2007
Volume2
Issue2
Publication date2007-07-07
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSustainability Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1862-4057 • E-ISSN: 1862-4065
PublisherSpringer Science+Business Media (PUBLISHER • DE)
DOI10.1007/s11625-007-0027-8
OpenAlexW2021379602
LanguageEN
Citations received56
References cited29

Sustainability is an important concept for society, economics, and the environment, with thousands of research papers published on the subject annually. As sustainability science becomes a distinctive research field, it is important to define sustainability clearly and grasp the entire structure, current status, and future directions of sustainability science. This paper provides an academic landscape of sustainability science by analyzing the citation network of papers published in academic journals. A topological clustering method is used to detect the sub-domains of sustainability science. Results show the existence of 15 main research clusters: Agriculture, Fisheries, Ecological Economics, Forestry (agroforestry), Forestry (tropical rain forest), Business, Tourism, Water, Forestry (biodiversity), Urban Planning, Rural Sociology, Energy, Health, Soil, and Wildlife. Agriculture, Fisheries, Ecological Economics, and Forestry (agroforestry) clusters are predominant among these. The Energy cluster is currently developing, as indicated by the age of papers in the cluster, although it has a relatively small number of papers. These results are compared with those obtained by natural language processing. Education, Biotechnology, Medical, Livestock, Climate Change, Welfare, and Livelihood clusters are uniquely extracted by natural language processing, because they are common topics across clusters in the citation network

Agriculture · Citation · Economics · Environmental resource management · Geography · Landscape ecology · Livelihood · Political science · Sustainability · Sustainability organizations · Sustainability science · Complex Network Analysis Techniques · Energy, Environment, Economic Growth · Environmental Education and Sustainability · Ecology

  • Defining Terms for Integrated (Multi-Inter-Trans-Disciplinary) Sustainability Research

    Open Access•Paul V Stock, Paul Stock et al.•Sustainability•2011

  • The Evolution of Sustainable Development Theory

    Open Access•Longyu Shi, Linwei Han et al.•Sustainability•2019

  • Sustainability science

    Open Access•Joachim H Spangenberg•Environmental Conservation•2011

  • Evolution and structure of sustainability science

    Open Access•Luís M A Bettencourt, Luís Bettencourt et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2011

  • Reasons and Policies for Migration in India

    Open Access•Sachi Rana, Shivani Lohia•ShodhKosh: Journal of Visual and…•2024

  • Are there literature reviews about gamification to foster Inclusive Teaching? A scoping review of gamification literature reviews

    Open Access•Santiago Ruiz-Navas, Pajaree Ackaradejraungsri et al.•Frontiers in Education•2024

  • Mapping the role of animal welfare in tourism

    Nadja Schweiggart•Journal of Ecotourism•2024

  • Climateonomics

    Open Access•Neha Seth, Kirti Jain•The Journal of Environment &…•2025

  • Mapping the technology evolution path

    Open Access•Huailan Liu, Zhiwang Chen et al.•Scientometrics•2020

  • Reframing evidence in evidence-based policy making and role of bibliometrics

    Open Access•Yuya Kajikawa•Scientometrics•2022

  • Scenario structuring methodology for computer-aided scenario design

    Open Access•Yusuke Kishita, Yuji Mizuno et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2020

  • Mapping and impact assessment of phenomenon-oriented research fields

    Open Access•Liane Rothenberger, Muhammad Qasim Pasta et al.•Quantitative Science Studies•2021

  • Pedagogy for Sustainability Science

    Leah Sprain, William M Timpson•Environmental Communication•2012

  • Mapping pathways to public understanding of climate science

    Open Access•Chelsea Canon, Douglas P Boyle et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2022

  • A modeling framework for comparative evaluation of municipal sludge treatment technologies

    Open Access•Jiayuan Ji, Akinori Shimizu et al.•Journal of Industrial Ecology•2026

  • Distributed Cogeneration of Power and Heat within an Energy Management Strategy for Mitigating Fossil Fuel Consumption

    Open Access•Yasunori Kikuchi, Yuichiro Kanematsu et al.•Journal of Industrial Ecology•2016

  • Coding communications across time

    Open Access•Kar-Hai Chu, Stephanie Pitt et al.•Network Science•2017

  • Mapping the evolving research landscape of sustainability science from 2006 to 2023

    Open Access•Mesfin Sahle, Shruti Ashish Lahoti et al.•Sustainability Science•2024

  • Establishing sustainability science in higher education institutions

    Open Access•Masaru Yarime, G Trencher et al.•Sustainability Science•2012

  • Learning for change

    Open Access•Matthias Barth, Gerd Michelsen•Sustainability Science•2012

  • How interdisciplinary is sustainability research? Analyzing the structure of an emerging scientific field

    Open Access•Ethan D Schoolman, Jeremy S Guest et al.•Sustainability Science•2011

  • New directions in sustainability science

    Open Access•Joanne Kauffman, Salvatore Arico•Sustainability Science•2014

  • Shedding light on a neglected area

    Open Access•Hiroko Nakamura, Shingo Shingo et al.•Sustainability Science•2013

  • Towards institutional analysis of sustainability science

    Open Access•Masaru Yarime, Yoshiyuki Takeda et al.•Sustainability Science•2009

  • Sustainability science

    Open Access•Yuya Kajikawa, Francisco Tacoa et al.•Sustainability Science•2014

  • Constructing sustainability science

    Open Access•Thomas R Miller•Sustainability Science•2012

  • Growing up

    Open Access•Kazuhiko Takeuchi, Osamu Saito et al.•Sustainability Science•2017

  • Facilitating data-intensive approaches to innovation for sustainability

    Open Access•Masaru Yarime•Sustainability Science•2017

  • Identification and analysis of the highly cited knowledge base of sustainability science

    Open Access•R K Buter, Anthony F J van Raan•Sustainability Science•2012

  • A mapping of global warming research based on IPCC AR4

    Open Access•Ai Hiramatsu, Nobuo Mimura et al.•Sustainability Science•2008

  • A bibliometric analysis of climate engineering research

    Open Access•Chris Belter, Dian J Seidel•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2013

  • The Psychology of Men and Masculinities

    Mike C Parent, Tyler C Bradstreet et al.•Psychology of Men & Masculinity•2017

  • The reflexive process in sustainability science

    Open Access•Julien Vanhulst, Patricio Padilla-Navarro et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2025

  • Global trends in business tourism research

    Open Access•Víctor Hernández-Andrés, Pablo de Frutos Madrazo et al.•Turyzm/Tourism•2025

  • An integrated framework for resilience research

    Open Access•Li Xu, Yuya Kajikawa•Sustainability Science•2018

  • Knowledge for sustainable development

    Open Access•Maarten Van Opstal, Jean Hugé•Environment Development and…•2012

  • Rural Tourism in the Context of Climate Change

    Open Access•C T Phan, Cao‐Nguyen Phan et al.•Sustainable Development•2026

  • Bridging barriers in sustainability research

    Open Access•Katerina Troullaki, Stelios Rozakis et al.•Ecological Economics•2021

  • The agrifood system policy agenda and research domain

    Open Access•Jill K Clark, Jeff S Sharp et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2015

  • The Strategic Environment Assessment bibliographic network

    Simone Caschili, Andrea De Montis et al.•Environmental Impact Assessment…•2014

  • Sustainability

    Open Access•Nuno Quental, Júlia Lourenço et al.•Environment Development and…•2011

  • Environmental sustainability and corporate social responsibility of business schools

    Open Access•Saša Petković, Nikša Alfirević et al.•Economic Research-Ekonomska…•2022

  • Le paysage intellectuel du développement durable en Amérique latine. Une analyse de réseau à partir des citations d’auteurs latino-américains

    Open Access•Julien Vanhulst, Edwin Zaccaï•Natures Sciences Sociétés•2019

  • Citation network analysis for supporting continuous improvement in Higher Education

    Claudia Colicchia, Alessandro Creazza et al.•Studies in Higher Education•2018

  • The environment in global health governance

    Open Access•Mylan Evrard, Alicia Rieckhoff et al.•The Lancet Planetary Health•2025

  • Principles for a sustainable circular economy

    Open Access•A P M Velenturf, Phil Purnell•Sustainable Production and…•2021

  • Mapping research activities and technologies for sustainability and environmental studies—a case study at university level

    Open Access•Keishiro Hara, Michinori Uwasu et al.•Journal of Environmental Studies…•2012

  • Mapping migration studies

    Open Access•Asya Pisarevskaya, Nathan Levy et al.•Migration Studies•2019

  • From basic research to applied solutions

    Open Access•Elizabeth M B Doran, Jay S Golden et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2017

  • The sustainability publication gap and its implications

    Open Access•Osvaldo E Sala, Christopher G Boone et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2019

  • A discourse-analytical perspective on sustainability assessment

    Open Access•Jean Hugé, Tom Waas et al.•Sustainability Science•2012

  • Research core and framework of sustainability science

    Open Access•Yuya Kajikawa•Sustainability Science•2008

  • Providing sound theoretical roots to sustainability science

    Open Access•Lucio Biggiero•Sustainability Science•2018

  • Academic landscape of 10 years of sustainability science

    Open Access•Yuya Kajikawa, Osamu Saito et al.•Sustainability Science•2017

  • Rural-urban studies

    Open Access•Gideon Baffoe•Habitat International•2020

  • Exploring Sixty-Two Years of Research on Immigrants' Integration Using Structural Topic Modeling-Based Bibliometric Analysis

    Open Access•Robert Djogbenou, Vissého Adjiwanou et al.•Journal of International…•2024

  • Fast algorithm for detecting community structure in networks

    Open Access•M E J Newman•Physical Review E•2004

  • Visualizing knowledge domains

    Open Access•Katy Börner, Chaomei Chen et al.•Annual Review of Information…•2003

  • The Concept of Environmental Sustainability

    Robert Goodland•Annual Review of Ecology and…•1995

  • The Report of the Ecological Society of America Committee on the Scientific Basis for Ecosystem Management

    Open Access•Norman L Christensen, Ann M Bartuska et al.•Ecological Applications•1996

  • Mapping the backbone of science

    Open Access•Kevin W Boyack, Richard Klavans et al.•Scientometrics•2005

  • Global sustainability

    Open Access•Rebecca J Brown, Becky J Brown et al.•Environmental Management•1987

  • The Concept of Sustainable Economic Development

    Open Access•E B Barbier•Environmental Conservation•1987

  • Finding and evaluating community structure in networks

    Open Access•M E J Newman, Martha G Newman et al.•Physical Review E•2004

  • A vector space model for automatic indexing

    Open Access•Gerard Salton, Anita M-y Wong et al.•Communications of the ACM•1975

  • Sustainability Science

    Open Access•Robert W Kates, William C Clark et al.•Science•2001

  • An application and e aluation of the C/NC-value approach for the automatic term recognition of multi-word units in Japanese

    Hideki Mima, Sophia Ananiadou•Terminology International Journal…•2000

  • Influential publications in ecological economics

    Open Access•R Costanza, David I Stern et al.•Ecological Economics•2004

  • Sustainable development

    Open Access•Sharachchandra Madhukar Lele•World Development•1991

  • Sustainability science

    Open Access•Hiroshi Komiyama, Kazuhiko Takeuchi•Sustainability Science•2006

  • Sustainability is not enough

    Open Access•Peter Marcuse•Environment and Urbanization•1998

  • Environmental and ecological economics

    Open Access•Chunbo Ma, David I Stern•Ecological Economics•2005

  • The meaning of sustainable development

    Open Access•Michael Redclift•Geoforum•1992

Unique citing works56
Citations per year3,11
Citation span2008 - 2026 (19)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 56

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae